Pros And Cons Of Pro Immigration Policy

Superior Essays
Refutation for immigration policy: Part 3 of 3

There are some major concerns about increased immigration and its implementation, and that has led to various types of objection to the policy. Following the same logic used in favor of immigration, it is possible to discredit these arguments that many people, especially those who have a misunderstanding of the principle of pro-immigration policy frequently use. Commonly cited objections include the risk of increased crime from immigrants, wage depreciation, and increased strain on government social welfare programs.
Abuse of government benefits is many opponents’ primary concern. Undocumented immigrants are technically ineligible for government benefit programs, but many take advantage of them
…show more content…
Policy opponents often fear that many immigrants just come to the United States for the infrastructure and will not be contributing members to society. What they may find surprising is that the current legislation governing immigration has a clause against “public charges.” This clause bars visa applicants who are deemed liable to become a public charge, as well as enables deportation of immigrants who become public charges after admission (Immigration and Nationality Act, Simon 95). The problem is that along with other enforcement measures, this clause has been disregarded. Proper immigration policy should increase the amount of immigrants allowed, but also make sure that the only people entering the country are those approved immigrants. Part of that job is thorough screening of prospective immigrants, which ensures the flow of immigrants will benefit both the immigrants and the nation. Potential problems of public charges can be addressed through already established avenues if legislation is enforced properly. Today’s data analytics could be usefully employed to detect liable immigrants during screening. To some, screening for people who are likely to become a drain on society may seem unhumanitarian, but someone who can hold a job (including low wage manual labor) should be able to qualify, and those who try to come to the U.S. due to circumstances in their home country but may be a …show more content…
While some of these arguments are motivated by nativism, most are concerned for the well being of the current citizen population over that of potential citizens, and have these priorities inform their policy opinions. While economic research suggests that immigration has an unequivocally positive effect on native welfare, it is a natural behavioral response to economic troubles. Researchers at Arizona State found that attitudes towards immigrants grew more negative as GDP growth slowed (Diaz 307-10). Other psychologists found that when confronted with economic stress and the prevalence of another people group (immigrants, in this case), natives tend to adopt a “zero-sum” view of the economy (Esses 134). If the national economy was a zero-sum game, then every job filled by an immigrant would be one taken from a native citizen. But the job market and economy in the United States, as outlined in the arguments above, are not zero-sum games: immigrants make goods more affordable which leads to savings for natives, more growth in industry, and job creation. Many economists cite the fact that most immigrants do not compete for the same jobs as natives, as entry level immigrants tend towards manual labor jobs, while established natives tend towards less labor intensive jobs, like jobs in communications (McHenry 35, Ottaviano 27). Immigration can ultimately be seen as

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Obama's Immigration Reform

    • 1475 Words
    • 6 Pages

    By taking the representation of immigrants on the voter districts then it 'll affect the states that have a high amount of non-citizens. This will be a negative effect on some Floridians politicians who might face this situation when it comes to voting and voter population. "The regulations ensure that voting districts are not drawn to disenfranchise minority populations." (Morrison, 2015). The new changes will let the districts count immigrants as voters.…

    • 1475 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It would help regulate illegal immigrants while helping the ones in America whom work here. This bill would also look good for many other reasons. It would show that America is a welcoming place for immigrant workers. America would be working to be inclusive without letting down their defense. They would strengthen their defense while giving people an easier obtainable path to…

    • 2318 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Solving the problem is the hard part. Some people want to keep immigrants out while others completely, while others want the U.S let immigrants in freely. However, both of these solutions will only bring more problems. If we keep immigrants out completely, then the economy will feel the burden due to lack of field workers (Zavodny). If we keep letting more immigrants come into the U.S, then there will be too many workers and not enough jobs (Zavodny).…

    • 950 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Also, many believe a reform will undermine the current immigration laws and those who waited for a legal visa to enter the United States. If another immigrant in another country had to wait to migrate to America legally, why should an immigrant who came here illegally get to stay too? To some, it is simply just not fair to pass an immigration reform bill. Another concern for those against a reform bill is that immigrants take jobs that could otherwise go to natural-born Americans. Since most immigrants are willing to work at such low wages, most employers prefer hiring them over American workers who will eventually demand a higher wage.…

    • 1279 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    There was a study done in 2012 from the Center of American progress, which stated various reasons how legalizing immigrants in our economy will help improve the GDP for our country and in fact if it happens it will also not hinder it. Surprisingly, the statistics from the article stated, that at least 453 billion would be deducted annually from the GDP if the illegal immigrants were to be deported (Americanprogress.org). Then, if for some unexpected reason, it was decided to be acceptable to deport every single unauthorized person. Then, it would cost an astronomical price over a period of time. I’m thinking during this economic crisis, unnecessary money should not be spent on just the fact that people are here unauthorized.…

    • 1908 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This Nation consists of a melting pot of race and culture primarily due to immigration. Many individuals perceive immigration with a negative connotation. However, the problems do not reside with the people who persist on trying to come in to America but the process of doing so. The policies to obtain a visa should be changed because the process last too long. Trying to receive U.S. citizenship holds in a matter of who gets lucky.…

    • 1632 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Illegal Immigrants

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages

    If illegal immigrants were to be deported, other Americans would have to take the places of these people. To make up for the loss of unskilled, undocumented workers in the country, better-educated workers than ones who only have a high school diploma would be drawn into less skilled jobs (Perryman). This yields negative consequences: higher wages, and therefore higher prices, which affect living standards and damper economic growth. However, some argue that similarly skilled Americans are forced to either accept lower pay or not work at all (Davidson). Although this effect is irrefutably negative, the impact on everyone else is positive.…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Illegal immigrants are usually considered a problem in the U.S. Is that the truth? Or have people overlooked the facts and evidence proving how beneficial they are. There are Americans who believe that undocumented immigrants cause economic, social, and violent problems to the country. However, in reality, they do the opposite and provide an improved life for immigrants and their families. Illegal immigration is beneficial to America because the positive aspects outweigh the negative.…

    • 2018 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While the first source wants immigrants workers and argues that they contribute to the economy and are a great addition to this country, the other article oppose the idea that immigrants workers helps the economy, and American citizens cannot seem to process the idea. The last article also mentioned Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump’s quotes, basically helping them as well as me, as the reader to better understand. Overall, there’s a controversy on which of them are right, but the impact of immigrants on jobs is important and needs to be discussed. They both relate to my research question since I am on a quest for the opportunities available to immigrants, and jobs are at the top of the list. In other words, no jobs, means no income, no income means no home, food, water and other necessities to…

    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The United States itself was founded by immigrants, yet the government is revoking the rights of immigrants today. The United States may be a free country, but country, but immigration has altered over the years because of a rise in illegal immigrants. Amnesty should be established to hard working tax paying persons whose only felony is their immigration status. Amnesty might not be the best answer to our immigration issue, but it is the only reasonable resolve. It will offer millions of immigrants a chance at self-sufficiency and social flexibility.…

    • 813 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays