Summary Of Why The Perps Get Off Easy By Yotam Feldner

Improved Essays
In Yotam Feldner’s article “Honor” Murders- Why the Perps Get Off Easy he brings up the ongoing controversy of “honor murders” among the Muslim community in Jordan and other countries. In his article he covers the different circumstances of honor killings in the Muslim state and how they are treated socially, legally and religiously. He first provides us with the Muslim form of honor called ‘ird that represents a family as a whole. ‘Ird is a form of honor that the females of the family contain and can only be decreased in value. A woman negatively affects her family’s ‘ird when she is caught or suspected of committing adultery. In this article, Yotam Feldner depicts to the reader of why honor killings occur in the Muslim state. In …show more content…
Dever’s and Sarah Bacon’s article Interpreting Honor Crimes: The Institutional Disregard Towards Female Victims of Family Violence in the Middle East they speak to how woman is not equally treated in the laws relating to honor killing in the Islam community. This article speaks to how woman are constantly under the threat of being harmed with honor related violence that is not rightfully judged by society due to the lenient punishments men receive, gender biased laws and the social acceptance of killings among the Islamic society. The authors of this text provide the viewer with their opinion of how Islamic societies are unfairly biased to males in honor killings. Men are able to receive mitigated punishments or no punishments at all when they commit an honor killing. This is due to the high power of men in government to make laws that make honor killings legal but not explicitly justified. The authors claim that the only way to create social change is to present factual evidence of the gender discrimination to the …show more content…
363) This quote deals with the fact that males are able to get out of honor killings by sating they were defending their honor. Muslim’s believe that when a female relative commits adultery she ruins the reputation of all relatives and therefore killing her would defend their reputation.

“women who violate these norms are considered a threat the community by fact that they are antisocial or deviant to social mores and norms. At the macro level, because there is a lack of punishment by the state, men receive lenient punishment because this type of crime is seen as traditional, cultural and familial, rather than an issue of law.” (pg. 369) Dever and Bacon state of why the state is allowing these cases of honor violence to continue due to the social norms created by the Islam community. Due to the fact honor killings are not initially dealt with through law, the state enables men to enact on a honor killing if they have a rightful cause. The laws are setup in order to protect the cultural rules of Islam rather than to defend a human’s

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Iftikhar(2016) reported Imam Zaid Shakir who said that in Islam there is nothing called honor killing and killing blameless women just because they did not follow their parents’ wishes is like cold-blooded murder and “ there is no legitimate Islamic religious authority who can argue”. Actually, all religions oppose honor killing, and some people are using the term “Islam “ in order to justify honor killing even though there is no support of it in Islam. So, people are creating and reflecting bad pictures about their religions, especially Islam, through their horrible acts. Moreover, if Allah tolerates people who did wrong things and sins, then who are we in order not to tolerate others and kill them? Actually, if a girl dishonored her family, it is a sin, but killing her is a larger…

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author of this article wants us as American 's to understand the "cry for help" that America needs. This world is falling apart because of everybody 's ignorance. These three heartless attacks on Muslim women was an unnecessary act, which could 've resulted in death. Religion and ethnicity is portrayed in a negative way in which being Muslim is not accepted and believing in what you have the right to believe in is not acceptable. The dominant factor behind these crimes were because these girls were Muslims.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Additionally, the narrative talks about “women who were killing themselves out of fear of being raped, and of men who, in the name of honor, would kill their wives or daughters if they’d been raped by the militia” (Hosseini, page 247). Whilst this excerpt is a prime example of how women were persecuted, it also holds a negative stereotype. The aforementioned excerpt could be misconstrued as a thought that “honour-killings” are permitted in Islam, which they strictly are not (QuestionsaboutIslam, 2017). Moreover, Hosseini doesn’t clearly state his thoughts on Islam, as he provides good and bad scenarios in support of Islam. Therefore, it is hard to understand if he is for or against the…

    • 1075 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The movie When We Leave takes places in turkey and focuses on a major conflict within the Muslim community. The major conflict within the Muslim community that the movie focuses on is honor crimes and honor killings. Honor killings are used by a family when a family member commits an action that negatively affects the honor of the family. In most cases it has to due with a female committing adultery with another man while they are unmarried. In this movie it depicts a situation where the main character, Umay, leaves her abusive husband to flea back home to her family.…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article Breaking the Web of Abuse, and Silence Voices of Battered Women in Japan by M. Yoshihara discuss male partner use of violence to control their spouse in different ways rather than physical and sexual violence, despite cultural influences all battered women at a point are degrade on their individual roles as women. They at times are displaced in society through various forms of emotional and verbal abuse for example being told you’re a horrible mother. She describes partners violence begins tightening a web in which women see a slim chance to escape and can…

    • 1306 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The reason for this appears to be that because on many occasions in such situations women’s reaction to violence or threat of violence is not immediate the killing is described as cold-blooded revenge killing. It appears that the law does not tend to recognise the plight of battered women because it may blur the lines between renege killing and killing when provoked. However, following the argument put forth in relation to discovery of sexual infidelity it can be said that such men kill due to revenge for their spouse or partner having cheating on them too. Furthermore, if the argument that women ought to have left their abuser as put forth by Lord Dunpark can be said to be correct, should a man not to have been expected to have left their partner or wife upon the discovery of sexual…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Honor killings include actual or imagined adultery or premarital sex. In comparison to Hester, who was condemn for adultery, both were women who committed the crime of extracurricular relations. “’I killed my daughter because she insulted all of our family by marrying a man without our consent, and I have no regret over it.’ Police investigator Rana Majahid quoted him as saying.” (“Pregnant Pakistan Woman Stoned to Death by Her Family” 1) The male relatives of Farzana Parveen, the murder victim, deny any guilt associated with the “honor killing”. Similar to The Scarlet Letter, the women both brought shame among their associates. Living in such a religiously bias community, a private human rights association reported 869 women in 2013 were victims of honor killings, including Sakineh Mohammadi Ashtiani.…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Any type of relationship with a man that is not a woman’s husband is not moral (Patel and Gadit 685). What constitutes dishonor to families can be: “pregnancy out of wedlock, sexual misconduct, and marriage outside family approval” (Patel and Gadit 686). People commit honor killings because of other broader reasons. For example, women who demand divorces from their husbands, but cannot do so “elicit a karo-kari attack under a false pretext” (686). In poorer areas, when women become financial burdens, families use karo-kari as a way to gain wealth or inheritance from the victim.…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wrights did something wrong that doesn 't run through a persons mind on a daily basis. Wrights believed that she was feeling lonely once she married her husband so she believed to kill him because of her feelings. The main idea of Wrights perception in “A Jury of Her Peers” is she is aware of wanting to kill her husband. In the article, “Trends in Crime: Does Perception Match Reality?” Savi stated, “Many factors contribute to our perceptions of crime. News stories, types of crime committed, location of crime—these elements and others help to shape the way we perceive the safety of our communities.” The quote explains the characters perception because it was proven that the form of perception can be a crime.…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    To begin with, a significant issue that these women face is having the opportunity to report the violence and abuse. Police stations in Yemen are male- staffed and it is culturally unacceptable for a woman to enter a police station and report the abuse unless accompanied by a male family member (Ba-Obaid and Bijeveld, 2007). This issue can become even more challenging when the male family member is the abuser. In this case, reporting the abuse might be impossible. Furthermore, since violence is included in the social norms of the Yemeni culture, women are brainwashed and perceive violence to be normal.…

    • 1110 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays