Thomas Paine The Great Debate Analysis

Improved Essays
Thomas Paine was a renowned pro-American writer and author of some of the most persuasive texts of the American Revolution. Paine wrote in a manner that appealed to the masses, not just American elites. He often quoted the Bible in his arguments in an attempt to engage people of all classes in the struggle for American independence and for a rejection of government based on hereditary monarchy. In Paine’s pamphlet Common Sense, it said the Colonists should aim for complete independence from Britain. He argued that Britain governed the Americans for its own benefit, not theirs, and that the distance between the two nations made governing from England very inefficient. The pamphlet sold in its thousands and became very influential. It helped …show more content…
Rights of Man argued against Edwards Burkes Reflections on the Revolution in France. Burkes generally supported the colonists in the American Revolution, and he also felt that Britain should be more pragmatic about the American colonist 's rights and complaints. Even though Burke supported the American Revolution, he opposed the French Revolution. There is a controversial debate about Thomas Paine and Edward Burkes through their own literature. In the article, The Great Debate: Edmund Burke, Thomas Paine and the Birth of Right and Left by Alan Ryan …show more content…
In the article Jefferson and Paine: A Relationship Beyond by Gaye Wilson, he describes Paine’s and Jefferson’s relationship through Paine’s literature. “His support of Paine had thrown Jefferson into the crucible of American politics and made him an identifiable leader of those who favored a strongly republican form of government. With a lesson learned, Jefferson would be much more careful in the future” (Wilson). Jefferson remained silent on certain publications by Paine because he did not know Paine’s religious beliefs. Paine’s work, The Age of Reason, attacked organized religion, the authority of the Bible, and the divinity of Jesus which opposed the idea of what America was built off of. “Jefferson identified Paine as an advocate of human liberty and praised his style of writing, but concluded his letter with a request for confidence: ‘Remember, that I am old, that I wish not to make new enemies’” (Wilson). While Paine was in France, he had received an invitation from Jefferson to return to America. When he did he attended a dinner at the Presidents house which then started the downhill of Washington’s and Paine’s

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Throughout his pamphlet Paine points out wrong doings of King George III that persuade Americans that the king does not care about the colonies well being, and that the English monarchy will only act in self interest. This rebuts any other arguments that attempt to show that the English will protect the colonies. When the argument of the advantages of monarchy come about, Paine tells that even though the simplicity of monarchy can be seen as an advantage the English constitution is far too complex. Again, he rebuts arguments to do with the king such as: the king is checked on by others. Paine shows that there is a fault in this argument by stating if the king must be monitored than he cannot be trusted, and that if he is being monitored by the people, than the people are better fit for the crown than the king is.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When people left Europe, and came to America, they were looking for religious freedom. They received that, but they also kept the government that burdened them for so long. So, for Paine to come along and spark a revolution in the citizens of America took bravery and it took heart. The people of America responded to him, and they took up arms after Common Sense changed their opinion of Great Britain. Through his appeal to their religion, and to a sense of wrong and right, Paine unified a nation that was sick of being looked down to.…

    • 1540 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It was Paine’s most significant and successful writing because it grabbed the attention of many undecided colonists (Britons); who did not believe their autonomy from Britain was essential. In this writing, he explains the importance of the colonies freedom and why it was a necessity. He also explained their allegations, issues with their complicated government, and the negligence of the monarchical powers. In the Common Sense pamphlet, he supported the American independence and in this essay I will explain his proposition and his three main arguments: Independence from England, the formation of a democratic republican, and why the separation of the countries made British ruling…

    • 1663 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American people were enthusiastic about the new state but Jefferson “worried that the purchase might be unconstitutional. The president pointed out that the Constitution did not specifically authorize the acquisition of vast new territories and the incorporation of thousands of foreign citizens.” (PG. 185) Although he felt his act was unconstitutional he still sent Lewis and Clark to explore the vast territory. Also once he became president he realized we needed a stronger government to take on unexpected challenges, leading him to put money back into the army, which goes against his low spending…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At the end of all the fighting and the cruel taxes being imposed by Great Britain, the colonists got tired of being treated unfairly and declared their independence from Great Britain. Thomas Paine played a big role in America’s History because he spread the idea that Britain shouldn’t be ruling America, we the people should be independent. Thomas Paine influenced Thomas Jefferson whenever he was creating the Declaration of Independence, which states why America is now an independent country. Due to both Paine and Jefferson creating the two documents that they made, those two documents created a solid foundation for America to grow…

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the eighteenth century, America was fed up with the British empire and thought they deserved their freedom. Although Thomas Paine and Charles Inglis both had good arguments and logical reason, Paine had a patriotic vision on why America would be better off as an independent nation that Charles Inglis did not see. Paine's argument consists of his views reconciliation, preventing war, and even the downside of independance from Britian. To describe the possible alliance between the British and Americans, Paine uses the word “Reconciliation”. Paine says that reconciliation would bring “The ruin of the Continent.” This does not mean that Pain wants America and Britain to forever be at war, but he is saying that in order to bring overall peace, America needs to be its own nation in order to thrive on its own and prevent further fighting.…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He wrote about the need of democratic electives and independence. He wanted all to know that the King was not fully dedicated towards the welfare of the Americans, he just wanted land and power. Thomas wrote in the benefit of the colonists, but the petition was written for independence under Britain. These two documents were caught in attention by colonists, and…

    • 1325 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With respect to the federal Constitution, the Jeffersonian Republicans are usually characterized as strict constructionists who were opposed to the broad constructionism of the Federalists. To what extent was this characterization of the two parties accurate during the presidencies of Jefferson and Madison? As war wages on in Europe, economic and political influence is spreading to America. As the President’s, Jefferson and Madison are challenged by upholding their country’s honor and putting their beliefs into action. However ideas change along with time and the Presidents may have to alter their beliefs to keep the nation stable.…

    • 856 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the pamphlet he made several valid points mocking the British monarchy but in the simplest of ways. He wrote it to get Americans thinking about the ideas of Independence and detaching themselves from British rule. He mainly argued that the colonists need to put an end to British rule and praised the idea of a Republic government based on democracy. With quotes from the bible as the basis for his writing many American were convinced that his theories were right. He asked many “common sense” questions including; “Why should small England rule a growing America?” and “Why should America stand for such mistreatment by the British?”.…

    • 1354 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even with years passing led to the Declaration of Independence. Francis Hopkinson signed the Declaration of Independence and is famous for his views towards the cause of America becoming independent. Paine argues how one speculative position that could persuade the people loyal to the King. “That the King is not to be trusted.” This shows that there is a fault in the way that the British government is arranged. Paine opposed the divided form of government and finds that a simpler government is a better government.…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays