Kimmel And Holler: Gender Analysis

Improved Essays
In Chapter 5 of of the Gendered Society (2011), Kimmel and Holler discuss the interactionist approach of ‘doing gender’. They discuss the arguments of Candace West and Don Zimmerman, who suggested that gender is not an inactive or fixed component, but instead it is a characteristic of an action and gender is the product of an occurring interaction (Kimmel & Holler, p.127, 2011). Kimmel and Holler (2011) argue that doing gender is a case of our biology determining which gender one will become (p.127). This relates to the social construction of gender because by determining gender we are suggesting that culture is culture creates gender roles and those gender roles are suggested to be appropriate behavior for that person of specified gender (Kimmel …show more content…
‘To do’ gender is an interactionist approach where our interaction and the physical evidence of our biological sex determines our socialized gender roles (Kimmel & Holler, p.127, 2011). Male genitalia and female genitalia classify the two sexes into different genders thus assuming they have differing personalities, which would necessitate diverse institutional and social characteristics to acclimatize to their social differences (Kimmel & Holler, p.127, 2011). Relating gender inequality and gender difference suggest also play a major responsibility in what it means to ‘do gender’. The case of Agnes, as discussed by Kimmel and Holler (p.131, 2011) further cements the idea that our primary sex characteristics does not determine our gender alone, because in this case Agnes was in every way a girl, but she did have a penis. Even with this ‘biological mistake’, as she referred to it, Agnes continued to always believe she was a girl, that genitals did not represent her femininity, instead Agnes referred to her breasts and her ‘lifelong sense’ that she was a female, as the signs of her femininity (Kimmel & …show more content…
After using my own everyday life as a source to draw examples of doing gender, I see that, “We create and recreate our own gendered identities within the contexts of our interactions with others and within the institutions we inhabit (Kimmel & Holler, p. 132,

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    “Gender role socialization assumes that individuals observe, imitate, and eventually internalize the specific attitudes and behaviors that the culture defines as gender appropriate by using other males and females as role models”(Shirley A. Hill 2002:494). Gender roles are learned in society by internalizing them and then applying them. Since gender is socially constructed, people have a perception of gender roles which partakes place in peoples everyday norms. Gender is systematically in our society in different ways. Gender roles are systematic because the expectations on behaviors become a chain in society.…

    • 1027 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Gender Identity Definition

    • 1479 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Social psychology states that gender expression is based on an individual's personal and relational coherence (Alegria & Ballard-Reisch, 2013). Rather than focu3sing on the biological and physical attributes of gender, social psychology aims to focus on the range of characteristics and behaviors that impact one's gender identity (Alegria & Ballard-Reisch, 2013). A distinguishing theory that highlights the social psychological perspective of gender is the concept of doing gender. Doing gender is a theory that states that gender is integrated into everyday interaction and language (Thanem & Wallenberg, 2016; Risman, 2009). While the concept of doing gender understands the sociological and symbolic interaction in gender identity, Risman emphasizes the importance in which society's changing values in gender impact the nature of doing gender (2009).…

    • 1479 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Society perceives gender as two specific categories, male and female. Yet, each gender has a prominent body part that distinguishes the two. However, ‘Of Gens and Gender’ by Anne Fausto-Sterling and ‘The Courtship of Mr. Lyon’ by Angela Carter illustrate the relationship between gender and the body. Sterling focuses on the innate genes to determine the gender of a person; while, ‘The Courtship of Mr. Lyon’ develops the representation of the body to determine the action of the characters in the story. ‘The Courtship of Mr. Lyon’ illustrates Sterling’s theory to adapt the biological genes in order help establish the character’s difference in gender.…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    She says that gender is maintained as a process, and as part of a stratified and structured system; which has caused gender to be “so pervasive that in our society we assume it is bred into our genes”. Lorber’s excerpt concludes, stating that, gender inequality “is produced and maintained by identifiable social processes and built into the general social structure and individual…

    • 1880 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gender Definition

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Specifically, as said by Judith Lorber in her article “the Social Construction of Gender,” such gender norms are “enforced through informal sanctions of gender inappropriate behavior and by formal punishment by peers of by threat of punishment by those in authority should behavior deviate too far from socially imposed standards for women and men,” (Lorber 143). This punishment bullies dissentients of the gender norm into accepting their fate as dealt by society, alongside fueling the cycle of reinforcing gender stereotypes and crushing non conformity. I find Lorber’s statement of communal penalties being a tool of perpetuating social convention to be agreeable with my definition of…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Although the words sex and gender are often used interchangeably, they have two different meanings from a sociological perspective. Sex is a biological characteristic that determines whether someone is a male or a female (Carter 2011). Gender, however, is socially constructed based on definitions as to what is “masculine” or “feminine” (Carter 2011). This paper delves into the social forces that can influence gender in any culture. Social forces include anything that is a part of the social environment such as organizations, group memberships, family, and the media.…

    • 1868 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gender Identity: Biologically Inevitable or Sociologically Imposed? Today in society, gender identity is becoming a prominent topic of discussion. Many people believe that the attributes associated with a specific gender are deep rooted and established prematurely. From the time that a child is born their gender roles and personalities in life are predestined just by the term, “It’s a ___!” There are two major theories that have explanations for this phenomenon. In “The Early Development of Gender Differences,” Matthew H. McIntyre and Carolyn Pope Edwards present a biological perspective to explain the inevitability of gender identity.…

    • 823 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The field of gender studies is an area of interdisciplinary study that analyzes the social aspect of gender and how it relates to different subcategories of life. It explores what it entitles to be female or male; and the experiences a person may encounter due to their gender, sexuality, race, class, etc. Because gender studies analyzes the social aspect of gender, it coherently applies to the subcategory of gender in the workplace. In most fields and professions gender has an effect on the way an individual is treated; and depending on the discipline it may have a greater weight in certain fields than in others. Nursing is one of the many fields where the understanding of gender studies can help you relate and identify why there is gender inequality within the field of nursing.…

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The concept of gender is central the construction of the body and sexuality in contemporary cultural studies. Gender is a complex matter, as modern representations of what it means to be a gendered and sexed body is internalized and acted upon differently depending on one’s culture and upbringing. Across cultures, gender and identity are intimately tied as something that should be viewed as an expression of ones individuality. However, this is rarely the case. Through the use of sociological theories of gender I will observe how the body is prescribed with masculine and feminine identities through cultural processes and socialisation.…

    • 2002 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    How does Culture Affect Gender and Personality Cultural influences affect gender and personalities for several reasons. Cultural influence is important and occurs in all communities in the United States of America. Some people say that culture influence and personalities should make individual decisions super on certain societies. Some say that culture influence and gender hinder self-expression. However, we can look at culture influences, gender, and personalities in term of how we study difference gender roles in our societies, how we study difference culture in our societies, and how we can study the difference personalities in our societies.…

    • 1643 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays

Related Topics