Sleuthing The Alamo Analysis

Improved Essays
In his book, Sleuthing The Alamo, James E. Crisp goes beyond the mere description of the historical events that took place during the Texas Revolution. Crisp’s passion to uncover why certain events of the Texas Revolution were remembered in a specific way, propelled him to closely examine and critically analyze the motive behind a number of writers and historians. It was this determination that forced Crisp to take no for an answer and to “attempt to separate Texas myth from Texas history”. What makes Crisp’s book Sleuthing The Alamo so unique, in contrast with most historical books, is that Crisp involves himself in his text in such a way that it becomes very personal to him. Additionally, Crisp doesn’t conceal his own personal biases as …show more content…
While the popular and most accepted belief was that Crockett died heroically in battle (as was clearly depicted in numerous films), the emergence of a diary written by Enrique de la Peña, a Mexican officer, who claimed “to be an eyewitness to the capture and execution of Davy Crockett in the immediate aftermath of the Battle of the Alamo” was about to send shockwaves to the historical circles. The first source that Crisp analyzed was Bill Groneman’s Defense of a Legend: Crockett and the de la Peña Diary. Groneman, a police detective and a historian, who latter would become one of Crisp’s lifelong colleagues, argued that the de la Peña diary was a forgery, thus the claim of Crockett surrendering was not accurate. The controversy surrounded Crockett’s death intrigued Crisp, who later on uncovered that de la Peña manuscripts came from J. Sánchez Garza, who had privately published them under the title La Rebelión de Texas: Manuscrito Inédito de 1836 por un Oficial de Santa Anna. After carefully studied Garza’s publication, Crisp felt that they were more questions raised than answered. Upon more digging, he discovered that de la Peña had written two separate manuscripts while he was imprisoned so Crisp arranged to get both copies and study them meticulously. Additionally, a second description of Davy Crockett’s execution, which would to be known as the “Dolson Letter” was accidentally discovered by a Rice University graduate student, would come to reinforce the claim that Davy Crockett surrendered rather than died fighting. After examining and analyzing all the sources Crisp could master, he concluded that based upon all the evidence, Crockett most likely surrendered, after General Castrillón promised him a safe conduct, but was condemned to death by an infuriated Santa

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Imagine enjoying the comforts of one's home; simply dining with the family protected by any and every outside discomfort. Then imagine deciding to leave this behind in efforts to defend a nation that great patriotic feelings have been developed towards.. Author and professor, James M. McCaffrey, wrote the well researched book Army of Manifest Destiny: The American Soldier in the Mexican War, 1846–1848 to portray the war in the “viewpoint of the common soldiers’ experience” (xii). Most authors simply write regarding where the battles took place and who was in charge. McCaffrey, however, zooms in to what actually went on as having a life of a soldier.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout 1832, Davy farmed lawyer supported by Jackson and by Governor Carroll of Tennessee, by 252 votes. Building in part upon his growing notoriety, Crockett defeated the incumbent Fitzgerald in 1833 to return to Congress. In 1835 he was again defeated. Disgusted, he is quoted as saying, “You can all go to Hell and I’m going to Texas.” Much of the same material spilled over into the first few issues of a series of comic almanacs published under Crockett's name from 1835 to 1856 that, as a whole, constituted a body of outrageous tall tales about the adventures of the legendary Davy rather than the historical David Crockett.…

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On May 2, Stonewall Jackson unwittingly got shot by one of his own men while in battle at Chancellorsville,Virginia. Saturday night, at the Battle of Chancellorsville, Tom Jackson, a Lieutenant General of the South, got shot by one of his own men while they were planning a night attack. When the surgeon arrived he decided that Jackson had blood clots in his wound. The surgeon had to act fast or the Union would come and attack them. On the way to the field hospital, the doctors decided that they would have to amputate Jackson’s arm because of the cut artery by the bullet.…

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the book Sleuthing The Alamo, James E. Crisp focuses on trying to uncover hidden truths with regards to the Battle in 1836. In his prologue, he argues in which he states that very little of what has been published on the Texas Revolution and Alamo can be trusted, and it is worth understanding. He wrote about his investigation on Sam Houston’s speech that he makes to the soldiers at Refugio. Crisp was determined to investigate Houston’s speech because he noticed that his speech was not even in correlation to his actions. Almost like everything Houston stood for was a contradictory in a way.…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Appomattox Summary

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Within the book the author gives a brief history of the battle, deceptions and movements of both Confederate and Union armies prior to Lee’s surrender at Appomattox. After this brief history, she gives a detailed account…

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Ethan Kolodny Mr. Delear Hist 2301 9/13/2014 Davy Crockett vs Texas Pride After the Great Depression in America, the people were climbing out of the whole that the Great Depression dug into their society. Americans were looking to start new lives, and build a better foundation of America. At this time, he T.v. was becoming incorporated into peoples everyday lives around the world.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Apostles of Disunion, Charles Dew discusses how he originally thought that states’ rights were the predominant reason that the Civil War occurred. This point of view stemmed from his readings as a boy and his ancestor’s experiences with the war. The central idea behind the authors writing of the book is his analysis of the letters and speeches that the secession commissioners wrote, in which he sought the reasons other than states’ rights to their secession from the Union. Correspondingly, he argues for the centrality of race and slavery as the reasons for the South’s secession. What’s more, is the reasoning behind why the author is writing this book and his projected achievements from doing so.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Palo Duro Canyon History

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The significance of the battle I have chose not only made Texas safer, but it also gave birth to our states national park! My bucket list dream is to travel the United States and to see all major historical landmarks. Without the Battle of Palo Duro Canyon, the Texas-Indian War would not have ended. Of course history would take a different course to have eased these tensions had this battle not occurred, but it certainly would not be as epic of a tale as the one written about in this paper. Palo Duro Canyon is the most dynamite and beautiful scene highlight in the Panhandle of Texas.…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    A Line in the Sand is a written documentary created by Randy Roberts and James S. Olson in which analyzes several aspects of one of the most famous events in Texas history, the battle of the Alamo. The battle of the Alamo was and has been controversial in that very little is known about what exactly happened during the siege. It was an event that caused a massive uproar during the Texas revolution and it also added more ire and will to succeed to the rebels at the time. The Alamo in blood in memory is the subtitle of the book and it implies that the event had left an imprint in Texas history and influenced the future and what Texas would become. In blood the Alamo will be remembered to some as a massacre, to others as a siege, and to others…

    • 1508 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Mexican War Dbq Analysis

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The mexican war started in 1945 when the annexation of Texas took place. After the annexation , Mexico and America had a disagreement on what the border of Texas was. The U.S. thought that the border was the Rio Grande , while Mexico thought it was the Nueces River. This quarrel then led to the war , the prize being the land. The United States was justified in going to war with Mexico because America believed in manifest destiny and that God gave them the land to overspread and also because 16 Americans were killed by Mexicans on American territory.…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The review of the book Sam Houston and the American Southwest highlighted that it is a scholarly account written by an expert on the role and impact of Sam Houston’s leadership in Texas, and the wider region. The author’s role as the author of the account is not questionable, the presentation of information is highly articulate, and the evidence provided supported the thesis of the book sufficiently. From the reviews made about the book, it is apparent that it is a research-based account of Sam Houston and his impact. Tucker, S. 2013. Almanac of American military history.…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When I picture the Civil War, I picture people fighting in a field and Abraham Lincoln delivering triumphant speeches of freedom and emancipation. Not often do I think about the desperate human struggle for survival in POW camps, the brutal journey many took to escape slavery, or the hundreds of dead bodies that lay mutilated after brutal battles. In the graphic history Battle Lines, by Jonathan Fetter-Vorm and Ari Kelman, such realities and human experiences are visually portrayed. In order to tell these stories, the authors ground each chapter with an object and a story. By centering each chapter around an object, the authors place a great importance on each item and draw a connection between the experience of the individual and the experience…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sleuthing The Alamo In the Rhetorical analysis, Sleuthing The Alamo, James E. Crisp dives head long into an extensive evaluation of the events, people, and historical stories of the Alamo. As he began his research he stumbled across a speech written and given by Sam Houston. Houston is a well acknowled man in both Texas and U. S. history with a reputation for fairness, and being and all around good wholesome man with a polished set or morals. Upon reading a statement Houston made to his men Crisp felt as if something were wrong.…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Annexation Of Texas Essay

    • 2045 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The Annexation of Texas The annexation of Texas by the United States remains a controversial topic to this day. Occurring in 1845, it caused a great uproar amongst the citizens of the United States and Texas. The main question when debating the annexation of Texas is how it affected slavery. Indeed, and because the annexation of slavery served to extend the area in which slavery would be allowed, this caused a situation in which it shifted the balance of power away from the North and towards the South in relation to the question of slavery.…

    • 2045 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It was hard for the Mexican people to not think it was a plot by the Americans to steal Texas right from under…

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays