Yuan had been the general in command of the Beijing Army. He had used his military power to become a threat to the Manchu government. Over the pre-texts that his war wounds made him unsightly in court, Yuan was dismissed by Prince Chun. Then later, when the uprising in Wuhan begun, Prince Chun asked Yuan if he would take the army to sort it out. Yuan indeed looked as if he was doing that, but once he reached Wuhan he turned on the Qing and joined the revolutionists as revenge for the unkind dismissal from the court. Yuan had the loyalty of the army, so it was easy for him to do this. However he was in no sense a revolutionary. He would allow the Qing to fall, but by no means would he would not want a republic in charge either. Yuan was the one to ask the Qing to step down though and without the military support the revolution would not have necessarily easily succeeded, which in comparison to Sun was probably more efficient. This use of force would have been more effective at a quick revolution. However this again was force and thus loyalty was created by using terror, not by changing the minds of thousands of Chinese over how the culture is. Therefore in conclusion, Yuan was only a short term cause, not a long term cause as he hasn’t been trying to revolutionise China for the long term as Sun
Yuan had been the general in command of the Beijing Army. He had used his military power to become a threat to the Manchu government. Over the pre-texts that his war wounds made him unsightly in court, Yuan was dismissed by Prince Chun. Then later, when the uprising in Wuhan begun, Prince Chun asked Yuan if he would take the army to sort it out. Yuan indeed looked as if he was doing that, but once he reached Wuhan he turned on the Qing and joined the revolutionists as revenge for the unkind dismissal from the court. Yuan had the loyalty of the army, so it was easy for him to do this. However he was in no sense a revolutionary. He would allow the Qing to fall, but by no means would he would not want a republic in charge either. Yuan was the one to ask the Qing to step down though and without the military support the revolution would not have necessarily easily succeeded, which in comparison to Sun was probably more efficient. This use of force would have been more effective at a quick revolution. However this again was force and thus loyalty was created by using terror, not by changing the minds of thousands of Chinese over how the culture is. Therefore in conclusion, Yuan was only a short term cause, not a long term cause as he hasn’t been trying to revolutionise China for the long term as Sun