Uncle Toms Cabin Commentary

Improved Essays
Here, Stowe highlights the emotional and genuine effect that religion had on slaves. Clearly, Uncle Tom cares about the passages in the Bible that ardently affect him and speak to his heart, not the political passages that can be twisted justify sinful actions. The slaves focus on the messages and themes in the Bible that calm their emotions and bring them hope and joy, and they practice religion for themselves instead of being forced to attend church because it is a tradition. Continuing on, McKay more specifically describes Stowe’s Uncle Tom’s Cabin as “a widely distributed pedagogic novel of Christian example, with Uncle Tom presented as a model – especially for children and peasants – of piety, probity, and calm strength of conviction”. …show more content…
Expressing that “Stowe’s book lacks unity: it is a panorama, a succession of scenes with little unity between them,” Montégut specifies that Uncle Tom’s Cabin has mechanical writing flaws and criticizes Stowe’s storyline and plot. He continues to share that the novel consists of “facts and facts only, presented crudely and without any tact”. Moreover, Montégut denounces Stowe’s writing style as dull and perhaps unprofessional, certainly not what Stowe had originally …show more content…
He additionally describes Uncle Tom’s Cabin as containing a “type of aggressive strength in the words and epithets which have often characterized political writings”. Because of its apparent vigor and informative nature, some French viewed Stowe’s novel as political work, rather than one that appealed to religion, as she had originally intended. However, no matter what the perception, Stowe’s novel does indeed publicize the message of abolition and informs France about the gruesome happenings surrounding slavery. In the eyes of Émile Montégut and various other French critics, Stowe’s book needs a more elegant and expressive approach, and it also effectively conveys Stowe’s antislavery message, yet in a more political way than she had once hoped. Through her abolitionist novel, Uncle Tom’s Cabin, Harriet Beecher Stowe seeks to inform the French people about the sinful, evil, and prominent nature of slavery and desires to morph their opinions concerning enslavement through various ties to religion; however, she ultimately tugs at their hearts through her strong emotional appeal while also communicating her forthright opinions about slavery in

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    He thought that because of the way he wove the bible into his writing his work had a definite sense of authenticity to it. Christians were justified in reading his book because it was the closest thing to truth that fiction would ever get. Bunyan uses his inclusion of scripture to justify his writing. When he writes the conversation between Christian and Pliable as Christian describes to pliable the kingdom of god and the everlasting life he has granted his followers, Bunyan cites Isaiah 45.17 which specifically says “But…

    • 1704 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Huck Finn is a lame excuse to discuss slavery, it does not consider the importance of the journey nor does it convey the right message. One specific critic had a strong viewpoint of how Twain unsuccessfully wrote the novel. “The Villain here is Mark Twain, who knew how to give Huck a voice but didn’t know how to give him a novel” (Smiley). Smiley is right to judge Twain’s work. The Advantages of Huckleberry Finn is a terrible book, due to the fact that it introduces characters that only cause a distraction to the actual goal, his avoidance of seriously taking Jim’s desire into account, and Twain…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The women filled his head with doubt about his faith. He sees a vision of Eva reading the bible to him it made him feel comforted and regains his strength and faith in The Lord (498). In conclusion Uncle Tom's Cabin by Harriet Beecher Stowe was mainly written to change people's perspective on slavery and to show that slaves were just as courageous, optimistic, and faithful as white people…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The novel proved to be essential to the abolitionist movement, and especially for the Civil War. In the first parts of the book Reynolds dwells on how Stowe’s characters had attributes that made them in favor of anti-slavery. Such qualities were his character’s religious beliefs, and the way the author was able to connect with the reader in a dramatic way so that they could rethink their beliefs toward slavery. In other words, he had a way of getting to them via emotions. Stowe’s hopes for no more slavery in the country were backed by civil rights leaders such as Martin Luther King and Rosa Parks, which Reynolds defends on how Stowe had a great…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Furthermore, it is sensible to mention that Vonnegut’s literature is not able to actualize the depiction of such catastrophic event that takes part in reality. The disarrangement of his novel in a way prevails the literal state that there is nothing more to say in the novel about war except “poo-tee-weet” because there are no other words to distinguish how ashamed, interruptive, and shocking and useless he perceived the whole thing was. Viewed at the introductory and conclusion of this novel there is complete silence, there is no appropriate interpretation to the horrific occurrence of war- no one knows why a massacre leads to complete silence except for the ringing of the birds. "Billy and the rest wandered out onto the shady street. The trees were leafing out.…

    • 1594 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Swift has a book that gives people a memory of nothing (Donoghue). While Swift is criticized for having no depth and seemingly put no effort into creating a story for Gulliver, he is also criticized for being not thorough in his writing itself. Whether it was sentence structure, or the message he was trying to convey with his words, it didn’t always come off properly (Orwell). There was at times when he tried to use his satire he is so famously known for with this book that it came off forced, therefore ineffective (Orwell). In addition to these critiques, Considine shed light on other topics Swift was to be criticized for.…

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Accountability can also be useful when reading the Bible. Having time set to read the Bible is important when making disciples, God can give you strength and ideas when you are in His word. To make more disciples out of this, invite a new believer or a friend who does not know the gospel to a Bible study. To a society or culture who does not know God, try to create stories out of what you are reading in order to spread…

    • 2115 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Abolitionists in 18th century Britain combatted many incorrect stereotypes and inappropriate justifications for the enslavement of Africans. To create an effective argument against slavery, writers had to counter these preconceptions in subtle and irrefutable ways. For instance, Olaudah Equiano’s Interesting Narrative uses nuanced language, an unexacting tone, and manipulated sentence structure to explicate his experience, garnering sympathy and disgust for African slaves’ plight, while remaining comprehensible and inoffensive to a white audience. Thus, his subtle rhetorical techniques relate Equiano to his audience, while still critiquing their treatment of slavery, accomplishing the seemingly impossible task of proving Africans should not…

    • 1230 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Faith In Uncle Tom's Cabin

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Christian characters in Uncle Tom’s Cabin use their faith to motivate others by having faith, to tell others Jesus Christ and put faith in him to go to heaven, to help others in hard times [OS]. Tom showed his strong faith as a concern to other people’s faith; he showed his concerns toward Augustine St. Clare and Legree, and motivates them for their doubts and actions [TS1]. After Eva’s death, St. Clare said to Tom that his life is like an empty…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Douglass interweaves undertones of resistance and solidarity amongst the slaves and free white men, as Mr. Listwell’s sudden epiphany after Madison’s soliloquy is illustrated through his repeated care for the pained slave. In stark contrast to Douglass’s prominent goal to encourage people to become abolitionists, Melville does not overtly pride his novella as anti-slavery propaganda, but instead allows his white readers to see the flaws in the “natural justification” of the power dynamic in slavery. Whereas Douglass articulates his view of egalitarianism through the powerful and capable slave alongside an equally capable abolitionist, Melville simply does the opposite by providing an incompetent white man to battle against an extremely powerful slave. Regardless of the mutinies in both novellas having similar outward appearances, Melville’s novella and his biased white character indicates the understanding of the idea that slaves are capable, while Douglass builds more upon the idea and forces his readers to take action to liberate them. Captain Delano’s disbelief of the slaves being capable of the upheaval of the ship can be juxtaposed to Mr. Listwell’s complete understanding of Madison’s capability and leadership, indicating the implementation of a…

    • 1582 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays