# The Puzzle Of The Sea Battle Essay

1654 Words Dec 12th, 2016 7 Pages
The puzzle of the Sea Battle ultimately functions as a counterexample or exception to the principle of bivalence. The problem is as follows: suppose somebody states the following proposition, “There will be a Sea Battle tomorrow.” According to bivalence, this proposition must either be true or false. For, if it were to lack a truth-value, there is a logical gap, and if it’s both true and false, there lies a contradiction. By denying a truth-value to the proposition, one denies bivalence, but maintaining it has a truth-value is an assertion of fatalism. The problem with the proposition lies in the future contingent tense. When you consider a disjunction of the two alternatives “Either there will be a Sea Battle tomorrow or there will not be a Sea Battle tomorrow,” one of the disjuncts must be true for the proposition itself to be true. Yet, because both disjuncts are statements about how the future will unfold, to assert either disjuncts a truth-value is to suppose the future is fixed.
In his solution to the puzzle of the Sea Battle, Aristotle concedes that the proposition can neither be true nor false:

“It is necessary for everything either to be or not to be, and indeed to be going to be or not going to be. But one cannot divide [the contradictories] and say that one or the other is necessary…It is necessary for there to be or not to be a sea battle tomorrow, but it is not necessary for a sea battle to happen tomorrow, nor is it necessary for one not to happen. It is…

## Related Documents

• ###### The Puzzle Of The Sea Battle We Must First Discuss The Principle Of Bivalence

1) To dive into the puzzle of the Sea Battle we must first discuss the Principle of Bivalence. The Principle of Bivalence can be summarized as follows: for any well-formed proposition, the truth value of that statement must be either true or false. The truth value of the proposition cannot be both (a contradiction), nor neither (a gap). And when looking at the puzzle of the Sea Battle it is of special importance to us to keep in mind that a proposition cannot be neither true nor false, for like we…

Words: 1413 - Pages: 6
• ###### Engineers Of Victory : The Problem Solvers Who Turned The Tide

explicitly says towards the end of the introductory chapter that what a reader should take away from this book is, “…how these various, eccentric pieces of the jigsaw puzzle fitted into the whole,” (pg. xxvi, 2013). In basic understanding, in order to support his thesis, Kennedy uses each chapter within the book as a piece of the puzzle that put together shows to the reader how the war was won and through what means. Now as to what Kennedy is trying to prove here is based on what he says in this book…

Words: 2187 - Pages: 9
• ###### Essay Wwii Of The South Pacific Against Japan

WWII in the South Pacific against Japan was a long drawn out battle and Japan ruled the war for an extended period of time. The United States entered WWII after the blow at Pearl Harbor December 7, 1941 by the Japanese; they continued to have triumph after triumph over the US Pacific fleet. This all changed with the victory over the Japanese at the Island of Midway, June 4 to 7, 1942. With the strategic importance of Midway’s location, cryptographers and all the military units, made this military…

Words: 821 - Pages: 4
• ###### The battle of the brands- Old Spice vs. Axe Essay

Title: The battle of the brands: Old Spice vs. Axe. By: Neff, Jack, Advertising Age, 00018899, 11/17/2008, Vol. 79, Issue 43 Database:Communication & Mass Media Complete P&G, Unilever claim respective products are up and rival's are down One of the crowning achievements of the Jim Stengel era at Procter & Gamble Co., at least according to Jim Stengel, has been the rebound of Old Spice in the battle for hearts and minds of men. P&G's former global marketing officer was so impressed with the old-school…

Words: 845 - Pages: 4
• ###### The Bloodiest Battle: The Battle of Okinawa Essay

The Bloodiest Battle The Battle of Okinawa (codenamed Operation Iceberg) proved to be the deadliest battle on the Pacific side of World War II. The battle involved six countries and more than 180,000 casualties. It became the last campaign in the Pacific and changed the course of history. In part of the island hopping campaign, the United States knew in order to invade mainland Japan, they would need the last piece of the puzzle. Okinawa was the last island needed to be taken in order to serve…

Words: 1241 - Pages: 5
• ###### Essay on Responding to Pain in Jane Eyre and Wide Sargasso Sea

Responding to Pain in Jane Eyre and Wide Sargasso Sea In both Jane Eyre and Wide Sargasso Sea, the main characters Jane and Antoinette are faced with hardships that affect each of them in different ways. In the passages below, the authors Charlotte Bronte and Jean Rhys illustrate that Jane and Antoinette grew fond of inanimate objects in response to the hurt that they had suffered in life. Although Jane and Antoinette appear to have come from painful backgrounds, each deals with her pain…

Words: 1594 - Pages: 7
• ###### Essay Beowulf Perseverance

Perseverance is a great factor in the heroic poem, Beowulf. In the poem the main character is named Beowulf, he is characterized for his great fighting skills and abilities. He uses perseverance as his main tool for success in the story; he uses it to defeat sea monsters, Grendel, Grendel’s mother, a dragon, and ruling as a good king. Staying committed until glory is reached is very important for success, because if the people do not stay committed during their tasks or goals they will not be successful…

Words: 1001 - Pages: 5
• ###### Essay The Hearts And Minds

to numerous deadly outcomes. Next, a story from across the Atlantic to a small southern town in the early 1940’s, where young African Americans struggle with an oppressive and prejudicial society, is a fight to be fought without any real victor, in Battle Royal. Lastly, grab a swimsuit and stroll the aisles of a 1960’s supermarket to examine a story of a cashier in the short story titled A&P. Furthermore, the comparable element within these stories, in which transform and bring about realization contained…

Words: 1415 - Pages: 6
• ###### Essay Gender Bending in Antony and Cleopatra

against Antony. Knowing that Antony is stronger on land Octavius challenges him by sea and out of pride Antony accepts the challenge, but then he makes a decision even more foolish, he allows Cleopatra to join the battle of Actium. Cleopatra now gets the masculine authority she has been seeking. Enobarbus knows how foolish this decision is, but Cleopatra insists on staying. ENOBARBUS Your presence needs must puzzle Antony, Take from his heart, take from his brain, from’s time, Which should not…

Words: 1810 - Pages: 8
• ###### Essay The Origin Of M How Did Life Begin?

The Origin of Man How did life begin? Where did humans come from? The origin of man is a mystery of the universe, however, there is a long-lasting battle raging between the Christian belief and scientists. Christians believe God created Adam and Eve six thousand years ago, and that all the humans, animals, plants of the world began at that time. This theory is called creationism, and their evidence is everything written in the Bible. However, scientists believe in the theory of evolution. They believe…

Words: 1292 - Pages: 6