Foner Labour Movement

Good Essays
The fourth source is a quote from historian Philip S. Foner’s book, The History of the Labour Movement in the United States, written between 1947 and 1994. The labour movement was a push for better working conditions, a reduction of child labour and a fair working wage. This specific quote was an 1870 poem that discusses the idea of fair working hours. The source uses phrases such as “tired of toil for naught” to describe the unrest among the working class. In 1870, the average worker spent 61 hours on the job for very little pay, as seen in the line “bare enough to live on”. In the time period of this poem, the workers were looking to cut their workday to just eight hours. New technology granted this workday change, as workers had the technology …show more content…
It discusses that the only way to produce the necessities of life is through human labour, but the “Left” is not willing to work with that system. When mentioning the “Left”, the source points to individuals that believe in an ideology that falls closer to the socialist side of the economic spectrum. This type of ideology promotes economic equality and more government intervention in the economy. The speaker of the source critiques this, stating that a socialist program can only result in “domestic poverty” and global hunger. The sources argues that a more left government will tax producers for the benefit of their possibly unemployed citizens. Benefiting citizens comes from “subsidizing” or funding in the form of government welfare programs. The source also heavily criticizes this system as they describe that members of this ideology believe that production occurs by “magic”. Capitalists would agree with this source’s perspective, specifically because it aligns with their beliefs in government economic involvement being detrimental to the overall economic health. To defend their beliefs, an individual could point to the downfall of the welfare state during the 1970s. Governments utilized Keynesian economics in the post-war years, choosing to spend revenue on social welfare programs and lowering …show more content…
Emblazoned on the ship is the title “European Welfare State” surrounded by multiple tiny lifeboats. During the post-war years, European nations championed the welfare state model. Many nations focussed on developing “social safety net” programs as wells as cutting taxes to boost economic spending. The welfare state also promoted an abandonment of protectionist policies which resulted in the creation of the European Union. One lifeboat in the cartoon features two American symbols, Uncle Sam and the Democratic Party’s donkey. The donkey appears to be saying “Trust me, it's the best” to sway the American nation (Uncle Sam) into supporting a welfare state model. The Democratic Party is a largely left wing party, advocating for government to play a bigger role in the economy, lowering taxes and increasing social programs. The cartoonist supports a more Republican ideology, as seen through his use of the Democratic symbol attempting to “sell” a sinking ship. Ronald Reagan’s implementation of supply-side, or “trickle-down” economics during the 1980s shows support for the ideology of this cartoon. Reagan’s approach involved reducing government regulation in the economy and increasing military spending. His methods were a reaction to the growing unpopularity of the welfare state model that had been brewing during the seventies. Critics of this source would view Reagan’s methods and supply-side economics as unsuccessful,

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Ronald Reagan’s policies were called the supply-side economics. This is the idea that sharp cuts in taxes and deregulation would stimulate businesses. Supply-side economics would also reduce government revenues and therefore reduce government. So the bigger idea was to make the government intrude less in people’s lives and let free market dominate. Reagan and Congress did everything to deregulate almost everything.…

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    However, the fiscal policy unfortunately increases the deficit budget that makes inflation goes high, which eventually makes the people lose their jobs and caused them into recession. Afterwards, the Federalists used this particular example to conclude that the government shouldn’t interfere with helping the economy. They also included the fact the government shouldn’t be in charge of regulating the economy, where they might corrupt the reserve system. In the conclusion, the fiscal and monetary policy can either run the economy which they may help prevent inflation or recession. Keywords: federalists, monetary and fiscal policy Deficit Budget The economy should be regulated by the fiscal policy while the government use its powers to cut taxes and spend money to control the interest rates.…

    • 1476 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Conservatism Dbq

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Friedman states that government intervention has made social and economic situations worse for Americans. But, all the recent successes of America are claimed to be attributed to the individualistic nature of the free-market economy. For this reason, Friedman proposes an already successful solution to the disappointing liberal actions of the American government to be more conservative. From a different end of the social hierarchy, a letter written to Nelson Rockefeller (Republican governor of New York) on February 6, 1971 (Doc 3) describes the negative effects of the government’s implications of “welfare cheats” and taxes. This “law-abiding citizen” uses her letter to request a necessary use of government intervention in fixing the damage in the poorer parts of New York.…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Johnson's Sixties

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages

    They claimed welfare did not alleviate poverty, but succeeded in encouraging single motherhood and undermined the work ethic. (GML 1028). In addition, they claimed that high taxes and expensive government regulations undermined economic growth because it drained resources from productive enterprises (GML 1028). This revival of the Gilded Age economic liberalism ideology was termed neoliberalism. Neoliberalists advocated for free market economics, weakening of union control, cutting public expenditure for social services, especially welfare and extensive deregulation.…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    World War II became the remedy to solve this economic crisis, developing a conservative opposition to slowly increase, forming the emergence of neoliberalism. Many conservatives believed that the New Deal possessed socialist ideals, serving as an abusive hindrance to a free-market economy. In addition, these individuals criticized this form of liberalism asserting that it undermined the country’s traditional liberal principles of privatization and self-sufficiency. They critiqued Roosevelt’s New Deal policies, claiming that he violated the laws of the Constitution by overstepping his political authority. One example of this was in 1933 when Congress passed the National Recovery Act, allowing the government to balance the economy through planning and replace the existing capitalist system (Kelley 2017).…

    • 963 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    1. Summary of End the Fed “End the Fed” by Ron Paul argues how the federal reserve (Fed) is detrimental to the economy and the nation. Although, the Fed claims that its role is to keep inflation in control, implement a solvent banking system, regulate financial system and also keeps the business cycle in steady state, Ron Paul disagrees on the above mentioned points and argues that the Fed has ironically created more problems than resolving them. By drawing examples from American history, experiences from his political career as well as his knowledge, Ron Paul put up a strong argument on how the Fed is corrupted, immoral and unconstitutional through a philosophical, economic and libertarian point of view. At the end, Ron Paul emphasises on…

    • 1516 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    While the debate between Mises and Marx continued, other philosophers would also debate if capitalism and socialism was better, and how each system would affect the entire society. Marx was against capitalism because of the gap between the two social classes that the capitalist system formed. Marx saw this struggle first hand during the Industrial Revolution and decided to write in his “Communist Manifesto”. He saw how the working poor became more of a commodity as the bourgeoisie obtained more and more power. Marx said that capitalism would make the rich richer and the poor poorer.…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Marx mentions that the discovery of America is a big reason for the separation of classes (Marx 9). He does not like the idea of capitalism because people value profits instead of other people like the working class. The increased trade led to the strengthening of the bourgeoisie, or capitalists. Marx say that “The bourgeoisie has torn away from the family its sentimental veil, and has reduced family relation to a mere money relation” (Marx 11). Marx believes that the increase in trade has made the bourgeoisie class selfish.…

    • 1596 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Although the Second New Deal greatly helped the Depression by creating a powerful social-welfare state for the well-being of American Citizens, there were still critics. Conservatives claimed that the government was intruding into the personal and financial lives of Americans while Liberals shined light on the holes in the plans like the lack of a national health-care…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Finally, adversaries of minimum wages argue that this method is not a cure for poverty because in capitalistic societies, businesses tend to react to minimum wage increases by increasing the prices of their goods and services. Therefore, even though minimum wages might not be an advantage to small businesses, the nation as a whole…

    • 1852 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays