The Failure Of Dr. Money Theory

Improved Essays
In August of 1965 identical twin boys were born. An accident occurred 8 months later during circumcision to one of the boys. The doctor accidentally burned the baby causing it to lose its penis. Doctors were going in and out to see the little baby boy to come up with a solution to fix it. Not one single doctor was able to come up with an idea or solution on how to fix it and eventually gave up. This left the parents upset and confused on what they should do. As they sat home with their boys, Dr. John Money was showing on the television talking about gender identity and sexually reassigning at the Johns Hopkins University. This made the parents enthusiastic that they knew Dr. Money would have a solution for their baby boy. Money had a vision …show more content…
Throughout her whole childhood, she was socially isolated and miserable, which led to her attempting committing suicide twice and was saved by her family on both occasions. Going back and forth to different psychiatrist and refusing to see Dr. Money it was time that she knew the truth. She changed her sex back when she turned 16. After 12 years of trying to convince him to be a girl, Dr. Money theory indeed failed. He indeed succeeded in turning John into a female physically, but he could not influence John’s male demeanor and beliefs. John had a couple more cosmetic surgeries to have a function penis. Later on he got married to a woman with three children, whom he raised. From reading the story of John/Joan, sex and gender identity in this case was a inborn sense. He knew from childhood years that something wasn’t right about himself that in fact he knew he was different from everyone else. He struggled against his impose of being a girl and knew he was a boy and did not fit into the female body that he was …show more content…
People have easily been shaped into something they are not. In the article when Dr. Money had a patient to talk to John/Joan, the patient was a transgender who was turned into a woman but love and enjoyed every second of it. Now in society if a person was born a boy but is attracted to the same sex they can have a sex change or identify themselves as a gay man and remain a man. There is now more plasticity and variability than ever in society. Change is at the tips of everyone’s fingers. Years ago this was unheard of but now it is so common and many cities are known to have a lot of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Rosenberg then asks the following question, “What is gender anyway?” (482). She asked this question in order to evoke deeper thoughts from the reader. Rosenberg continues and states that gender is more than the anatomy that creates humans male or female, that it is something more complex. As Rosenberg argues this, she references history and how men and women were stereotypically perceived to be. She describes that males were known to be the ones who were less emotional and were providers. Then in contrast that females were less of providers and more emotional. She uses history to show that stereotypical gender roles are false accusations of how men and women act. The author then continues to state that the term transgender is a broad term to label people who express themselves differently than their gender that they were born with, wether or not they have had surgery. Rosenberg then articulates that gender identity crises does in fact occur at very young ages of children. She then tells the story of a little boy named Jonah age six who wanted to become a girl. The parents decided to let him be a girl by changing his name to Jona and…

    • 1268 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From childhood into adulthood, a person is bombarded with societal pressure to personify the roles assigned to their gender– gender meaning how the individual identifies (male, female, transgender, gender fluid, etc.) not their biological sex. Traits or behaviors typical to one gender are deemed socially unacceptable. Aaron H. Devor–previously Holly Devor, before his gender reassignment in 2002– professor of sociology and former Dean of Graduate Studies at the University of Victoria in British Columbia, illustrates this in his essay, “Becoming Members of Society: Learning the Social Meanings of Gender.” In his essay, Devor explains how characteristics such as behavior or physical appearance (apart from one’s reproductive system) define individuals…

    • 326 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Anthony Rockwell’s theory about money was that it could buy anything. I think this is untrue because things such as, emotions cannot be bought in the genuine form with money. Yes, money may set up a situation, but it does not make the feelings that come out of what might happen. I think that Rockwell may have this theory because he has so much money, and that makes him think that the possibilities with money are endless. If he was not as rich, I think Rockwell would realize that there are things that you cannot buy, but you have to earn them.…

    • 175 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this case, the parents of the child name it ‘Baby X’ and do not reveal the child’s sex to anyone; this way it will not be subjected to stereotypical gender roles as it develops through stages in life. The child is raised in an environment where they are free to dress how they like, play which sports they like, choose their own role models, develop an assortment of skills and most importantly choose their own identity without worrying about behaving like a boy or like a girl. By the time the child enrolls in school, it has developed a multitude of skills that allow it to accomplish more than the average student. Instead of limiting the child’s abilities based on which a boy or a girl can and cannot do, it is open to more experiences which in turn, leads to a happier and healthier life, “X won the spelling bee. X also won the relay race. And X almost won the baking contest, (Gould, 1972, 7). From a medical perspective, child ‘X’ was given a psychiatric evaluation to determine its mental health compared to all of the other gendered students in their school. The parents of all the other children assumed that being gender-less would have negative consequences on the child, but they had never considered the possibility that the case might be reversed. Based on the stages of psychosocial development, which…

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Imagine a world where your gender defines who you are and who exactly you could become. Stereotypes about gender could be as simple as a person born male would become a construction worker or police officer and a person born female would become a school teacher or hair dresser. People are to fit into their gender stereotypes, and that was that. But, it is not the 1950s anymore. It is 2016, and in today’s world, gender is but a place on your lower body. People can identify as the opposite gender than they were born with, or identify as both genders, and even identify as no gender at all. It has become a personal issue that is not yet fully accepted into society. If someone finds out you are a transgender, they have the right to refuse service to you or kick you out, no questions asked. Transgender people are treated differently because of how they identify themselves. Grouped together with LGBT: lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender, the group as a whole has had to deal with riots against them, social media threats against them, and prejudice following them everywhere from shopping malls to even the public restroom.…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gender identity can develop at almost any time throughout a person’s life, but it usually occurs as a small boy or girl. They will find themselves drawn to the same gender, not necessarily in a sexual way, but with intrigued feelings.…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Families with a Transgender Child Learn and Change is a written article from 2015 by Boston Globe reporter Crisela Guerra. This article is a short essay informs its audience about a specific issue within the transgender community, which is transgender children and their families. Guerra cultivates a convincing, open-minded, and well-balanced text with the use of ethos, by introducing the reader to a young transgender child named Q Daily, then uses logos by giving the reader the facts on transgender children, and finally uses ethos by quoting a psychotherapist who specializes in gender.…

    • 601 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During this process, however, one twin, David Reimer’s, penis was burned off by an electrocautery needle. A catheter took the place of the child’s penis as their parents explored their options. During this time, phallic reconstruction was a crude and unpracticed operation (Colapinto). Doctors had little hope that this operation would be successful, and even if it was, the reconstructed penis would never have the normal capacity of a real penis. Nearly seven months since the accident, Joan/John’s parents caught wind of Dr. John Money. Money was making great strides in the research of gender and gender identity. It is widely believed that he even coined the phrase “gender identity”. Dr. Money was a driving force behind the John Hopkins medical center 's Gender identity clinic (Colapinto). He believed that the child could undergo a sex change operation in which his dismembered penis would be turned into a vagina, and that he would transition well into the female gender as long as his family acted like and convinced him that he had always been a girl. Money was drawn to this case because of their being another twin boy who could act as a control group during an experiment that he would conduct for a…

    • 2414 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stories involving transgender people have been in newspapers, magazines, and tabloids for over fifty five years and have captivated and intrigued the American audience from the start. It all began in 1955 when Christine Jorgensen, born George, publicly announced her gender confirming surgery and began life as a legally recognized women. There was a media frenzy with headlines such as “Bronx GI Becomes a Woman!” and “Bronx ‘Boy’ Is Now A Girl”. But instead of “withdraw[ing] from public attention [Christine’ turned the notoriety to her advantage with a series of lucrative tours on the lecture and nightclub circuit” (McQuiston 1989). “By cultivating the demeanor of a lady and refusing to call herself a homosexual,” Christine was able to remove…

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the article, "The Transgender Tipping Point", the Trans world was introduced to the society we know today. After one year of the decision from the Supreme Court to allow people to marry who they loved, no matter their sex, transgender people begun to build a civil-rights movement to challenge the long-term norms and beliefs. What were news to me that I learned in the article, there is no concrete correlation between a person's gender identity and sexual interests and many insurance plans have explicit exclusions for treatments related to gender transitions. These were issues that some transgender people had to reject because of seeing gender as a spectrum than a freedom to their movements. States in America, such as, Connecticut and Vermont…

    • 332 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Money, although they say that it isn’t everything, money actually is a huge part of daily life. Every family, business, and organizations depends on money to survive and grow. No matter the place you go or things you do you are a variable of the functionalist or conflict theory of sociology. Each class is exploiting the other for goods and services and you can clearly see this in the information given below.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Caster Semenya

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Caster Semenya is an athlete who has identified herself as a woman and has her whole life. However, it changed when she was required to do a gender testing. In this test, she found out that she had no ovaries or uterus, but she did have testes that could produce testosterone. Because of this result, there was a huge debate whether she would be allowed to race as a woman because she had a huge advantage over the others. However, Dr. Myron Genel, a professor at Yale University, states that she is a female born with a birth defect. Normally, in the world there is 1% of the population that are born with a disorder of sexual development. Many of these people can show the physical characteristic of both genders or have a chromosomal disorder. Furthermore, it is not usually noticeable in a girl until she hit puberty or she is trying to have babies, or in Caster’s case with a gender testing. But she is not alone, in 2000, the Journal of The American Medical Association reported that 27 of the 11, 373 had a disorder of sexual development. In some cases, it can be treated with surgery. But many doctors recommended for the patient to be older because their gender usually becomes noticeable at an older age.…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the book “As Nature Made Him,” Ron Colapinto writes about a family who goes through a traumatic experience after a shocking accident at the hospital. On August 22 1965, a young couple —Ron and Janet Reimer— welcomed twin boys into the world, Bruce and Brian. In 1966, a year after the twins were born, the couple took the twins to the St. Boniface hospital for a circumcision. Unfortunately one of the twins—Bruce— suffered a mishandled operation, which severely damaged his penis. The Reimer’s did not know what to do about their wounded child; they were ashamed of the appearance of his penis and did not want anybody to find out what happened. It was troubling for the Reamer’s until they saw an interview of a psychologist who specializes in gender reassignment, John Money, on the television. The couple agreed to a treatment—that was offered by John Money— which would alter Bruce’s gender. Dr. Money explained the gender reassignment treatment and the surgery, which would turn Bruce’s penis into a vagina and raise him as a girl instead a boy. After much serious thought the couple chose to do the operation— leading to Brian Reimer becoming Brenda Reimer.…

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    After reading the article Transgender Today, written by Eve Glicksman, I was able to collect information about transgender and how public perception is changing, in a glorious way. A few of the changes we have seen over the past several decades with public’s perception of transgender is that “more studies are exploring treatment for transgender people who seek it” (Glicksman), transgender individuals are now being praised and supported more frequently, and health insurance plans are starting to be offered from multiple universities. In the beginning, being transgender was frowned upon, many would refer to transgender as “nature made a mistake” (Glicksman). Another astonishing sign that transgender people are now more accepted than they were…

    • 156 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Therefore, some people don’t practice either a male or female gender, and instead they practice something in between. Transgender people are part of this continuum. Avery experiences challenges with his gender identity everyday due to the outside world and societies views on transgender individuals. Our society has an overwhelming number of people who believe that gender is unable to change and if someone does get a sex change then they are considered to be disturbed. (CG 36). Within the reading “Becoming Members of Society: The Social Meanings of Gender” in Composing Gender, the author states: “Persons who perform the activities considered appropriate for another gender will be expected to perform them poorly. If they succeed adequately, or even well, at their endeavors, they may be rewarded with ridicule or scorn for blurring the gender dividing line.” (CG 40). Avery experiences ridicule within his day to day life. Whether that be a weird look or stare from a stranger, or peers bullying him. As discussed in lecture gender is perceived as a process. Gender creates social differences and hierarchies depending on one 's gender. Therefore, people who do not identify as either male or woman are seen as disturbing a social system which has been prevalent for many generations, which leads to discrimination against…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics