Hegemonic Masculinity In Saving Private Ryan

Great Essays
In many cases, men are afraid to show signs of being feminine. They feel pressured by society to act a certain way and behave in a manner that will make them seem manlier. Many have a fear of being stigmatized for acting a certain way around others, so the majority of the time they suppress their feelings and conversations with others. This can limit their bonding and friendship building. For men, according to society, they must become masculine and nothing else. However, that is not always the case because they have agency. They are allowed and able to have several types of masculinities. The film Saving Private Ryan represents the way different men are capable of being different than just a typical hegemonic masculine man that society has …show more content…
The lecture notes “ The Social Construction of Gender Relations” talks about the assumptions and beliefs that society has constructed about gender. A hegemonic masculine male is someone who poses as a dominant male. It is someone who is strong and independent. It is a male who leads and gives orders (slide 11). In the film, Captain Miller, who is in charge of a group of soldiers, must give orders and command that group. He must get treated with respect and soldiers must follow his commands. An example is seen when Captain Miller gives a speech about the mission he took on. He explains how he does not care about Private Ryan but about completing the mission he took on. The reason why he began his speech was because a member of his group was tired of trying to save the life of a man who they did not even know was still alive. Captain Miller opens up about what he does outside of his soldier boundaries and what life is like outside for the very first time. This scene illustrates this gender concept because Captain Miller is the captain, and he is the only one in the group that others depend on for guidance and survival. Captain Millar showed the viewers how a man can be an extreme hegemonic masculine male while at the same time being able to open up about his personal life. He also finds a way to stay tough and being a natural role leader for his group of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In both passages “Biographies of Hegemony” by Karen Ho and “The Naked Citadel” by Susan Faludi, there are two higher institutions, which would be Wall Street and the Citadel whose goal is to “remold” an individual to fit their criteria. Each individual has a certain identity and presents themselves in a specific way. People are known to change due to influences on their everyday lives, which eventually changes their identities into someone completely different. In these two passages, it becomes evident that because of the pressures put upon people by these hierarchies, people unconsciously change and are shaped into new individuals while hiding their true identities. Any person can be completely stripped of their old identities by falling under…

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Society is not an all-male world anymore, it is an interracial society in which men cannot just be leaders by showing their masculinity. This is one of the reason why men go to an all-male institution. At the Citadel, cadets are able to create their small world and “feel called to defend those walls”, because some things in their lives are “endangered from without” (Faludi 103). For this reason, the cadets feel that the Citadel is a place where they can not only discharge their feelings but also feel better by earning the sense of becoming leaders and winners. Henceforth, the immediate context is just a trigger that gives opportunity for people to behave in a certain way.…

    • 1455 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When the preliminary emancipation proclamation paved the way for the African Americans enlistment where black men have the opportunity to fight for freedom and demonstrate their manhood and masculinity, we can see that most of the Black men sought to volunteer to join and becoming the soldiers in the Civil War. It is because, all of them were struggling to claim their manhood and masculinity. By joining military service in the Civil War, they have the opportunity to manhood, glory and also freedom that was so irresistible for them. Furthermore, we can see that many white men considered and linked military service with adult masculinity. Thus, by joining this war, they can show to the whites (especially to their masters) their manhood and prove to them their masculinity.…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    By instilling the idea that women are inferior compared to men, the meaning of being a woman or showing femininity is distorted. Especially when femininity is compared to a contaminating illness that poses a threat to whoever and wherever it is exposed to. Many times “one culture can reshape how a population in another culture categorizes a given set of symptoms, replace their explanatory model, and redraw the line demarcating normal behaviors and internal states from those considered pathological” (Watters 519). The Citadel has a created its own culture based on masculinity that is completely separate from everyone outside its walls which will not allow women due to the drastic changes that will follow the acceptance. The Citadels long held belief of masculinity over everything else shows how the metaphors of gender identity further the vision of women as a threat that will only work against the all-male policy once they are allowed in the institution.…

    • 1782 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Hegemonic Masculinity

    • 1855 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The term “patriarchy” has been used to describe the social system of men holding the power and authority. Since the 1960s, feminist are working hard to spread the awareness of how patriarchy system related to the inequality treatment existing in both genders (Cranny, 2003). It is argued that different sectors in the world such as labour force, education, politics and more has been undergoing a domination of male, known as “hegemonic masculinity”. Since this phenomenon of hegemonic masculinity has been deemed natural, ordinary or normal (Donaldson, 1993), various actions and thinking are seen to favour masculinity characteristic, or in this case, men. Raewyn Connell describes the situation of masculinity favouring situation as “patriarchal dividend”.…

    • 1855 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This not only applies to males but females as well. In the 2009 film The Codes of Gender by Sut Jhally we learn that in advertisements females are shown to be soft, gentle and not in control, so that men are able to be shown as strong, masculine and in control of the women. When females differ from the “norm” of how females should behave they may also be stereo-typed or looked at in a negative way by society, just because are different than the…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the reading “Bros Before Hos: The Guy Code”, Michael Kimmel critics what it means to be a man and the “Guy Code” they are expected to follow. According to Kimmel, masculinity is a problematic social construct that invokes behaviors that men tend to follow unconsciously. The unconscious behaviors that men tend to follow is know as the “Guy Code” that is passed down to them when they were young. Kimmel claims that boys follow the “Guy Code” at a young age because they don’t want to be considered gay or in masculine.…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Man may not be about the male gender, but what makes one masculine. When masculinity is a construction, the relationship of masculinity to femininity can be read as a factor of how ‘man’ is represented. In The War of the Worlds and Starship Troopers, masculinity, and even gender, is ‘relational’ rather than as a thing in itself: masculinity is to a large extent defined in relation to femininity and vice versa. Even when femininity is absent, it is always lurking, a haunting reminder to maintain masculinity. From the narrator of The War of the Worlds to Juan in Starship Troopers, masculinity is portrayed as barely able to stand alone without relating to femininity.…

    • 1130 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Soldiers of the Vietnam War viewed it as a complicated and unwanted conflict, as illustrated in Tim O’Brien’s historical novel The Things They Carried. The soldiers in the book faced fear, pain, and death for a war they didn’t believe in; they killed and died because society taught them to place strength above all else. The Vietnam War introduced a pressure to aspire for masculinity and twisted love into obsession which shaped the beliefs, ideas, actions, and feelings of the soldiers in an irreversibly harmful way. O’Brien uses masculinity as a driving force for the actions of all the soldiers. The desire for masculinity and fear of ridicule pushed many young men into the war, and resulted in a generation of men that "died and killed because…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Masculinity’s Crossroads The article “Guys vs. Men,” Dave Barry uses satire to explain the problems with masculinity and a new approach to how males should be classified and judged. The article “The Crisis of American Masculinity” by Eric Garland discusses his view of how the traditional image of manhood is dying in today’s society. Each of them give their opinions on what manhood is; the manner that society should treat males with, the importance of masculinity in males, and their opinion of the necessity of these masculine characteristics.…

    • 2174 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Masculinity is term that is heavily influenced by a society’s cultures and beliefs. Masculinity is also a term that could have multiple definitions depending on the way men are portrayed in certain cultures. Masculinity is defined as a set of attributes, behaviors, and roles generally associated with boys and men. Certain masculine traits include courage, independence, and assertiveness. Men are supposed to be strong, independent and not need help from anyone no matter what the circumstances are.…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the film Twelve Years a Slave, portrays the slave narrative of the protagonist Solomon Northup. Due to the debilitating, traumatic, and degrading experience of Patsey, and other characters, viewers are able to deepen empathy and understanding regarding slavery. As a female slave Patsey experiences and imbalance relation between Mistress Epps and Master Epps. Patsey, also known as, the queen of the fields, is seen as an asset to Master Epps. Master Epps displays love and affection for Patsey by constantly raping and abusing her in a violent manner.…

    • 1557 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “It is clear throughout the film that when difficult decisions must be made, they must be made by a man. This message, like the reassertions of feminine gender norms off the pitch and masculine norms on it, serves to undermine the progressive messages of the film.” (Abdel-Shehid 150.…

    • 1185 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Equal opportunity may not result in equal outcome In light of Secretary of Defense Aston Carter’s recent announcement that all combat military occupational specialties will open to women, I feel compelled to speak on this controversial subject. In this paper I will talk about both sides of the argument including factors of the effects of gender integration in combat units and provide reasons that justify predictions that people have made. This certain topic affects me because I have a brother that has given four years of service and has five more years of service to give after becoming an officer for the Marines. My brother Thomas served as infantry member and if they rule that women may serve it will affect him in his military career in the…

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is simply naïve to disregard the overwhelming influence that the media and literature has had over the public over the past century and more precisely, in our youth. As a society, we constantly twist ourselves to fit the mold presented to us through various media outlets (e.g. TV, movies, magazines, advertisements, etc.) and in literature we encounter in our lives for a multitude of reasons. Throughout time, men have been presented to fit very traditionally masculine traits based on a preconceived narrative as to what it means to be a man and how to present oneself in order to be perceived as manly by others. Media and literature have branded a hyper-masculine image of men that has in time become what is expected for young boys to follow––be it relayed to them or not.…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays