Steven Shapin's 'What Are You Buying When You Buy Organic'

Improved Essays
Strolling through Stop and Shop, customers always seem to lay their eyes on the organic aisle for a split second, and think "What really labels this aisle as organic? Why would I ever want to be healthy?" Some, nonetheless, walk through the aisle, picking up these overpriced products that claim to allegedly be free of artificial flavors and genetically modified chemicals; products that claim to be unlike those found in the other ten aisles of the supermarket. The article "What are you Buying When You Buy Organic," by Steven Shapin depicts the corporate food industry, specifically Earthbound Farms and how the discussion of organic produce is more of a profitable matter, than what matters most, the health of an individual. Organic food is dictionary …show more content…
Growing up, I was always taught to choose the more expensive version of a food product, as they all claim to be organic, 100% natural and free of artificial preservatives. Labels that read “No toxic pesticides or additives” would appeal to me; making me believe that I was benefiting for the amount of money I spent. Consumers, much like me, who attempt to live healthy lifestyles are now unable to know how much healthier organic food is than regular food. Shopping for produce at my local supermarket will be a a bit more challenging, for I will now question if the price reflects the nutritional value at all. Shapin’s argument thoroughly shows how the use of such pesticides allows us to be retrospectively “safer.” Since we know the supposed “risk factor” or what is more likely to be in our food, rather than the bacteria from a tractor or a horse and plow, I can agree that it would be safer to go by the use of such pesticides. Shapin’s work depicts the bias of corporate America and how our foods are not all they are made out to be. Therefore, I would like to know how corporations can be better regulated in order to stop such forms of false advertising. In addition, I agree with Shapin’s idea that “how we want our food produced and delivered are decisions about what counts as social virtue.” (435) I believe that consumers and producers should communicate with one another more, which would essentially benefit both of them, as well as society itself. If consumers knew what producers were manufacturing, consumers would be more likely to purchase it, which would help producers economically. Shapin's piece helped me realize the true meaning of natural food and how there is no way to truly eat

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The final book that really spiked with my interest and stayed with me was Michael Pollan’s “The Omnivore's Dilemma: A Natural History of Four Meals.” In this book, we followed Mr. Pollan as he explained the food that we eat in three parts, two of which we read. In Part 1 of the book I realized that our government has set us up to buy processed food in order to feed into the large companies that continue to control this nation’s economy. Consequently, as it does not care about our citizen individual health, it is my perception that if more people knew this, and if they understood that by buying more organic products, it would cause the demand to go up and the prices down, then they would.…

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A. In Michael Pollan’s informative novel, The Omnivore’s Dilemma, the author encourages the idea that food has a greater role than just filling our stomachs. He does this by informing the readers about each of the aspects in which food contributes to, such as environmental and even political roles. In doing so, Pollan separates his novel into sections; each diving deeper into an idea that some may glance over. The author, using these sections consisting of the industrial, organic, and hunting-gathering food chains, discuss the dilemma humans must face when picking their meals.…

    • 981 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For some people the way we farm today isn’t how most people would like to eat their vegetables. For example, the fertilizers and chemical sprays that farmers use over their crops were said to be used in World War II as explosives and other such weapons in the war (Pollan, pg. 898). It is a wide concern on pesticide sprays over farming crops because of the many chemicals being used. Critics believe it may possibly harm the environment and those that eat the products. In the article, “What’s Eating America” by Michael Pollan explains how mass production started and how nitrogen became a huge part of booming growth.…

    • 633 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The advantages of the modern labor and food production system, such as food labels and availability, greatly outweigh the misfortune of more genetically modified organisms. The greatest improvement of the modern food market is food labels. Though many individuals ignore this valuable information, it can be a great tool in choosing what food is the most healthful. In the 1800-1900s, a label on a can of food could claim that the…

    • 474 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The problem with the food industry today is not only the corruption that goes with it, but also the way it impacts consumers health and the environment. The food industry as a whole is unethical; using schemes to lure consumers into buying their unhealthy products, industrial farming causing destruction to ecosystems nearby, and the decline of societies overall health and awareness. In the article, “When a Crop Becomes King,” by Michael Pollan, the author describes the way corn has completely dominated the farming and food industry, and how it has negatively hurt land and local farmers. Wendell Berry introduces the point of how consumers play a crucial role in the continuation of the mistreatment and abuse of animals in his article, “Pleasures of Eating.” David Barboza in his article, “If You Pitch It, They Will Eat It,” that companies have become aggressive with their advertising, causing childhood obesity levels to skyrocket.…

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Walking into the supermarket there is a variety of choices. Those choices presented include organic food and regular or GMO food. Budgeted consumers typically choose the least expensive products, while ‘health conscious’ consumers lean towards organic products. After writing a rhetorical analysis on the film Fed Up, there were questions that came to mind. One in particular was: What are the differences between GMO foods versus organic foods and why do health conscious shoppers steer clear of GMO products?…

    • 955 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Pratichuk Sociology

    • 1744 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Final Exam Take-Home Portion SOC 341: The Sociology of Food Zoraa Lutas 1353639 With reference to class ‘Been There; Ate That’ assignments (among other materials), discuss the broader significance of micro-driven social change in the food system. “Together they (the citizens) can understand the challenges that face their local communities and develop strategies for engagement. They are able to take responsibility for a number of tasks and follow them through while recognising their rights within a larger system. By working together on a common vision, participants directly witness the strengthening of their community.…

    • 1744 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While viewing the lecture, this began to strike me as perhaps an aspect of food production that can illustrate inequality. For example, a wealthy individual could perhaps view Michael Pollen’s lecture, gain insight into their regular eating habits, change their eating habits, and perhaps be more selective about where they shop for food and where they eat food. They may even perhaps begin to shop at organic food stores and live a healthier life as a result. However, although Michael Pollen acknowledges that in some instances the cost of organic foods may be coming down, he also does acknowledge that organic or sustainable foods can in general cost significantly more than traditional corn based food products. For those who do not belong to a privileged class and wish to change their eating habits to healthier alternatives such as organic food, this can perhaps prove to be problematic.…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Omnivore's Dilemma Summary

    • 2472 Words
    • 10 Pages

    The government and large corporations demand for farmers to focus on quantity versus quality by providing subsidies and rewards for higher yields. In my first paper, I stressed the importance of health ramifications on my personal food choices. I wrote about the industrial use of chemicals, dyes, and preservatives as well as the stripping of nutrients from basic ingredients and the possibility of bacteria from feedlots. Unfortunately, my choice to support the industrial food system helps increase the threat of these health…

    • 2472 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Obesity By John Freedman

    • 1377 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Barry Estabrook, author of “Organic Can Feed the World” posted in The Atlantic, brings to the attention of his readers that there is no evidence supporting the notion that organic food cannot feed the world. He believes with the help of “locally farmed” food and a Wholefoods-esque market scattered throughout the once “food deserts”, America can turn around its obesity issue. Estabrook argues that by localizing the production for organic foods the costs of that food will decrease. Regardless if this is true or not, the amount of money, time, and effort to takes to create this elaborate system of organic food stockpiles would be astronomical in comparison to creating healthier fast…

    • 1377 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Obesity In America Essay

    • 1238 Words
    • 5 Pages

    All too often, many people living in poverty, just above poverty, and even some in the middle class are not able to afford quality, organic foods that are locally grown and made due to exorbitant prices. The prices for pre-packaged foods, produce grown with toxic pesticides, and unhealthy snack treats such as sodas and snack cakes are cheaper and more readily attainable than organic and/or locally grown and made foods. For example, a group of students and Colby College surveyed prices of various organic food and conventional food prices at five local Waterville grocery stores ranging from produce like lettuce to canned tomatoes and yogurt. Their findings showed that in every case of price, the conventional was cheaper than the organic; similar studies have been done in many college classes, laboratories, and supermarkets across the United States (Pillsbury). In addition to this there has been a recent study conducted by Newcastle University, the largest of its kind, that shows organically grown foods are indeed healthier as they hold more nutrients and antioxidants than conventional produce.…

    • 1238 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many people debate on whether organic food is actually better for you. Advocates believe organic foods are safer and more nutritious. Although organic sales have been steadily increasing, “many experts say there’s not enough evidence to prove any real advantage to eating organic foods” (“Is Organic”). Much of the organic movement has been driven by social trends and misinformation about health benefits.…

    • 431 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “What Are You Buying When You Buy Organic?” by Steven Shapin, Shapin discusses the current trend of people who are migrating to eating organic food only but also moves to dismiss any false connotations of what it truly means to be eating organic products. Shapin brings up the popular assumption that farms that claim to produce organic products are imagined to be a small family-owned business. That was not the case, as evidenced by Shapin’s article, where he pointed out that one of the biggest organic food producers, Earthbound Farm, went from a two-and-a-half-acre farm into a combined 26 thousand acres farming space. In addition, Earthbound Farm has production plants in different parts of the country which conjures up images of a large cooperate operation. (429) To keep up with the world…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Advertisement can attract anyone that it wishes, especially crowds that are gullible and believe in the first thing they see or read. We see it everyday in our lives, but we may not realize it affects our actions. In the essay, “What’s Natural about Our Natural Products?”, Sarah Federman discusses the word “natural”, how it appeals to people and how it is used by companies to lure people into buying their products. By using the word natural, companies make people, especially, the health conscious people, believe that there is a difference between a "natural" product and a regular product. Federman uses her personal experience as well as solid facts.…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    He asserts “the fact that better food — measured by taste or nutritional quality (which often correspond) — costs more, because it has been grown or raised less intensively and with more care. ”(Pollan 23). According to The Rationalization and Persistence of Organic Food beliefs in the Face of Contrary Evidence by Olson, Erik L, the authors disprove Pollan’s claim through a content analysis of 710 reader responses for a Stanford study, which objective was to examine the ‘pro-organic’ and ‘organic-skeptic’ reader comments and determine the personal impact of organic food consumption, as well as the environmental impact of organic food production. The exposure of a Stanford University meta-analysis, which concludes that organically produced foods do not offer any significant nutritional advantages, as opposed to, conventionally produced food completely refutes Pollen’s claim. The study proves that just because a food has the label “organic” on it does not mean it is significantly “healthier”.…

    • 1362 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays