Martha Nussbaum Women And Cultural Universals Analysis

Decent Essays
Martha Nussbaum is an American philosopher who published “Women and Cultural Universals”. Focusing on specifically page twenty-nine through thirty-four and then pages thirty-nine through forty-three paragraph one from “Women and Cultural Universals” Then, comparing Karl Marx to Nussbaum’s capabilities theory. Karl Marx’s critique is consistent with Nussbaum’s capabilities theory, while solutions that Nussbaum proposes are also consistent with the solutions and alternatives Marx offers. Nussbaum creates a list of capabilities that are fundamental abilities that should be open to both men and women. It is up to each individual to decide whether to act upon them, how they act upon them, and to what extent they act upon them. Karl Marx, believed …show more content…
“For we do not want politics to take mere survival as its goal; we want to describe a life in which dignity of the human being is not violated by hunger or fear or the absence of opportunity” (40). Nussbaum compares this statement directly to Karl Marx’s idea. This relates to Marx when he used an Aristotelian notion of function to describe the difference between animal use of things and the human use. Nussbaum’s Central Human Functional Capabilities should be possessed by every citizen, no matter what they have or decide to pursue in their lifetime. The Central Human Functional Capabilities includes the following: life, bodily health and integrity, bodily integrity, senses, imagination, thought, emotions, practical reason, affiliation, other species, play, and control over one’s environment. Nussbaum believes that if any human life is lacking any one of these capabilities, they are falling short of a fully good human …show more content…
Each of their solutions and alternatives also are consistent. Martha Nussbaum see that women are struggling all around the world in every culture and tradition. Even in some of these cultures the women see that the way that they are treated is right and natural because it has been going on for so long. Women are seen as property, women are seen as the lower class when compared to men. They are oppressed in so many different ways. Nussbaum’s capabilities theory was created to show the solution to women being oppressed and a way to make sure every human knows what their fundamental capabilities are in order to live a fully happy life. Nussbaum believes that every human has the right to life, health, integrity, imagination, thought, emotions, practical reason, affiliation, and other species. No human should be denied any of these capabilities. Karl Marx also believed that humans should not be oppressed by the government or other individuals and provides solutions to eliminate social classes and private property so that another human is not above just because of the things that they own. Nussbaum and Marx provide humans with a way to try and attempt to get rid of the inequality in our current

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the article, “On the Gender of the Middlebrow Consumer and the Threat of the Culturally Fraudulent Female”, Radway scrutinizes and manipulates magazine articles from primary sources in the nineteen thirties era. Although, she analyzes feminist readings that are predominately written by males; who also express a general concern for the rapid changes that were happening within the time period. Radway specifically uses primary text written within the time period to scrutinize the authors themselves. In addition, Radway establishes that the primary texts were written by experts, mainly those who positioned themselves as becoming known as an expert, as she would call them the; highbrow, high class experts. She introduces the idea that there is…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this piece, Marx discusses the concept of “Estranged Labour”, about which he goes into great detail. He begins by stating that the current political economy takes the worker from the level of a human, to that of a commodity. He describes this as “the most wretched of commodities”, as the commodification of the worker is always done in contrast to success of the land owner. This creates two classes, the property owners and the propertyless workers, with a stark distinction between the two. The political economy that creates this distinction is run by greed, which is fueled by competition.…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On January 18, 2015, Brock Allen Turner sexually assaulted a young 22 year old woman behind a dumpster. Turner, a former Stanford swimmer, was chased down after completing sexual penetration with said unconscious young woman by two Swedish students. The swimmer was eventually tackled and the authorities were called. Turner claims his acts were completed with full permission from the young woman, whom for confidentiality reasons will be called Sarah. Sarah was taken to a country hospital and treated for abrasions Turner had given her.…

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Charlotte Perkins Gilman argues about the fragility of women within the pecuniary sphere and how the economic standing for all people is defined and controlled by men. According to Gilman, human females are the only ones directly attached and solely dependent on men unlike other female species. In ‘Women and Economics,’ she examines the traditional roles of women and how this limited view prevents them from obtaining any economic dependence or identity outside of their husbands. Women do not “produce or distribute wealth,” which she finds highly problematic and cause for social and economic reform.…

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the 1900s thousands of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children were dispossessed and put into missions. The act of dispossession is to forcibly remove an Indigenous person from their land, this is what happened to these children, but not only were they removed from their land, but also their families. This was extremely harmful to the children as although they gained a higher education than many other Indigenous people they missed out on learning about their cultural heritage, which is a fundamental part of Indigenous identity. Claire Henty-Gebert’s social and cultural identities have been negatively affected through the removal of her from her family and the moving around she had to do as she grew up in the mission she was placed…

    • 1272 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the eighteen century woman did not have the same rights and privileges as men. The right to vote was not allowed. Education and occupation opportunities were scarce. After marriage women had to give control of their property to the husband. A woman place was in the home caring for the children and tending to domestic affairs.…

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Mill’s On Liberty and Marx’s The Communist Manifesto are both political works about how they believe the government should be run in which they both believe that the people should not be oppressed by the government or other people. However, both differ in their opinions of what type of form a government should be; Mill believes that the government should take on the form of liberalism where it plays a limited role on society that emphasizes on individual freedom and freedom from tyranny of the majority. Marx on the other hand, believes that communism is an ideal form for a government where it will emphasize equality for the people that will eliminate exploitation among one group of people over another. While Mill believes human nature is detached…

    • 1913 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the Communist Manifesto, Karl Marx attempts to educate the general public on the communist agenda that emerged in the 19th century. He proposes an arguably attractive explanation to the timeless class struggle in human history, explaining that the laboring proletariat class will eventually rise to political power and eliminate future class division and oppression through the seizure of property ownership. In essence, Marx favors the concept of the unity of the whole, whereas John Stuart Mill in On Liberty argues for the value of the individual and their liberties of thought, discussion, and action. In this essay I will defend Mill in justifying the utilitarian favorability of individuality and liberty rights, because prioritizing communal…

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Human Nature Human beings have the capability of being quite despicable in situations involving monetary gain, power, or control. This is often associated with individuals in government or those of higher social status. In order to diminish such control over other individuals of less social or political power, Karl Marx and John Stuart Mill proposed their own stance on the influence government should have. Both individuals differ in their belief of individuality, liberty, freedom and self cultivation as forms that best define our human nature. Marx and Mill also differ in how such ideas are to be carried out.…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Women Across Cultures

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages

    throughout history men have been in control of many things in this world. Views on women as less fit for taking care of certain task and it didn't make a difference in the event that she had some foundation or a smidgen of education. Society has looked upon men and seen men as the provider and there was not other way of looking at them. Women must be in the house doing what "women were useful for" that was to fulfill the men's needs and take care of the kids. Throughout the day women were assume to stay home and tend to their young one and cook meals for them.…

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction Western modern day culture for women, particularly women born in United States (US), experience major differences in life, liberty and freedom compared to women born and raised in foreign countries; such as China, Nigeria and India to name a few. This paper is written to help readers understand and to educate the existence of vast cultural differences among foreign women in context of seeking justice. The content of this paper focuses on information only. It is not for the purposes of judging other cultures way of life or for being neither right nor wrong.…

    • 862 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Susan Okin is a feminist philosopher and the author of Is Multiculturalism Bad for Women. Okin’s condemnation of immigrant multiculturalism conveys an extreme form of liberal intolerance shared by liberal feminists alike. Despite raising some valid issues of inequality amongst immigrant societies, Okin’s argument is based on the worst of immigrant culture constructing a misleading narrative about multiculturalism. Here I will analyse Is Multiculturalism Bad for Women to support my argument that Okin’s portrayal of immigrant cultural is in essence liberal intolerance and that the issue faced by women within immigrant cultures is not that of a cultural issue but an issue of cruelty and inequality. Liberal feminism supports the notion that a strong connection is present between culture and gender which unfavourably positions immigrant women within society.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “The first American women were Native American women” (Brown). This notion is often forgotten, even as early as the first European conquest of American lands. The invasion of the Europeans on the western end of the globe forever altered the original traditions of natives to the land. Bringing their religious culture across the sea, Europeans struggled to understand the way of life of the Native Americans, and resorted to view them as “savages” and inferior people. In particular, compared to European females, the American Indian women were tremendously different from the uniform in various aspects of life such as marriage and work.…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Going back into ancient times, a woman’s role in society was always centered in the household. Tending to the children, keeping the house clean, making dinner for her husband and children, etc. were typical roles. It was not until the passing of the 19th Amendment that women were given their rights and their voice was heard. Women should not have been abused and tortured in the early 1900’s…

    • 1760 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. Mill and Marx both argue that women are oppressed in modern society. How are their understandings of this oppression similar/different? Mill’s and Marx’s understanding of female oppression by the society is more different than similar.…

    • 1489 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays