Rhetorical Analysis Of How To Save Indonesia's Forests

Superior Essays
Thuman 1
Jaden Thuman
ELA 11B
Mrs.Linder
24 April 2016
Raging peatland fires bond to destroy Indonesia’s environment
“According to a 2007 study by the World Bank, Indonesia is the world’s largest emitter of greenhouse gases after America and China, mostly because of the destruction of forests and peatlands”(“Logging the good news; Indonesia’s forests”).This happens when land clearing plantations and farmers in Indonesia decide to clear land by creating forests fires that wipe out trees. This creates problems like high carbon emissions being released, toxic regional haze, deforestation, and the endangering of wildlife. While at first it might appear that an easy solution to the deadly carbon emissions poisoning Indonesia 's air, is stopping factories and plantations
…show more content…
One way the government is doing this is by assigning military personnel to guard their forests and peatlands.
The Qatar Tribune’s article “How To Save Indonesia 's Forests” speaks on what Indonesia is trying to do about the problem: “ Widodo (president of Indonesia) has deployed 25,000 personnel to control the fires and instructed the government to prosecute those who set them.
But he understands that this is not enough.” The Economist’s article, “Logging the Good News;
Indonesia’s Forests” complicates matters further by bringing to light Indonesia 's failed attempts to stop illegal land clearing. Illegal land clearing has continued in much part due to a corrupt forestry ministry. The President’s task force has done little to stop the forestry ministries current practices. The Economist states, “the forestry ministry is widely seen as corrupt, even by
Indonesian standards, and officials have been caught selling permits to exploit forested areas.”
Thuman 1
If President Widodo and his Government can crack down on illegal land clearing they can

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The article, American Forest Policy-Global Ethical Tradeoffs, addresses the issue of global increases in timber demand, especially within the United States, coupled with the decrease in timber production and forest cultivation within the U.S., and the potential solutions that may remedy the growing timber dilemma. The authors propose several solutions and discuss their potential benefits and costs, but overall, voice their preference of establishing forest plantations and practicing intensive forest management. The article is written is a very straightforward, factual way that is aimed at the general public, in an attempt to have them understand the unintentional hypocrisies of their actions of advocating reduced logging while still importing…

    • 1465 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Australian and Indonesia, while similar in many ways, have very considerable differences, particularly in their economies. Both are mixed market economies, but while Australia’s economy is well developed and has a large proportion of government interference helping to make Australia one of the most desirable nations to live in, Indonesia’s economy is less advanced with a lower level of income per capita and a lower standard of living than Australia. Though Australia is four times larger than Indonesia, Indonesia’s population is ten times that of Australia’s. Australia is also a highly industrialised economy because it’s GDP ranked it at 12th the world. Comparatively, Indonesia is ranked 16th by GDP.…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Palm oil is in charge of expansive scale forest transformation in the tropics and broad carbon outflows, adding to global warming. As global demand for palm oil keeps on expanding, tropical forests crosswise over Southeast Asia, and progressively Africa and Latin America, are at danger for transformation into vast scale palm oil plantations. In traditional plantation agriculture, a single crop is grown over a large area planted in neat rows with well-developed network of transportation and communication, connecting plantation areas, processing industries and markets together, which exists in palm oil agriculture. Heavy dependence on labor is there in plantation agriculture, which is true in case of palm oil production, though currently, efforts have been taken to revolutionize it with machinery and reduce dependence on labor.…

    • 580 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to my information sheets the tropical forests come in two different varieties wet and dry and both of them are under threat The worst destruction is occurring in the wet forests latin America has lost thirty-seven percent Asia has lost forty two percent and Africa has lost fifty two percent of their original tropical wet forests this information shows the extent of the destruction and I am sure it is even greater then what is shown currently in my information sheets. Logging was thought to be the biggest cause of deforestation has taken second place to do cultivation by the forest farmers who don’t actually own the land which are estimated to be about 150 million worldwide the conversion of forest to agricultural plots plantations and pastureland these farmers follow to logging companys and convert what is left after the logging companys leave these farmers do this so that they can earn a living but the problem is that they are doing it in a way that is not sustainable for the environment they cut down all the trees and burn them and use the ash for feriziler after three of four harvests insects weeds and soil impoverishment causes them to leave and repeat the same cycle some farmers usually seed the plots with grass then…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Though Brazil is known quite well for its stringent deforestation laws, there is very little existent enforcement of these laws. Many agencies are underfunded and understaffed, and some are even involved in timber laundering, where trees are illegally harvested and given clean documentation to facilitate their sale. The new found protection of forests by indigenous tribes had been met with controversial reactions. One indigenous group, the Guardians, “have tied up loggers, torched their trucks and tractors, and kicked them off the reserves” (Phillips). This, of course, has led to the decreased logging in the area, but some people are fearful of the radical methods in the already dangerous area.…

    • 2010 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Western World’s imperialism was one of the major reasons for the development of industrialization. In addition to factory work and other forms of manufacturing forms of resource extraction, especially mining, were made increasingly, important by industrialization. Also prominent was the cash- crop monoculture. Since some places had plenty of natural resources to make machinery, industrialization formed. Mass deforestation arose as a growing problem in many parts of the world.…

    • 106 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I select the project regarding World Bank support for Brazil’s “Polonoroeste” development program, in particularly the one which help the building of a highway in the middle of Amazonian state of Rondonia and Mato Grosso to start a new development area where before there was only forest. The project consisted in help the local civil government in develop new infrastructure such as road, agriculture fields and so one which can connect the coast area, the most developed one, to the Amazonian area. Inside the project there was also the Idea to build a highway long about 1500 km into the forest, with also a resettle plan for the migrants in the northwest of the region.…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Academic Peer Review Paper

    • 1214 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The scientific article by Obidzinski et al., which was subjected to much scrutiny by peers before being published, provided an objective view on the negative impacts that the palm oil industry would have on the environment, society and economy of Indonesia. The press article was written by World Growth, an organization promoting development, and it was more subjective, presenting evidence that only explained one side of the story. The intended audience for this article is perhaps thinking less critically than an expert in the field reviewing their peer’s work, meaning the power to persuade the public audience is easier to achieve, therefore not needing to be as…

    • 1214 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Commercial Genocide The Earth and the gifts it gives are being exploited to earn money. This is because of worldwide deforestation. Countries destroy their trees to earn an easy profit at the cost of the Earth’s forests. Deforestation is used to create plantations, clear land for real estate development, and to harvest paper or wood.…

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Earth is currently facing detrimental environmental issues. These issues have been evident for decades; however, many people have continuously denied them to be problematic or even their existence entirely. While these critics have managed to get away with the rejection of these problems for many years, it is no longer deniable that the issue of environmental degradation is very real and in need of immediate action. Much of the population has come to understand this, and have executed a variety of modest attempts to increase environmental sustainability. However, these efforts have demonstrated to be of minimal effect in solving the large-scale issues directly causing the degradation.…

    • 1550 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Besides that, the low farmers also caused by the fires with the similar purpose with the corporations where both wanted to open the new land easily. Moreover, the forest fires case disassembled the negative side of government’s behavior in order to gain personal interests. (Sizer, Leach, Minnemeyer, Higgins, Stole, Anderson, Lawalata, 2014). It has the more serious concerns in the environmental side. It caused the lost of harvest opportunity, disturbance in aviation, environmental damage and lost of ecosystems.…

    • 2084 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Oil Palm Deforestation

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages

    However, the decrease in poverty caused by oil palm revenue leads to some positive indirect outcomes to be reported such as schools being built, health clinics/hospitals, or religious centres.3 The paper by World Growth5 supports oil palm because of the requirements of oil palm for the global market, and that it is generating money for the people of Indonesia, West Kalimantan, and Bunyamin, which is beneficial to the people in poverty as stated in Cramb and Curry.1 However, the scale they used was too broad, and missed the true financial impacts as reported by Obidzinski et al.3 that it further widened the gap between the upper class and the poor. However, Cramb and Curry1 measured the macro and micro economic issues and concluded that the popular ideology of oil palm’s capitalist expansion is destructive to rural livelihoods is more complex than expected, and that in some regions, the people of Asia and the pacific region provided a potential to escape poverty by adding money and jobs to their economy and adding new livelihood…

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Brilliant Essays

    Importance Of Orangutans

    • 2343 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Illegal timber is approximately 80% of the total volume logged in 2003, which is comfortably the largest share of all logging in Indonesia. Legal timber concessions can also be detrimental when granted in priority areas for biodiversity conservation, but illegal logging currently has far greater impacts. Whilst the forestry sector is very important to the Indonesian economy, illegal logging is costing Indonesia at least $3b a year in lost revenues alone . Officially exported wood products accounted for $6.6b in 2003, and unreported exports at least an additional $2.4b, suggesting that direct illegal export is at least 30% of the total export.…

    • 2343 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Brilliant Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nevertheless the world Bank Forestry Policy states that 'high private discount rates, particularly among the poor populations that depend on forests, are the cause of deforestation ' (The Open University, 2015c). There is an empirical evidence that poor people are more likely to deforest in higher rate and to do that borrow in informal markets with high interest rates. (The Open University, 2015d). On the other hand, according to World Bank examination (The Open University, 2015e), the link between poverty and high level of deforestation might vary as some society used forest management that sustain them for centuries. For example…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Indonesia is rich in natural resources. The natural resources that Indonesia has are petroleum, tin, natural gas, nickel, timber, bauxite, copper, fertile soils, coal, gold, and silver. By having this much resources, Indonesia is able to do trading with super powers, such as United…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays