Religion Gives Meaning To Life By Louis P. Pojman

Good Essays
Critical Analysis Paper # 3
Analysis of “Religion Gives Meaning to Life,” by Louis P. Pojman
Introduction:
In this article, “Religion Gives Meaning to Life,” Louis P. Pojman believes that religion, but mainly a theistic religion gives purpose and meaning to life. Pojman feels that, since people cannot prove that theism is true or not true, then therefore, people should live like theism is true. A world with theism, living life following a higher being would be a better world than living a life of self-governing, autonomy. Lastly, Pojman believes that living in autonomy is not really affected by having a religion or faith but instead religion may help everyone’s autonomy because they will have more purpose for their personal goals. On page
…show more content…
They would have no reason to help and care for others because their main priority would be themselves. This will allow people to do good things for others but also this would allow people to kill, steal and destroy whatever and whoever they want without any consequences. This correlates with one of Pojman’s example situations about living in autonomy and living with theism. Situation A is about people being as free as possible but they are in a large room with poisoned gas that is slowly filling the room. Although they still have their freedom, they will die sooner. This shows that people will be able to do what they desire but slowly poverty, crime, and death will increase because there is no moral guidance nor boundaries on what the people should. That is why if secularism was true and theism was false, life would possibly be better with a higher …show more content…
Autonomy allows people to gain their own personal goals, yet it can lead to destruction and chaos. Majority of the people would not want to live in poverty or always having to keep their guards up because it would be easy for anyone to steal or try to kill them for things of great expense or less. Freedom is great but not at expense of losing one’s life. On the contrary, living in a theistic life, people have a meaning to why they are on earth because it is given or shown to by their higher being with a good promised ending for everyone. In order to get this great promise from their higher being, a person will to give up some of their freedom, which would include things that would harm themselves or others. There is also the comfort in knowing that God loves and cares for all people and has a plan for their lives. This is not only good morally but good for the community of people, to actually help one another to achieve personal goals together. This helps prevents people from wanting to do bad or evil things to get what they want and makes it safer for everyone. This also correlates with Pojman’s other example of situations living with theism or autonomy. In situation B, Pojman discusses having a purpose and giving up a little freedom in order to eliminate great sufferings in the world. A theistic world would be better for everyone spiritually and

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    With moral codes it is much easier to relate to some people. Virtue Ethics can simply help us because becoming a better person as individual and have a positive impact on our lives. Hopefully one person at time can make a large group of virtuous people, it is said this could not happen but with faith maybe someday it could happen. People need to stop being selfish and start to care about other people. Once people truly stop being selfish and fully understand the virtues of ethics they can they make ethical…

    • 971 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Even if Jim had made a promise to not kill anyone, he would be able to break it in this situation because it would maximize the happiness of the greater good. There are always exceptions to the rules of utilitarianism. An action for a utilitarian that is morally right is one that is decided based on outcomes and consequences. Looking at Jim’s situation from an impartial view, only one prisoner will have pain along with Jim experiencing some pain in having to kill someone. But, that pain fails to outweigh the happiness, or pleasure, that will come from the other 19 prisoners and Jim all being saved.…

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    One thing for a society like Utopia to work would need to include no selfishness, greed, or anything of the such. Ideally, everything would be perfect because everybody has everything, but the concept of corruption would ruin the chances of such from getting far. People would want to cheat the system by taking the easy route and leave hard work for others. The innovation for new ideas and technology would be declined as there is no incentive to improve or make higher quality items as everybody gets anything they would want. The process of transforming to this lifestyle would require much dedication and most likely a fresh start due to people’s formed values, opinions, and greediness.…

    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Some of them filled with ego and selfishness and some are kind hearted and selfless people, both are there. Morality or justice plays a pivotal role in our society to maintain the balance and peace among society and also makes a society a better place to live. If the whole society is immoral or unjust then there would be a chaos and it will become worthless to live there. Morality, we can call it norms but which are innate by nature note learned or it is kind of reinforcement by teaching. People don’t do injustice because they have fear of law or they don’t want listed their name in the criminal records, otherwise if the government give free rights to do what ever they want to do, they are just afraid of consequences of getting caught or acting unjustly .…

    • 1406 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    We also need to not try to be like somebody else. Being yourself helps to be a genuine person who can reflect positivity into the world. Staying true to ourselves helps us finding focus and understanding our core values and what we find important. Another mentioned point is bringing a positive attitude to every situation. Negativity only hurts us and others.…

    • 1310 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    As we go on in having our selfishness we also have problems in terms of willingness to participate and cooperate with each other without asking anything in return. This philosophy is the ideal thinking. Most people thought of refusing to accept that this saying was impossible to proclaim with. We are born for a specific purpose, and for that reason itself comes with a greater expectation from others in return. The only difference would be, either that purpose should be expected as a personal gain or for a bigger picture that in the end, more individuals besides yourself will benefit from it.…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Though some may judge one’s past errors, people should show their true selves to the world because people are more likely to find happiness in life when they are being honest. Hiding one’s identity ultimately prevents one from finding self-fulfillment in life. Dimmesdale…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Some will question the suffering of an innocent child because of the parents. It is also a road to heaven for the child. Death isn’t always bad, it is a natural occurrence. There are possibilities that the person is in a better place now and would’ve had to suffer more on Earth. Our sufferings are different but it is there to teach us something in order to live a better life.…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Denzel Washington actions do not do this. His actions to steal money, and commit adultery caused many people to suffer so his choices were clearly wrong. Ethan Hawke may have suffer in the beginning because of his moral decision but in the long run it will benefit from those choices. He most likely will be a better cop, not be hated and chase down by bad guys and live and more happy and long life. So in the cause of Ethan Hawke character he made the best choice that would give him and people around him the least amount of suffering and negative…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It will create a world where people care and love each other and no one wishes anyone else to suffer like they may have, suffering also makes a man sympathetic towards the ones who are suffering, Finally, suffering should not be seen as a punishment but as a blessing by God, without suffering we would not be able to appreciate all that is given to us. Suffering will only lead to better…

    • 1269 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays