Noted by Smiley, “being honest about Huckleberry Finn goes right to the heart to whether we can be honest about our heritage and identity as Americans.” By employing hypophora, Smiley emphasizes the initial purpose of reading works from a non-contemporary setting. After asking “Why are we reading a Shakespeare play or Huckleberry Finn,” the author answers with “because these works are great, but they also tell us something about the times in which they were created.” The part after the word “but” is important since it explains the reason of the negative effects that can be brought by changing sensitive words that are viewed as unacceptable in the book. Noted by Smiley, these words carry feelings, emotions, and history contexts in them that accurately describe the issues that were happening in the era when the book was written and being honest about these words can help the students to immerse themselves in the setting from which the words were created, which was emphasized in the last part of Smiley’s answer to the question. Overall, the article is compelling since the author uses evidences to reinforce his primary argument. For example, in order to convince the reader that changing words have unintended effects on the audience’s evaluation of the work, the author illustrates that the word “‘slavery’ doesn’t carry the same shock value, and so it toned down what Twain is getting at.’” Another example would be when the Smiley states that the values hidden in the book covered with a “comic veneer” are “transient,” which provides a reason for the action of the publisher to modify words that they view inappropriate. More importantly, these examples also
Noted by Smiley, “being honest about Huckleberry Finn goes right to the heart to whether we can be honest about our heritage and identity as Americans.” By employing hypophora, Smiley emphasizes the initial purpose of reading works from a non-contemporary setting. After asking “Why are we reading a Shakespeare play or Huckleberry Finn,” the author answers with “because these works are great, but they also tell us something about the times in which they were created.” The part after the word “but” is important since it explains the reason of the negative effects that can be brought by changing sensitive words that are viewed as unacceptable in the book. Noted by Smiley, these words carry feelings, emotions, and history contexts in them that accurately describe the issues that were happening in the era when the book was written and being honest about these words can help the students to immerse themselves in the setting from which the words were created, which was emphasized in the last part of Smiley’s answer to the question. Overall, the article is compelling since the author uses evidences to reinforce his primary argument. For example, in order to convince the reader that changing words have unintended effects on the audience’s evaluation of the work, the author illustrates that the word “‘slavery’ doesn’t carry the same shock value, and so it toned down what Twain is getting at.’” Another example would be when the Smiley states that the values hidden in the book covered with a “comic veneer” are “transient,” which provides a reason for the action of the publisher to modify words that they view inappropriate. More importantly, these examples also