Moral Obligation In Sophocles Antigone

Superior Essays
Every person has a moral obligation between separating what the state says and what they believe. The battle between the state and the individual can cause some controversy such as the topic of censorship. Some wonder if it is right that the government or a big company can obstruct books, news, movies,etc. An abundance of power should not be given to one person, but instead to the people with a voice. The opinions and beliefs of an individual should not be obstructed or it can be detrimental to the society.

One voice should not represent an entire state because that leads to negative society. For a society to prosper, there must be a balance between powers. In Antigone by Sophocles, Haimon states,”It is no city if it takes order from one voice,”
…show more content…
The public heard of this and became uneasy with the idea, but Creon decided to do it anyways and disregarded what everyone was saying around him. This similar theme occurs in The Declaration of Independance also. The king of Britain let his power and pride get the best of him similar to Creon in Antigone which also resulted in an unhappy society. The people had no say over his “Tyranny over the States,” which cause the people to become angry and separate from Britain. Having too much power and unfairness usually comes from having one person speak for everyone. The first example of this would be Creon. He always thought what he says goes and refuses to listens to others because it made him appear weak. Creon let his pride get in the way and thought he was doing what’s best for the public, but not only did he do the opposite, he had to live with that guilt for the rest of life. Similar to this was king George of Britain who completely ignored the people and hurt them economically, mentally, and physically. This unfairness led to a war with much bloodshed just because the King disregarded the citizens even though they tried many times …show more content…
When someone limits freedom speech, it creates fear among people. In line 399-404 of Antigone, she mentions how “ all these men here would praise me were their lips not frozen shut with fear of you,” and how “they keep their tongues on leash.” She recognizes how the people there agree with her except they are so afraid of Creon that they don’t say anything. Antigone on the other hand speaks her mind, willing to accept the punishments that come along with it. Another example of this fear would be Ismene, Antigone’s sister. Antigone proposes the idea of burying their brother, but Ismene refuses out of fear even though it would be the right thing to do. Tim O’Brien in the story Rainy River also shows the fear of speaking up for himself. Going to war seemed scary to him, but being a coward scared him even more. Tim ended up going to war, but he felt like a coward because he wanted to speak up and say something, but he didn’t. Restricting the freedom of speech also makes people uneducated and unaware of the world. An example of this today would be China where they are heavily censored. Authoritative governments like China suppress viewpoints by managing distribution of information, state licensed journalist, and withholding government advertising. Some governments even prevent citizens from receiving news from outside sources (Opposing Viewpoints). All these restrictions cause

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    “When we know that those in power are morally wrong, do we break their laws, or do we collaborate with them by obeying?” (690). In Antigone, by Sophocles, free will and morals go against the established law and authority. Sophocles tells of the struggles of Antigone with the King of Thebes, Creon. Creon places a law that goes against the divine law of the gods, and Antigone obeys the divine law instead of listening to Creon and suffers unfair consequences because of his hubris. Creon’s arrogance causes most of his family’s deaths because they all feel betrayed.…

    • 1160 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My response to the ending of the story was not a positive one. I did not like the way the events of Harrison Bergeron were resolved at all. After I finished reading the story, I realized that the United States government controls people in this universe in a way that makes it virtually impossible for people to rebel. They make it so that no one is coherent enough to even plan a rebellion, and even if someone was able to overcome their handicaps, the live executions of these rebels makes everyone afraid to follow in their footsteps. Harrison’s father George had difficulty thinking about things because of his handicaps.…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Doing so he forced his insecurities and precautions onto everyone else with the intentions to snitch if the rules were not followed. In this way he was oppressing the people, almost like a dictator, by everyone being aware of the potential freedom they could hold but instead succumbing to Byelokiv’s containment. Their state of mind changes as well because they cannot enjoy themselves like they would normally so similar to the people in Brave New World they lose their distinctiveness along with their happiness. And although the people are experiencing stability they are unquestionably despondent because they cannot experience the joy of free…

    • 1579 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Once Montag realizes what the government is doing is wrong, he will stop at nothing to do what he thinks is right. Even if people close to him do not agree with him. Montag first understands that he will not make everyone happy when he tries explaining his new believes to Mildred saying, “Is it true, the world works while we play? Is that why were hated so much?” (Bradbury 70). Montag believes that whole town is angry or sad because the government considers the population as stupid, and thinking that they are worthless.…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Whether its for the benefit of innocent people or sadistic satisfaction, it should never be justified. It alters a person's life to the worse. Every human should feel safe. If they are withholding information then it's their choice and they have a right of choice. Governments should not violate those human rights because they are the ones who should protect the people.…

    • 1387 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is an important when human rights are being considered because with issues of national security can often lead to improper treatment of minorities and foreign nationals. The judiciary is best not to defer to Parliament on matters of national security as Lucia Zedner explains that with “judicial protestations of deference to ‘ministerial responsibility’, in practice it is the executive that makes most controversial decisions regarding security. Whatever deference judges owe ministers can hardly be said to extend to civil servants .” Since neither the judges nor civil servants are elected to office, judges…

    • 1936 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although Mill rejects paternalism, he does say that the “only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm [or a definite risk of harm] to others” whether it be physical violence or mental (Mill, p. 10). Therefore, a school such as SVSU with a enhanced focus and outreach towards diversity as well as students of numerous races on campus, must deny Spencer’s speech in order to prevent harm. Especially, when Spencer’s speeches come with a “definite risk of harm” as seen in multiple occasions. Mill himself believes that the only time to allow such paternalism would be to prevent harm and Spencer’s movement has already proven harmful to different racial…

    • 906 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Citizens must trust their country, but a country does not have to trust its citizens. This double standard leads to anger and when people get angry, they protest. The United States does not need any more protestors more than those who are already protesting the election, which many believe was rigged for Donald Trump, thus showing a mistrust in the democratic system in America. The trust has been broken between America and its peoples. America has also managed to lose the trust of perhaps its only real friend in the middle east: Israel.…

    • 1188 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Devlin and Dworkin agree that not every individual is capable of giving consent and there should be restrictions of what individuals are capable of such, this would allow legal intervention in some of the acts Devlin considers immoral. Public morality is something that comes from justification not from a reasonable man making decisions for society as a whole. Although if a society has an overwhelming opposition to an act that Dworkin would deem as justificatory then there should be a right to overturn such act otherwise it could potentially be more harmful to society than prohibiting…

    • 1204 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    That makes them fear to do the wrong thing. Propaganda is used by this controlling force to make sure the folks of oceania are under their control. Also the people were constantly scared because they were monitored by “Big Brother” such as “ Winston kept his back turned to the telescreen. It was safer; though as he well knew, even a back can be revealing.” (Orwell 3) This quote represents how the government monitors the life of the citizens and represents how they are in complete control over the people. Another thing that made the government a totalitarian was the lies and false information they would release to the public, it was very paradoxical that the Ministry of Truth was in charge of the media, which did the opposite of telling the truth and kept the truth censored to the people.…

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics