Collaboration When Bearing In Margaret Edson's Wit

Improved Essays
The behaviors of medical staff in the play Wit by Margaret Edson (1998) allow us to view different circumstances that take place. In the play, patients are supposed to be the main focus of all care. Susie Monahan, the primary nurse of one patient, Vivian Bearing, who suffers from stage four ovarian cancer, is one of the few health professionals whose caring attributes display the principle that the focus of care should be on the patient. However, if Monahan was part of the collaborating team, she would have been more assertive as a nurse and would not have struggled with the ethics in nursing, thus allowing her true identity as a nurse to show earlier in the play. Susie Monahan is not part of the collaborating team. Collaboration …show more content…
Dr. Posner, who was her former student and is now her physician, disregards Monahan’s suggestion to lower the dosage for the next cancer treatment. Instead, Posner says, “No way. Full dose. She’s tough. She can take it. Wake me up when the counts come from the lab” (p. 45). Dr. Posner dismisses her ideas and leaves the room. If she was part of the team, the conversation would have gone more in depth because it would have already been discussed in the course of action for the patient. In addition, when Bearing experiences excruciating pain, Dr. Kelekian, the head physician, says to give her a morphine drip. However, Monahan suggests patient- controlled medication and gives a valid reason: that it will keep her attentive instead of making her lethargic. Dr. Kelekian dismisses her while she tries to explain; her words are cut off, whereas, if Monahan was part of the team, the conversation would have continued. This proves that Monahan is not part of the team, which leads to her struggles with nursing …show more content…
It was a perfect time to show assertiveness, especially after Bearing had an increased temperature and was in an immunocompromised state. However, when she does decide to be more assertive it is toward the end of the play. By that time, Dr. Posner tries to revive her after Monahan grabs him and says she is not a full code. The patient is already dead by the time she decides to be more assertive. When one adds some assertiveness to her caring nature, one has Monahan’s true identity as a nurse. Despite all the issues Monahan faces, from not being on the team to struggling with moral outrage, she discovers something more, which is her true identity as a nurse toward the end. Her true identity comes out toward the end when she aggressively advocates for the patient. She needed assertion to fulfill the patient’s last wishes to let her die. However, she discovers her true identity as a nurse too late. If she was on the collaborating team from the start, she would have discovered who she is

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    She tears down the patients and convinces them that something is wrong with them instead of helping them overcome their issues. Most patients on the ward can leave voluntarily, but the Nurse Ratched inflicts so much self doubt…

    • 1106 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Unit 7 Morgan, a peaceful explorer and newly employed young woman, was not expecting to have trouble at all that morning. In fact, it had been one of those mornings that seemed to point toward a fulfilling and bright day, and trouble seemed incongruous with the sun, birds, and cloudless sky. There was just nothing that Morgan could imagine that would ruin the promising start she was getting today. That day she had planned on hiking out in the mountains, seeking to have a quiet day to herself. She was excited to observe the nature and have a private picnic with no one else around her but simply the elements.…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Docta Caro Analysis

    • 1353 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Digging the heels of her hands into the small of her back and arching first back and then forward to ease the kinks Dr. Caroline Taylor groaned as the stiffening muscles protested her efforts to loosen them, then ran her hands through her cap of short black hair. She stood at the end of the men's ward surveying the patients lying in the narrow metal beds. Dysentery, an appendix, two leg wounds from farming implements and an assortment of other ills had brought these villagers to the little hospital Dr. Taylor, “Docta Caro”, ran in this nearly forgotten corner of Bukaso. She had just finished rounds in the men's ward and signed off on the various orders for her nurses and still had the women's and children's wards to walk.…

    • 1353 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After reading the story about Leah and Elizabeth in the book “fjdsjfdsf” by jfsdfdls, my ideas and values about a nurse were reassured. The story is about a woman named Leah, who finds out she has been diagnosed with cancer and must die leaving her son and husband behind. There is no lesson or class in life that can prepare us for life-changing moments like this, so we rely on the presence and comfort of the nurse. In this story, Elizabeth was the nurse who gave her patient comfort and ultimately allowed her to die peacefully. Activity one asks the reader to reflect on the story and ultimately, reflect on how Elizabeth eased Leah’s pain and suffering.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Now that these individuals have been shunned by society and placed into the ward, they feel that they lack the significance to stand up for themselves in opposition to the inadequately placed authority of Nurse Ratched. They are able to escape the oppression and suffering of the ward, and enter a “vegetable”-like state, “ dead” to the world (122). But McMurphy “reach[es] into the fog” and “drag[s]” the patients “blinking into the open” (124). Kesey’s metaphor illustrates that McMurphy dissipates the illusion of the fog and brings the patients to reality. He convinces them to stand up for themselves despite the oppressive force of Nurse…

    • 439 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Healing Histories Summary

    • 2049 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Throughout Canadian history, there always seems to have been a rough patch and mistreatment when it comes to the Aboriginal people. One specific example would be the implementation and operation of Indian Hospitals, a part of Canadian Health Care history some would rather forget and one that many still feel the pain of. In her novel Healing Histories: Stories from Canada's Indian Hospitals, Laurie Meijer Drees collects and documents multiple experiences from within these hospitals. By studying and comparing Marjorie Warke’s story to Marie Dick’s, I will evaluate the similarities and differences, as well as discuss how I can use this information and understanding in the future.…

    • 2049 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Wit by Margaret Edson is a play about Dr. Vivian Bearing succumbing to advanced metastatic ovarian cancer. Edson herself has said that this is a play about grace. This theme is evident in Vivian’s gradual transition from graceless intellectual to gracious cancer patient; a transition which is accompanied by her finally understanding life and death from a human perspective, rather than a scholarly one. Edson uses literary foils and mirrors, the evolution of Dr. Bearing’s character, Vivian’s fourth wall breaking interjections and flashbacks, and John Donne’s poetry as important tools to convey the theme of grace throughout Wit. Edson uses Susie and Dr. Jason Posner to exemplify Vivian’s character at different points in the play and provide comparisons as she evolves along her journey to grace.…

    • 1060 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Every nurse has the opportunity to make a positive impact on their patients and the nursing profession on a daily basis through the use of advocacy (Tomajan, 2012, Abstract section). Advocacy plays a significant role in nursing and must be demonstrated to give patients a voice when they are unable to express themselves to protect the patient’s safety and well-being. Throughout the novel A Nurse’s Story, Tilda Shalof actively demonstrated advocacy regarding her patients, which enhanced her qualities as a nurse. Advocating for a patient improves the quality of their stay at a health care facility and increases the likelihood for the patient to utilize health care services in the future. It is important for nurses to work together as a team to…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Image of the Professional Nurse As we view the media daily, we tend to see that there are many different aspects of our daily lives being portrayed either negatively or positively. The image of nursing is a very important factor because it may change people’s image on the professional nurse. The media portrays various misconceptions about nurses. However, the positive portrayals of nurses in some concepts are being revealed. This paper further explores how the image of the professional nurse is portrayed positively in the media.…

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Though they begin to see what exactly he is intending, attempting to lift his commitment. However, the patients cannot help but to see that he is becoming how they once were before he showed up, “After [McMurphy] doesn’t stand up for [them] any longer” (p. 173) The suggestion here shows how much the patients on the ward relied on McMurphy and respected him for standing up to the authorities. However, little does McMurphy know, it takes a greater toll on some of the patients.…

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Humans are a complex species. Emotions define who we are. Our ability to bond with others with sentiment and compassion is what makes us human. A human without emotions is meaningless. What is the point of life if you do not have passion?…

    • 1082 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Strength Found in Susie In the inspirational movie Wit, there are many miscues in the healthcare-client interaction and moral character within the health field towards Vivian Bearing. Vivian, a doctorate of English literature, is suffering from stage four metastatic ovarian cancer. Throughout the film, Vivian experiences terrible bedside manner from physicians, ignorance of hospital staff, and feelings of being nothing more than scientific research.…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Movie Wit

    • 1316 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The movie Wit portrays the gripping trials of a patient with terminal cancer and the ethical dilemmas health care professionals must face when treating such a disease. It follows the journey of Vivian Bearing, a middle-aged English professor who is suddenly diagnosed with stage four ovarian cancer. She agrees to undergo an experimental treatment conducted by Dr. Kelekian and Dr. Posner where she will receive a vigorous dosage of chemotherapy in attempt to combat the growing cancer cells. However, there are several unseen consequences to such treatment that evolve throughout the plot. The method of care and the physician-patient relationship play a vital role in communicating the problems of today’s health care system.…

    • 1316 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The nurse has had a clear advantage over McMurphy since she is able to hurt him and the people he is trying to save. Despite his physical pain McMurphy does his best to please everyone. For example after taking everyone on a fishing trip his friend, Bromden, describes McMurphy as an unusual kind of tired. It is clear that he cannot withstand the pain of his two conflicting ideal. The more he tries to help Bromden and his friends the further he is from his original goal which was to leave the mental ward.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    All fourteen points ensure complete and holistic care of the patient. There is an exchange that takes place between those who provide care and those cared for that goes beyond the empirical reality of the moment and incorporates the spiritual. The 'art' of providing care includes an aspect of caring that has metaphysical origins and connotations. It concerns all aspects of the human experience, physical, psychological, spiritual and social. The Gestalt approach to nursing and the inclusion of caring as a primary requisite is the heart of the concept of interactive theory as it applies to nursing and as presented by Ms. Henderson.…

    • 2852 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Great Essays