Volkswagen Failure Essay

Improved Essays
Corporate Failure Analysis of Volkswagen

This article will analyze the Volkswagen case in the viewpoint of corporate governance. As the scandal

came up to the scene, Volkswagen defrauded in emission tests and make the improper cars pass from

the tests in the “normal mode” rather than the “best case” scenario which also is not suitable for US

emission standards. As a result, 11million cars were recalled, VW lost 20 billion dollars and especially 80

years of good reputation of the brand is suddenly collapsed. 1

This reputational loss is a big issue on which means the cost of excluding from the industry and be the

one who doesn’t want to be traded with. This requires some down actions to the company like

decreasing the prices,
…show more content…
But the reality of the

numbers is opposite to these explanations since a very huge number of cars were delivered for 7 years.

Company is claiming that senior management couldn’t recognize the 7-year period of corruption which

seems not possible. The situation seems like a “passive management”.

According to the many C-level or board member sayings that it is true that corporates in Germany

generally have corporate governance problems. Germany corporate governance problem is an globally

known term which is called as “co-determination”. Co-determination is a governance method which

means representatives of workforce must have place in the supervisory board and also their votes are

counted as twice in case of conflict. 2 The aim of codetermination is minimizing labor tension by the

power of representation on the board but in many years, experts claiming that this method is decreasing

the company’s productivity in case of unbalanced distribution of votes. This makes an environment

which creates many problems in case of supervisory board make a mistake. As a more brief explanation,

Germany governance model formed by dual board structure. This integrated board does not
…show more content…
After

experiencing the less effective nature of crowded decision-making meetings, co-determined companies

found a way to two-layered discussions meetings of which labor-representatives firstly discussed the

issue among themselves and then came to the supervisory board.

As an overall summary, dominant shareholder percentage of Porsche and Piech families comes to the

stage with a big and powerful conflict of interest. Other than this, governmental share is the major part

of the organization. And lastly, co-determination method of governance totally pressured the labor

representation power which at the end leads the company to the single-way viewpoint dominance.

One of the most important lesson in the VW case is keeping the “conflict of interest between managers

and shareholders” and “corporate governance issues” separate is crucial. And one of the key weakness

at the company is the lack of diversity of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Tesla Motors Failure

    • 985 Words
    • 4 Pages

    largest competition comes from U.S. automakers like General Motors (GM), Chrysler, and Ford. The problem is U.S. manufacturers pay a higher cost to manufacture their brands, wherein foreign markets have a lower cost. Also, U.S. automakers are constantly subject to government regulations, union negotiations, and having to decrease their labor forces; which placed each one in a vulnerable position. Despite the fact, a government "bail-out" called Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP) was put into order, giants like Ford did not accept it. Instead this automaker capitalized off its assets during the recession.…

    • 985 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Volkswagen Pollution Essay

    • 1509 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Safety is the number 1 focus for anyone with this scandal, Volkswagen’s president stepped down, they were fined millions of dollars for cheating their test, Losing their top sales spot to Toyota. With more pollution being made, this can cause major health problems down the road and causes the climate to change. Since the scandals, Top car companies like Honda, GMC, Ford have all called back cars because some of their equipment was damaged or like Volkswagen, cheated the system and didn’t want to lose money and being fined along the way. Climate changed is another factor that is caused by pollution. Ever notice why it’s much hotter than last year, stronger weather, bug outbreaks or more increase of…

    • 1509 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Case Study Lambert-Martin

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages

    For optimization of focus, top managers should be allowed to hold a single docket especially if the duties and responsibilities are many. The current status of the supply chain is hurting the company as a whole because with separate reporting from each group, it is difficult to keep track of costs. More so, there is a tendency of a decentralized system to lose focus of the general direction of the company because attention will be fully on departmental targets. On his research on industrial trends, Arthur stumbled upon a document that indicated that large organizations were moving away from a decentralized system. In many ways, this shift was caused by the realization that a decentralized system has many challenges that can be resolved by centralizing certain components such as administration, procurement and manufacturing.…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Traditional Leadership Styles This paper describes the traditional and new-genre leadership models and further details the differences between transactional and transformational leadership. The Industrial Era systematically designed organizational charts separating leaders from followers, but as hierarchies are becoming less linear, new-genre leadership models are penetrating the organizational charts, making traditional styles obsolete. As leadership concepts evolve, so does the perception of followership. Research reveals the followership role is transforming into an active participant of a company and molding junior personnel into future leaders, vice the previous opinion of followership as a passive role. Traditional Versus New-genre…

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Corporations often face ethical dilemmas doing business. It could be firing a worker, making side deals, and gross negligence meaning endangering people’s lives to make a profit. There are various examples of companies and corporations seemingly choosing profits over people, this study is focused on the Ford Motor Company and their vehicle the Pinto. In 1968, Lee Iacocca president of Ford Motor Company was under the gun to develop a sub-compact car to compete with foreign car manufacturer Volkswagen (Dowie, 1977). To get the vehicle ready to sell quickly, he ordered that production chop their timetable down.…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Truck Cartel Case Study

    • 1435 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Lack of competition is bad for consumers because, as the producers do not try to innovate or to offer the best possible prices anymore, they end up paying more for less quality, and bad for the economy of countries because they cause a deadweight loss. This is the reason why the EC has made the fight of cartels one of its priority. The Truck cartel case is a good example of how the EC take actions against cartel agreements. The fines are based on the number of customers affected and the duration of the agreement. As the cartel existed for around 14 years, from 1997 to 2011, and its extend was 90% of the medium and heavy trucks produced in Europe, the members of the cartel received a record fine of around € 3…

    • 1435 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is a difficult situation for big companies because almost every aspect of manufacturing is different and the connection changes everything. Top-down decision making is based on determination goals early in process, inflexibility, lack of employee participation, lack of motivation compares to this bottom-up is based on flexibility, teamwork, projects are team driven, high level of team motivation. Also, different approach by companies in company management whereas Chrysler was less strict and make working place more self-governing what could lead to problems how it happened after merged with Daimler Benz AG. Daimler Benz management approach was more intense, precise and controlling…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Stevens, (2014) GM’s CEO, Wagoner, knew that with the failures of major lending and banking agencies and the bailouts being offered by the government, may be his only chance to save the company (Stevens, 2014). After a tedious and lengthy process, congress agreed to bailout GM. However, even with the bailout as an option, Wagoner and executive colleagues struggled to meet certain requirements of the bailout terms. It was evident as GM, a struggling corporation would require restructuring as one of the requirements before receiving the bailout government aid. Thus, Wagoner was obligated to resign as the CEO of GM and then they would be bought out by the “New General Motors Company”, giving the government control of the new automaker company.…

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Business ethics refers to a kind of social responsibility of the enterprise in the scope of morality for each level of object.Corporate social responsibility is even more significant in the automobile industry, which has huge interests. Volkswagen(VW), the world's largest automobile maker, has used "cheating" software to detect emissions in the United States as its biggest scandal in its 78-year history, facing tremendous fines and criminal investigations. Relative to gasoline vehicles, diesel exhaust often contains large amounts of nitrogen oxides. In order to meet the stringent environmental standards of the United States, in addition to installing diesel particulate filters, diesel vehicles often use urea injection to reduce toxic nitrogen…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Vw Company Case Study

    • 1113 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Since September 2015 that the EPA reported that VW were selling cars with defects in the diesel engines, lawsuits haven’t stopped coming its way. USA today recently reported that the company had taken a 20 billion loan to help covering the costs of those lawsuits, the fines and the vehicle repairs generated from the scandal. Bentley, Lamborghini and Ducati, are the most lucrative brands under the VW umbrella. VW may have no other choice than selling those brands, and use the revenues to cover settlement disputes from the scandal. b) Company Structure Reorganization Also, as a way to mark his imprint and distance himself from his predecessor, it wouldn’t be a bad idea from new CEO Matthias Muller to shake things up by reorganizing the company’s…

    • 1113 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays