Steven Shapin's 'What Are You Buying When You Buy Organic'

Improved Essays
Strolling through Stop and Shop, customers always seem to lay their eyes on the organic aisle for a split second, and think "What really labels this aisle as organic? Why would I ever want to be healthy?" Some, nonetheless, walk through the aisle, picking up these overpriced products that claim to allegedly be free of artificial flavors and genetically modified chemicals; products that claim to be unlike those found in the other ten aisles of the supermarket. The article "What are you Buying When You Buy Organic," by Steven Shapin depicts the corporate food industry, specifically Earthbound Farms and how the discussion of organic produce is more of a profitable matter, than what matters most, the health of an individual. Organic food is dictionary …show more content…
Growing up, I was always taught to choose the more expensive version of a food product, as they all claim to be organic, 100% natural and free of artificial preservatives. Labels that read “No toxic pesticides or additives” would appeal to me; making me believe that I was benefiting for the amount of money I spent. Consumers, much like me, who attempt to live healthy lifestyles are now unable to know how much healthier organic food is than regular food. Shopping for produce at my local supermarket will be a a bit more challenging, for I will now question if the price reflects the nutritional value at all. Shapin’s argument thoroughly shows how the use of such pesticides allows us to be retrospectively “safer.” Since we know the supposed “risk factor” or what is more likely to be in our food, rather than the bacteria from a tractor or a horse and plow, I can agree that it would be safer to go by the use of such pesticides. Shapin’s work depicts the bias of corporate America and how our foods are not all they are made out to be. Therefore, I would like to know how corporations can be better regulated in order to stop such forms of false advertising. In addition, I agree with Shapin’s idea that “how we want our food produced and delivered are decisions about what counts as social virtue.” (435) I believe that consumers and producers should communicate with one another more, which would essentially benefit both of them, as well as society itself. If consumers knew what producers were manufacturing, consumers would be more likely to purchase it, which would help producers economically. Shapin's piece helped me realize the true meaning of natural food and how there is no way to truly eat

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    It’s really bizarre how far they will go to make profit off of a human beings purchase. Author of the essay “The Supermarket: Prime Real Estate” Explains that “low prices sound good for people without much money, but nutritionally, there’s a catch. Low prices encourage everyone to buy more food in bigger packages. If you buy more, you are likely to eat more” (Nestle, 2006, p.502). Furthermore food companies could care less about exposing people to an unhealthy lifestyle.…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Three Reasons Why You Should Be Eating Organically Have you ever been at your local grocery store and have had to choose between a lower priced product and a considerably more expensive product labeled “organic”? The product may have ranged from a meat to a produce, but whatever the product was, chances are that you went with the lower priced item just to save a couple of dollars. What if you were aware that the higher priced product is actually the better option of the two? Spending that little extra money for that organic product is worth every penny once you are aware of all the benefits that come with organic products. Thus, you should be incorporating organic food into your diet because organic food is better for your body, helps keep our environment clean, and actually tastes better.…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even though these people know what is going on, they still do not change their lifestyles. But they have good reasons, according to Michael Pollan’s reasonings in The Omnivore’s Dilemma. Pollan explains how the food corporations have “push[ed] our evolutionary buttons, fooling the omnivore’s inherited food selection system “ (107). Even though humans are not meant to eat these foods, the sensory apparatus in within humans have evolved to always crave these processed foods. It has even gotten to a point where “people with limited money to spend on food would spend it on the cheapest calories they can find” (Pollan 108).…

    • 2977 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many people are wronging informed that organic food is more nutritious said Arick. Those who eat primarily organic, naturally and locally produced diet don 't think there 's any more vitamin C in an organic tomato than there is in a conventional tomato. We eat organically because of what isn 't in the tomato, namely herbicides, pesticides and chemical fertilizers. (“What We Know, and Don’t Know About Organic Food”). Arick explained why many people are eating organics because they don’t want those toxins in their kids bodies or their own…

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The resulting income should be earmarked for a program that encourages a sound diet for Americans by making healthy food more affordable and widely available” (Bittman). Although the author has a good point because yes you could tax unhealthy food but in reality it has one fatal flaw. Taxing food because you do not want people to consume it is unconstitutional. People are free to eat whatever they want. Americans are not known for liking high taxation especially when it come to what they eat.…

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Omnivore's Dilemma Summary

    • 2472 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Because almost all of the food that I eat is supplied by large companies, I am not helping to reduce the carbon footprint through my food choices. My family and I do not go out of our way to eat food produced locally except for the food that we grow in our own garden. Some environmental impacts of supporting the industrial food system are the growing lack of diversity, chemical run-off, and growing pest-resistance. Economically, my food choices are contributing to the transformation of crops into commodities. Farmers are told to produce higher and higher yields regardless of the sacrifice of uniqueness and diversity.…

    • 2472 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This then started the whole spree of cheap food on the market because they were using cheap crops to create food the exact same way every time, and this created cheap food. The government was willing to subsidize the food system in order to create this illusion that there is cheap food available by the masses. On the other hand, almost all kinds of food is more expensive than people realize once you add up all of the environmental, societal, and health costs that go into one product. There is nothing even decent about industrialized food. The more industrialized food there is the more chance people have of becoming obese because they will not have the money to purchase healthy food or gym memberships.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Food Consumption: Kill or Save the Planet? “Eating is an agricultural act,” stated Wendell Berry in his article “The Pleasure of Eating” (630). However, it is also an ecological act. By rushing, people do not even think what they eat, how the food is made, and how this production affects the environment. Practically, we eat whatever food producers “put” in our mouths, but many manufacturers do not care about the harm caused by such production; their main concern is to generate a profit.…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When shopping for groceries, it is important to make healthy decisions. Making healthy choices is a decision based upon prices, availability, and personal preference. However, it is easy to choose the unhealthy options when the food industry is using brightly colored packaging and empty promises to lure people to purchase their food. Hence, the food industry can be seen as the main contributor to obesity. Nobody wants to be told what to eat, but with clever marketing, the food industry does not have to say a word.…

    • 1320 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although there are given benefits of using GMOs in crop production, such as longer lasting produce, easier farming practices, and more appealing crops there are also harmful effects through the consumption of these products. The negative effects we see are the ways in which GMOs can impact the health of an individual, which is evident here. This is why it is important to establish the requirement of GMO label on all food, so that we can start moving towards the right direction and hopefully get people to realize that GMOs are not necessarily good for you. To put this into perspective, these labels would force the customer to become aware of what they are eating, rather than ignoring it and eating it regardless of the fact. We believe that this…

    • 1257 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays