Similarities Between Boxer Rebellion And Taiping Rebellion

Improved Essays
Q8. The Taiping Rebellion and the Boxer Rebellion had several similarities between the two; on the other hand, they had a handful of differences. The main similarity the two shared was the fact that they were both violent uprisings located in China. Adding to this, they both used fighting in order to share their beliefs and disagreements with the way things were currently operating. The Taiping Rebellion and the Boxer Rebellion had similar means when it came to the action that took part in achieving their goals. However, they were both fighting for different changes within China. Although they both had many similarities and difference; in the end, they faced similar rises and downfalls during the time of their rebellions. The Taiping Rebellion …show more content…
The young ruler Guangxu introduced new measure to modernize China. He wanted to reorganize China's education system, strengthen the economy, modernize the military, and streamline the government. At the time, many of the Qing officials saw the modernization of China as a threat to their power. Fearing for their power, they called in the Dowager Empress to handle the current problems. The Dowager Empress immediately placed Guangxu under arrest and took over the control of the government. However, this ended up helping nothing and it brought no positive changes. Furthermore, the Chinese people's frustrations would continue to grow, this would eventually lead to the Boxer …show more content…
For example, both rebellions had occurred during the reign of the Qing Dynasty in China. Another example, after the fall of both rebellions, the government had mentioned and made efforts to reforms being made. Adding to this, after the Taiping Rebellion, the some government leaders had called for reforms patterned on Western ways. Likewise, after the Boxer Rebellion they had called for profound government changes. They believed that changing the government was the only way to help China survive. Another similarity, both rebellions were self-strengthening movements. Finally, their biggest similarity was the fact that they had both been violent uprisings in China. They decided that they best and most effective way to rebel was through acts of violence. On the other hand, these rebellions had shared a handful of key difference. The Taiping Rebellion had lasted for nearly 14 years and had killed over 20 million men in the process. On the contrary side, the Boxer Rebellion lasted an estimate of 2 years and had killed less than 500,000 men. After the defeat of the Taiping Rebellion, the Qing imperial government was left sufficiently strengthened. After the defeat of the Boxer Rebellion, the Qing government was severely weakened. However, the biggest difference between the two was their motives. The Taiping Rebellion had aimed out overthrow the Qing government, this goal had made the

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Empress Dowager Cixi (alternatively Tz’u-his) has traditionally been characterized as a powerful obstacle to reform; promulgating Qing conservatism, Manchu values and neo-Confucianism, and, throughout the second half of the 19th century, stolidly resisting political reform. However, from her return to court in 1902 to her death, a dramatic revolution in Cixi’s approach towards Western influence brought China across the threshold of the modern world with “no foot-dragging” (Cixi correspondence, First Historical Archives of China, 1996, page 1020). Though she may not have directly initiated the transition into modernity,…

    • 1695 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Chapter 22 Apush Essay

    • 2882 Words
    • 12 Pages

    CCP gave peasants reduced rents, taxes, and interest rates; they taught literacy to adults, mobilized women for the struggle and led the victory against the Japanese (the Guomindang seemed to be interested in fighting the Communists rather than the…

    • 2882 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Within the bounds of socioeconomic equality, living standards for the farmers and peasant class, and producing a government that fully captures the desires of the living class, both regimes failed. However, the decoupling of ideologies and state was more patent in the Qin Dynasty as the revolts surmounted the bureaucracy in only a few years whereas the Communist party in China has continuously adjusted its approach to governing to fit the economic needs of…

    • 1590 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The samurai and knights had many similarities and many differences. The two shared a common idea of feudal order, manners, and loyalty. Samurais and knights also agreed that training is vital to becoming an important figure. They also agreed training was important before battle. Their disagreement in battle was that that the two did not agree on the idea of gender roles in battle. Differences that arose while training children to become leaders included how long to train them. Despite their many differences, the similarities between samurais and knights were greater than their disagreements on how to live.…

    • 560 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    By the late 19th century in China, under the rule of the Qing dynasty, the effects of imperialism from western powers led to the rise of the Boxer Rebellion in China. This included the growing problems of economic disruptions on the country’s domestic industries and enterprises. Furthermore, the continuation of social grievances of poor living standards from natural disasters and the threat of Western establishment were seen as radical changes to China’s conservatism state.…

    • 74 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There were two main ideologies at the time of the Qin and Han dynasty: Legalism and Confucianism. Both these ideologies had promising outlooks at first, as they led to fairly stable governments for a short period of time, but that was until they both started showing major flaws. Those flaws, including total control and community punishment for the Legalism; The Confucian educational system and factionalizing for Confucianism. These flaws eventually led to the total dismemberment of the respective empires.…

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The force that lead to the defeat of the GMD was the Chinese liberation army who used their eight point covenant to gain the support of the masses (Chen 562). Mao’s ability to rally the masses allowed the CCP to defeat the better armed GMD in a short and bloody civil war (Karl 72). Another major key the CCP victory was the ability to use the peasantry, who viewed the CCP as their saviors, to defeat the GMD in the North of China (Karl 72). It was due the CCP giving the people, especially the lower class, a sense of hope for the future that the CCP was able to use them in their final conquest of China. An example of this hope is explained by Xie Pei-lan “If I joined the Revolution I would have my freedom,” this quote shows that the people in China believed that the CCP could give them more freedom then the GMD (Video 28:47 Xie Pei-Lan). It was the CCP’s ability to connect to the masses that allowed them to defeat the GMD and unify China under a Communist…

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Not only were they similar, they are also different in many ways as well. Over the years, the Tang dynasty defeated many other dynasties. But the Qin dynasty has…

    • 319 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Next, Qin Shihaung is a good example to how absolute kings would control the people to strengthen themselves. “The state of Qin rulers believed in a political philosophy called Legalism that justified strict centralized control and using the people to strengthen Qin,” (Qin Shihaung DI). Qin controlled countless amounts of innocent people in order to strengthen himself. He controlled what was important to the people such as their beliefs. He slowly over time controlled the people so he would become stronger. For example, Qin resembles much like Hitler. Hitler claimed Germany ruled the world and slowly over time started to blame the Jews for everything. Then Hitler would have the Jews put the Star of David on their shops so everyone would see.…

    • 188 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American Civil War took place between the Union and the Confederate and the Chinese Civil War of 1946-1949 took place between Kuomintang and the Communist Party. Both played important roles in countries’ history, the American Civil War and the Chinese Civil War of 1946-1949 have some similarity such as the effects and consequences of the war, but the purpose of the war and the treatment toward citizens during the war time are different. In fact, both the American Civil War and the Chinese Civil War of 1946-1949 are important to the unity and future development of the nation.…

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Boxer Rebellion began in 1898 in the Qing Dynasty of China. During this rebellion there was an ongoing question of which side was fighting for the more “just” outcome because each had a very different opinion of what justice was. The Boxers were fighting against the British invaders and trying to unify China by ridding it of Christian influence. The foreigners were trying to make money by selling opium to the Chinese. Each side thought the other side is evil but they did not try to understand the other side. In the book Boxers, by Gene Luen Yang, Yang tries to portray the struggle for justice that the Boxers encountered after the Opium Wars. Likewise, in the book Saints, Yang shows another side of the story. The story of a young Chinese…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In so many ways the two nations were nothing alike but yet many people still consider the two to be the same. Lenin proposed to not oppress mediums of entertainment or sources of literature but instead use them for socialistic gain. Through regulation he could ensure that only party interests were at heart. Later when the Soviet Union took control this regulation or for short propaganda was the most devastating of all soviet weapons. Soviet leaders were able to influence all of the world by connecting with people on a personal level. Mao Zedong opposed all of this in extreme ways that only added fuel to help a class schism develop. Prior to world war two Russia was already a very large nation but after the war it became even larger. The newly gained western territories were very influential when opposing developed western capitalistic societies. But keeping all that land would prove to be extremely difficult, communism conflicted with the status quo of everyday business in some of these absorbed nations. Other nations felt that they were oppressed or even being forced to renounce who they once were under threat of violence. The economy in China and Russia nearly collapsed under communism and with starvation running rampant in Russia Lenin recognized the need for some capitalistic practices. Russia 's later leader Joseph Stalin was dedicated to undermine everything the…

    • 1507 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    One comparable result of these revolutions were the execution programs that emerged from them. In France, a program called the Reign of Terror, led by Maximilen Robespierre, had started. The purpose of this program was to institute a policy of fear or terror in those who dared to counter revolt. Although this began as a period of trials against those who seemed to oppose the revolution, it quickly altered into morbid confrontations where those accused were not allowed to defend themselves. Many were killed through the use of guillotine, an execution method of beheading. The Reign of Terror caused the citizens to be fearful of their government, and ultimately caused instability in France. The most similar program China had to this was the Cultural Revolution led by Mao Zedong in 1966. At an attempt to encourage socialism and criticise academic authorities, most high school and college level boys dropped out to enforce these new ideas. These boys created their own group named the “Red Guards” and their enforcement eventually turned into execution of anyone who opposed the ideas, very similar to the Reign of Terror in France. Like France, the Cultural Revolution created an unrest Chinese society. A major difference in the outcomes of the French Revolution and the Chinese Communist Revolution was the effectiveness of the leaders that rose to power afterward. In France, a man named Napoleon Bonaparte became the leader of France, providing stability and the policy of nationalism. After the French Revolution, the nation was very vulnerable to takeover by anyone, so when Bonaparte took charge and conquered much of Europe, he was able to provide them with a very strong army, which strengthened France. Also, he was extremely nationalistic, influencing his people to be proud of their country and unintentionally made them more cooperative as a whole. This situation in France was…

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    China’s Qing Dynasty flourished during the 1800s, but by the turn of the century, its power and influence had begun to decline. By 1912, a combination of internal and external factors had caused the once glorious dynasty to collapse. European influence was one of the most prominent factors that led to the decline and eventual collapse of the Qing Dynasty. After the Opium Wars in the mid-1800s, Great Britain imposed unfair restrictions and treaties on China and took control of Hong Kong. Other European and Asian nations, like France, Germany, Russia, and Japan, soon followed suit and took advantage of China’s weakened state. By 1900, foreign countries controlled the majority of trade and military power within China. While the Qing Dynasty faced external threats from foreign countries, they also struggled to quell internal conflicts. Many people sought modernization or governmental reform, but the Qing Empress, instead of complying with the wants of these reformers, chose to execute them. An underground anti-foreigner movement, called the Boxer…

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are many reasons why Hitler and Mao were able to maintain power and the methods that were used have similarities and differences. Hitler and Mao were two authoritarian leaders that were able to rise and maintain power in the 20th century. Mao, who was a strong left-wing socialist was able to maintained his power in China. Hitler on the other hand, was a heavy right-wing fascist, and was able to maintain his power in Germany. All in all, the methods and ideologies used by both Hitler and Mao were unique to their own country, but in the overall presence, were very similar.…

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays