The Shortcomings Of George Dickie's Art And Aesthetic: What Is Art?

Improved Essays
Human beings always have had an innate ability to imagine and create that what lies beyond just a primal, basic understanding of the world around them. It is this nature that overflows with ingenuity and vision that begs to be conveyed through something that has existed since the dawn of humanity. Artistic expression is an undeniable epicenter of the human identity. The arts are such a rooted part of the human identity that every society, culture, civilization, and group emulates some form of it, from pottery in Ancient Egypt to Shakespearean plays in 18th Century England. With this in mind, philosophers have attempted to answer throughout history the burning questions pertaining to this need and appreciation for the arts, to explain what stimulates …show more content…
In George Dickie’s Art and Aesthetic: An Institutional Analysis, he sets out to define art by first explaining what it means for art to be part of an institution, part of the “artworld”. For example, the film industry can be viewed as an art institution. What the filmmaker provides is art, and it is art because it exists within that institution of filmmaking, and that institution exists because it is an “established practice” by not only the filmmaker but as well as the actors, film critics, film goers, and the like. So is true for all other art institutions, such as painting, sculpture, theatre, literature, music, etc (all having their own sub-institutions as well), thus making the artworld a direct by-product of that what the individual cultures around the world make it to be. Dickie then proceeds to actually define what a work of art is. “A work of art in the classificatory sense is (1) an artifact (2) a set of the aspects of which has had conferred upon it the status of candidate for appreciation by some person or persons acting on behalf of a certain social institution (the artworld) ” (Dickie). Artifactuality, to Dickie, has two sides. On one hand, artifactuality can be thought of in the traditional sense where something is made by man, through painting, sculpting, crafting, etc., in order to serve in a position within the artworld. On the other hand, artifactuality is also when something that preexists is taken and altered in some way in order to have a purpose. Dickie has often used driftwood as an example. If the driftwood is taken and sharpened and refined by an artist to display its characteristics of a sculpture, then it is an artifact. Furthermore, if the driftwood is taken, unaltered, and used as a tool for something like digging, it is also an artifact because while nothing was physically changed about the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Bob Ross Research Paper

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages

    When we look at the world today, not all of us enjoy art, not many of us practice it, But no one is surprised when someone comes along from our friends or family who is deemed talented at art. This mindset, this overall acceptance than anyone can go out and learn how to do what they love. It’s a modern phenomena, full of aspiring graphic artists and cartoonists, painters and animators. We see more and more art classes each year, the world seems to want to learn how to do art, because having artistry as a hobby has become commonplace in these times. We owe a great part of this to one man, to one show, and to a thousand words of encouragement Bob Ross’s; The Joy of Painting has brought us.…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My artifact is a ribbon I won at an Interscholastic Equestrian Association horse show last year. The horse show was on April Sixteenth, and took place in Centre Hall, Pennsylvania. The show was Western Zone Finals. For a rider to qualify for Zone Two Finals, they must acquire at least fifteen points in five or less horse shows. The Interscholastic Equestrian Association, also known as IEA, is for middle and high school students.…

    • 317 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Theodore Dalrymple’s What We Have to Lose, Dalrymple explores the human ability to convey meanings and higher thought as a means to differentiate the civilized from the uncivilized. He alludes to the notion that the main factor that distinguishes humanity is our ability to make art and other expressive mediums that can articulate the different and complex emotions and thoughts that we experience. His main methodology to support his argument is through various anecdotes.…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Meaning of Art In Dorothy Allison’s, This is Our World, she creates many arguments about art, artists, and the way art is viewed. There are many times throughout the essay where she claims the audience can interpret art differently. However, this is not always the case. The interpretation of art is not always up to the audience.…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In her 2006 article “The Trouble with (the Term) Art”, Carolyn Dean argues that the using the word “art” for both past visual expressions (particularly nonwestern) does not quite capture the true definition of what these pieces are. This argument is valid, to consider these works as mere entertainment erases a culture’s true history and identity. Dean has a very strong argument for the analysis and retirement of the term “art”, however the ideas surrounding the concept of “art” explain the larger issue as a whole. Carolyn Dean argues that pinning the recent idea of “art” on nonwestern works does not inform one about the culture, but rather condenses that culture into easily defined novelties.…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    (p. 27) I agree with Dean’s thoughts on how this term falsely includes objects into the art category when they were originally intended for a much different reason. A recent instance comes to mind when thinking of this topic. My mother was rearranging a few things in our home and she placed a few new art pieces around the house. Our home is full of interesting items, and one item that made its way into our house during the decoration process was an arrowhead found by my grandfather in New York quite a few years ago.…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    History is compilation of data and materials gathered throughout time and analyzed to form some consensus of what happened in the past. A common way people learn about history is through reading and memorizing textbooks and historical literature. This can be an effective way of understanding the past but it is important to not overlook other ways of understanding the past such as artwork. Although artwork may not always tell the person about specific knowledge, it may sometimes give more information that other sources could not. The important thing to note about historical artwork is that it shows the scholar insight about what the people of the time thought of themselves and not what other people thought of them.…

    • 963 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The documentary “Exit Through the Gift Shop” depicts the transformation of a family man obsessed with filming every waking moment, Thierry Guetta, into a self-absorbed and self-proclaimed artist, Mr. Brainwash. In capturing this man’s journey, the documentary brings to light two significant issues in the world of art. The first being the use of assistants to create artwork and the second being the instantaneous success of an artist; whom without the endorsements of already renowned and respected street artists would have never amounted to anything noteworthy. For generations, the use of assistants to create artwork has been an imperative asset to several notorious artists, including Mr. Brainwash.…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Constantly evolving, constantly transforming. A place where any outsider has to prove themselves before being welcomed with open arms, where fame or riches is not the predominant factor instead communication is the main concern. Art is such a dexterous community, with countless of people from different backgrounds, ideals or beliefs, as a result, it doesn’t belong to only one culture alone and it becomes a form of communication that can reach multiple people regardless of the language boundary that has separated men throughout time and time again. In a sense, I am Alice in the Art world, as a discourse community art has established a part of what I am today by influencing me in my early years, transitioning my life, integrating me into a whole…

    • 2060 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Dionysus

    • 1814 Words
    • 8 Pages

    It is believed that first evidence of artistic activity is a diagonal itching on a stone with a shark tooth, associated to Homo erectus around 500 000 years ago. However the oldest undisputed form of figurative art is a sculptured Venus figurine around 40 000 years ago. A time where human behavior hadn’t yet developed behavioral modernity which consists of abstract thinking and symbolic behavior among other things, yet art found its way. These first forms of art were not pure creation of the human mind but a consequence of primordial form of mimesis. With the evolution of human consciousness and complex cognitive skills, like language, writing, analytical abilities, the artistic ability evolved as well.…

    • 1814 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    In Art as Experience, John Dewey argues that art enhances how people experience life. Specifically, Dewey stated that to fully live one 's life, they must understand and appreciate the art around them in order to enhance their everyday experience. In this paper, I will use Art as Experience as my source to show Dewey 's argument with the use of examples and artworks mentioned in the work to back it up. I will touch on the classification of art and how art can enhance experience, the different experiences that can occur, and how art is similar to life.…

    • 1808 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    First of all, what is art and what is not art? It is always hard to define art because different people has the different idea about art. According to the article, “The ARTS and the CREATION of MIND” “It is a process that is shaped by culture, influenced by language, impacted by beliefs, affected by values, and moderated by the distinctive features of that part of ourselves we sometimes describe as our individuality. (Eisner)” In…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first pieces of art date back 700,000 years ago when people carved objects and drawings on stone during the stone age, but why did said people feel the initial impulsion to start chipping away on rocks in the first place? Why we indulge in art, literature, media is completely analytical, for we are humans and all humans strive for one thing-power. When we watch media we gain a sense of today’s culture and activities, when we read literature we gain knowledge, when we look at and discuss art we gain notoriety, which are all three things one needs to climb the ladder of prestige. Of course not everybody wants to be categorized into one large group so we use pieces of literature to help further define us. Literature provides a reader with…

    • 1143 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Importance Of Art Education

    • 1720 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 9 Works Cited

    “For very young children, making art -- or just talking about it- provides opportunities to learn words for colors, shapes, and actions” (Lynch). It is vital for a child to learn the importance of art early in their life so that they can choose whether or not they will be dedicated to pursue a career involving art skills. Learning about these basic forms of art at an early age gives children more insight in preparation for their educational life. “Although some may regard art education as a luxury, simple creative activities are some of the building blocks of child development” (Lynch). Students involved in simple creative activities within their peers can affect their emotional status and gives a more comforting feeling being around others that have similar qualities of enjoyment.…

    • 1720 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 9 Works Cited
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Throughout this course I have gained more of an appreciation for artwork and the artists that create them. I have also gained an appreciation for the people that try to define what art is in general or more specifically what makes good art. We have read great thinkers and their philosophies on this, and the fact that even people of such great intelligence can disagree on the subject proves how challenging it can be. By reading the opinions of these great thinkers, and by discussing their thought with our class, I feel I am in a much better place as to define what makes good art myself. I define art as anything created by someone that inspires another to appreciation.…

    • 2210 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays

Related Topics