The Story By Mr. Harr Essay

1184 Words Mar 17th, 2016 null Page
The story by Mr. Harr captures vividly, the civil justice system as discussed in the class text “May it Please the Court” by Brian L. Porto. According to Porto, there are five main actors in the judicial process, especially in a civil proceeding. These players include the plaintiff tell me what they do, the defendants here too, the lawyers for the plaintiff and the defendants’ side, as well as the judge who presides over the civil case. For instance, the case in A Civil Action by Mr. Harr fits within the civil proceeding guidelines as detailed in the class text. Notably, Woburn is the plaintiff, with Jan Schlichtmann and his as plaintiff’s lawyer. The defendants in the case are major cooperate companies, W, R Grace, and Beatrice foods. The defendant’s legal representatives are Cheeseman for Grace and Facher for Beatrice with Judge Skinner presiding over the proceedings (Harr, 1996). As is common practice in most judicial system, the plaintiff files the charges within the limitations as provided under statutes. In the story by Mr. Harr, the Woburn took three years. On the defendants’ side, Beatrice through lawyer Cheeseman applied for the dismissal of the case on grounds that the case was frivolous since the plaintiff had no firm grounds for negligent actions. Indeed, the class text by Porto describes trivial cases to be those that aid in clouding the courts, which essentially overloads the cases resulting in case backlogs. Admittedly, Cheeseman was well within the…

Related Documents