Analysis: Why Student Athletes Should Not Be Paid

Improved Essays
One of the hottest debates in the sports world is whether or not college athletes should get a cut of the revenue they produce for their school. Men’s basketball and Football players produce billions of dollars a year through television contracts for their schools, so why don’t they get a percentage of the profit? Recently, star basketball player for Wisconsin, Nigel Hayes was on College Gameday and held up a sign that said “Broke college athlete, anything helps” and the sign had a referral to his venmo account “BrokeBadger”(Hoffer) . Nigel Hayes gives his heart and soul playing basketball for the University of Wisconsin and he does not even have enough money to eat. Another example for this is Shabazz Napier, who said he went to bed hungry …show more content…
For example, The John E. Jaqua Academic Center for Student Athletes at the University of Oregon is a “sparkling glass and stainless steel building and is 40,000 square feet of spaces to facilitate college education for student athletes” (Chudacoff). Most student athletes at major college programs are accommodated with buildings like the one at Oregon. Chudacoff claims that not only do student athletes get to learn in the best facilities, they also receive full scholarships for their school and have no debt after they graduate. Many students straight out of college usually find themselves in debt, but student athletes do not have that problem because they receive full scholarships. Also student athletes receive a bunch of free clothing from major companies, such as Adidas, Nike, or Under Armor (Chudacoff). He points out that these companies not only provide student athletes with jerseys but also clothing of their choice for no charge (Chudacoff). The author states that student athletes, mainly those who play basketball or football receive high quality medical care and the newest weight and conditioning equipment (Chudacoff). They have the best treatment available for their injuries. For example, in 2009, Baylor star quarterback Robert Griffin III tore his ACL and his surgery was performed by Dr. James Andrews, who is known as one of the best sports …show more content…
So they do not really know what is like to be in people like Nigel Hayes or Shabazz Napier’s shoes. On the other hand I believe that student athletes should be paid. I believe this because of my personal experiences. In high school, I devoted my whole life to golf. I played all four years in high school and know how much time and energy it takes to be a student athlete. On average, I probably spent 4 hours a day practicing. That is 28 hours a week and on top of that I had school work. I am not trying to say that high school athletes should be compensated at all but I do believe college athletes should because playing sports is like having a full time job and on top of that they also have to keep up their grades in the classroom. Another reason I believe that college athletes should be paid is that more athletes would stay in school longer to get their degrees. One thing Chudacoff and Scott may have not considered is that many basketball players play one year in college and then declare for the draft because they need the money. In 2015 only 1.1% of all draft eligible NCAA men’s basketball players were drafted. (NCAA) If they are paid many student athletes would stay in school longer, develop their skills more and more athletes would earn a degree. That degree is very important because less than 1 percent of college athletes actually make it to the pros and they

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Although many athletes are given scholarships, they still can fall in debt to other things such as books, living, and extras. Meshefijian stated, “In the past twelve years, the amount of money generated by sports has increased nearly 300%” (par. 3). Student athletes lose the opportunity to have a job for a majority of their time because they are preoccupied by games, practices, conditioning, and on top of that they must also be a full time student and maintain a GPA that keeps them eligible to participate in their sport. College scholarships can only support a student for so much. Earning a salary would substitute the money they would be earning if they were able to have a job.…

    • 1767 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    The only ones not cashing in, it seems, are the player themselves. " This does not seem fair that the ones who are making the money are not receiving any of the money. Greg Johnson, sports editor at The Daily Targum, and StudentNation, organization who give first-person accounts from student activists, organizers and journalists reporting on youth-oriented movements for social justice, economic equality and tolerance, says, "Coaches and athletic directors can negotiate million-dollar contracts, billions are available for installing state-of-the-art facilities, but the whole enterprise hinges on maintaining an arbitrary benefit to the student athletes. " Supporters of the notion that college athletes should not be paid argue that there are problems with payment. Johnson, who spent sixteen years working in the School of Sport Sciences at Wingate University (NC), and Acquaviva, professor of sports science at Wingate University (NC) say that refuters ask the questions "how much should the athletes get paid and will payments be based on performance?…

    • 1639 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    two recent rulings may change the face of college sports, “ Shabazz Napier the point guard for the University of Connecticut stated, "There are nights that I go to bed and I'm starving. " This is as problem that could be solved if college athletes were…

    • 1453 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Due to NCAA rules, athletes have not been allowed compensation for their participation in college athletics. This rule has caused a great divide and debate within the collegiate sport world, especially with the recent exponential growth of college athletics. For instance, college sports critics Val Ackerman and Larry Scott argue “that college is ultimately about getting a degree and getting ready for life long after their playing days are over” supporting their claim that college athletes should not be paid (Ackerman and Scott). Opposing that view is the idea that college athletics offer exactly those benefits and more, which would be maximized with payment. As of right now, college athletes are being compensated through scholarships that average…

    • 319 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Should NCAA athletes be paid by Alexis molina I fully think that NCAA athletes should be paid for their effort on their college team. College athletics have gained immense popularity among Americans over the past few decades. This has resulted into increased in a lot of money for the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) and the participating colleges, which has sparked the debate of whether college athletes should be given money beyond their athletic scholarships but I think they should get paid for the following reason they should be paid because without the players that risk injuries on the team the association would not make the money they do now and their coaches get paid but why not them and most importantly students after…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Paid Student Athletes

    • 1489 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Pay for Play? Dave Anderson, Laura Freedman, Lee Goldman, and Peter Goplereus III have all written articles on whether or not the NCAA should pay their student athletes. Their articles, “Top 10 Reasons College Athletes Should be Paid”, “Pay or Play”, “Should College Athletes Be Paid”, and “No Control Over Their Rights” all provide many reasons as to why student athletes deserve payment. The NCAA is in the wrong for accepting “free labor” from these athletes. Although many student athletes are on scholarships, often times it is not enough, so they deserve fair compensation.…

    • 1489 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This validates that even the top colleges in the U.S. that play in the biggest college tournament don’t get paid when they are the cause that brought all of the money in. Another example that proves that athletes don’t get paid is the Louisville Cardinal basketball team. According to Chris Smith from Forbes, the Cardinals are the highest paid college basketball team in the whole nation earning just about 45.1 million dollars, but with all of this money the players are not getting paid for their hard work. Finally, this proves that college athletes bring all of the revenue, and they don’t get paid…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over the past couple decades, college athletics have increased their popularity tremendously. The increase in popularity has led to a surplus of revenue brought to each of the Universities and the National Collegiate Athletics Association (NCAA). Last year Oregon had a revenue of $196,030,398 and not a single player was compensated for the work they did on those sports teams (Berkowitz para. 1).…

    • 1460 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many people have recently raised controversy on the subject of whether college athletes should be paid or not. The student athletes feel they should be paid for their performance on the field due to the fact that they spend most of their free time on the field or court practicing the sport they love and they cannot afford to manage school, sports, and a healthy sleep life style on top of working to be able to afford things. College athletes should not be paid for their performance on the field. The student athletes should not be paid to play because they are in school for education, this could cause issues for colleges with auctioning, this can cause money problems for the student athletes, and sports are not a job they are a choice. Student…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most of these athletes are getting everything paid for including their tuition, meals, and housing. If they were to be paid on top of that, what would be the point of trying to do good in school. The money to these athletes would out weigh getting good grades and would in turn hurt education. The whole point of being good at a sport in a collegiate level is to reward the athlete with an education and a college university. Rewarding them with a salary also would further demonize college sports.…

    • 1695 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Forbes argued athletes are “core members of their university’s marketing teams” (Martin 1.) This leads to the argument expanding. 43 hours a week is what most adults work. On top of 43 hours of practice and games, these athletes have school and homework which in unbelievable at such a young age to handle. Not only are they doing all that but most of these kids are also living on their own for their first time which is a huge step in life that they are learning.…

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The average American works a little over 40 hours a week, while student athletes spend 43.3 hours working and training. So they work more than the average American yet are not even paid, but they generate millions for their universities. If you believe athletes are being paid in scholarships and their free education, but they are not able to use it to their full promised value because of the requirement of their colleges and the NCAA such as where athletes are not allowed to take more challenging courses which sets up athletes up for failing later in life because a tiny percent of athletes go pro.. The average student athlete misses a quarter of all their classes during the year because of the need to travel for sports contests. So they arent really given the whole value of the scholarship.…

    • 1302 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Problem Of Paying Student Athletes

    • 2586 Words
    • 11 Pages
    • 5 Works Cited

    This results in many people trying to sue the NCAA because they believe this isn’t fair but that is another discussion. College athletes deserve to be paid based on all they do for their university. Works Cited Edwards, Harry. “Share the Wealth” 16 December 2011. Web.…

    • 2586 Words
    • 11 Pages
    • 5 Works Cited
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    College is a time to prepare those for a career that lies ahead where they will make a living. Scholarships are already paying athletes to represent their school. A vast majority of schools are not making a profit off their athletic programs, and have no way to pay their athletes. There also would be no way in determining how much each athlete deserves to get paid. All in all, there are too many uncertainties when it comes to this topic.…

    • 1302 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The article, “The Case for Paying College Athletes,” by Allen Sanderson and John Siegfried, seeks to provide an in-depth analysis of compensating college athletes. Specifically, Sanderson and Siegfried analyze the history of the NCAA and its governance, the reasons for operating commercialized sports programs, the market for college athletes, the NCAA’s power, the distributional aspects of change, and finally, how changes will arrive (Sanderson & Siegfried, 2015, p. 115-137). The authors begin with a description of both the history and governance of the NCAA. The NCAA was established in 1906, resulting from President Roosevelt’s advocacy to improve the safety of players (Sanderson & Siegfried, 2015, p. 117).…

    • 1125 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays