Edward Bok And Colin Powell: A Comparative Analysis

Great Essays
Edward Bok experiences patriotism in his fifty-years of Americanization. Although Bok has trouble adjusting and transitioning into the United States, he does not allow his struggles to stop him from pursuing his dreams. Bok writes about America’s limitless opportunities and refers it as the “land of opportunity”. Colin Powell, the first African American Secretary of State, writes about his parents’ immigration from Jamaica to America and discusses the effect of 9/11 on America. Both Edward Bok and Colin Powell convey an optimistic and inspirational tone and develop the idea of “land for all” and “land of opportunity” through the use of connotative diction in contrast to the Immigration Chart and Political Cartoon which has an overwhelming …show more content…
Bok demonstrates an inspirational tone by stating, “As the world stands today, no nation offers opportunity in the degree that America does to the foreign born”. This relates to the Political Cartoon illustration by showing thousands of people wanting to pass through a funnel to reach America. Throughout Bok’s autobiography, he remains inspirational by inspiring immigrants to want to come to America. He portrays this by explaining the opportunities that America provides. In contrast to Bok, Powell maintains an optimistic tone by quoting, “I believe in America and I believe in our people”. Throughout Powell’s essay, he conveys an optimistic tone by remaining hopeful and confident about the future of America and by continuing to stay positive. Bok and Powell represent contrasting tones in their writing however, their tones have similar positive meanings. The Political Cartoon and Immigration Chart illustrate an overwhelming and unwelcoming tone. The Immigration Chart reveals an overwhelming tone by distinguishing the increase and decrease of immigrants over time. When the U.S. experiences a domestic issue, the amount of immigrants in the U.S. decreases. However, when foreign countries experience issues, the amount of immigrants in the U.S. increases. The Political Cartoon displays an unwelcoming tone by illustrating that many Europeans desire to immigrate to America, but only …show more content…
Bok justifies America as a land of opportunity by stating, “...however America may have failed to help my transition from a foreigner into an American, I owe to her the most priceless gift that any nation can offer and that is opportunity”. In Edward Bok’s autobiography he claims America as a land of opportunity where foreigners work to achieve their dreams. Colin Powell remains optimistic and indicates that Americans do not fear the hardships that come their way. The Political Cartoon interprets people’s willingness to leave all that they have to come to America. Powell supports this by stating, “We must be careful, but we must not be afraid”. Colin Powell discusses 9/11 and the effect it has on America, and emphasizes that Americans do not fear immigrants because of 9/11. Powell confirms that foreigners no longer consider America a welcoming nation by writing, “Unfortunately, to many foreigners we gave the impression that we were no longer a welcoming nation”. He indicates that America continues to welcome all people despite the fears resulting from 9/11. Both Edward Bok and Colin Powell display and create the idea that America welcomes and offers opportunity.
The Political Cartoon and Immigration Chart express the idea of immigrants transitioning from a foreigner to an American. The Political Cartoon compares to a funnel because a great amount of Europeans

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The US has been a blend of races, cultures, and ethnic groups evolving from successive waves of immigration since the very beginning. As far as immigrants coming to the US, Germans were the first in question as to their ability to become ‘real’ Americans. Next, questions were raised about the Chinese, Irish, Eastern European’s and most recently Hispanic-American and Muslim-Americans. This list alone provides a wide range of cultural beliefs and values all located in the US. Buchanan argues that patriotism, the love and loyalty for one’s own country, is at the heart of the nation, however; considering the mixture of immigrants located in the US, there is a mixture of love and possibly still loyalty to their original country.…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Being an immigrant to the new world was never a simple task. Adversity, opportunity, and adaptability lurked around every corner as these foreign families sought a new and better life. Struggling with standing out as a “new immigrant”, overcoming poor work conditions, pay, and unstable jobs, and seeking out new opportunities while adapting to necessary survival strategies are some of the many trials a new immigrant would face while coming to a new land. Having lived through it all, Kracha and Dubik from Thomas Bell’s Out of This Furnace saw every aspect of becoming an American.…

    • 1047 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Pia Orrenius and Madeline Zavodny’s academic journal article, “The Economics of U.S Immigration Policy,” Orrenius and Zavodny state that Americans’ outlook on immigration vary from those who believe immigrants (legal and illegal) positively impact the economy and those who believe immigrants negatively impact the economy. Pia Orrenius and Madeline Zavodny’s argue that the United States needs to implement an “immigration policy that addresses the concerns” about low-skill, unauthorized “immigration’s labor market and fiscal impacts” (954). The article may appeal to experts or those who have a higher interest in immigration due to the diction and the genre of the article, an academic journal, while discussing the public concerns with immigration,…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Immigration in The United States during the progressive era resulted in an essential transformative period during American history. The United States was a beacon of hope for immigrants looking for prosperity and a fresh start. However, during the years 1880 through 1925, important transformations within the American economy occurred there were important such as the successful and lucrative industrialization and tensions arose regarding the government’s negative feelings and toward the large flow of immigrants and new cultures. Once the frontier was closed and became irrelevant as the United States settled, there was an illusion of hope for people immigrating to the US.…

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Immigration Dbq Essay

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages

    During the late 19th and 20th centuries the United States experienced an influx of immigrants, who brought with them diverse cultures, religions, and languages. Since Columbus’ voyage in 1492, immigrants sought opportunities. By the end of the 18th century, the thirteen english colonies became the United States, and the country prided itself as a “nation of immigrants.” The first wave of immigration took place during the colonial period, and the second wave took place during the mid 19th century. Because they were usually white, English-speaking protestants from Northern and Western Europe, these immigrants mostly assimilated successfully.…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Analyze politically, socially and economically to what extent immigration impacted American society from 1865 to 1898. The United States has always been a mixing pot, immigrants from all over the world have been coming with a common goal to better themselves and their families. Nonetheless, immigrants had never had it easy to succeed in a foreign society, the time period 1865 to 1898 was no the exemption. Irish, Russians, Greeks, Poles, Hungarians, Romanians, Chinese and Bohemians among many other were coming to the union to face prejudices from “true Americans”. Immigration caused a strain in society since the government would not help immigrant at any point under any circumstance, the gap between the rich and the poor grew as immigrants…

    • 1124 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over the years North America has become the home to many immigrants, resulting to this continent to become a big melting pot of cultures. People from all over the world moved to America to find their own American Dream. Nancy Lee Johnson, a senior at George Washington High, had a passion for Art and contested to win a scholarship, which she thought would be her way out to a better life. Nancy Lee’s displeasure to not winning the Artist Club Scholarship due to her being a “Negro” made her to rethink the true meaning to the Pledge of Allegiance that she said every week at the assembly’s. Nancy Lee was a proud “Negro American” even though she knew that “A Negro in America was often hurt, discriminated against, sometimes lynched…” she still believed in her American dream.…

    • 301 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dbq Immigration

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the late 1800’s, many people around the world decided to leave their country and immigrate to the United States. Some came for the economic opportunities, while others came seeking freedom or relief from political and religious persecutions. As more people started coming in, borders became hectic, new ideas were produced, more jobs were created to support the growing population, and the population became more diverse. Depending on which side of the spectrum one falls into, immigration could be seen as good or as bad. In the United States, immigrants are persecuted and one of the main reason why is they are being accused of taking over jobs, this of course causes a division between the citizens and the immigrants.…

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    America Pull Factors

    • 1067 Words
    • 5 Pages

    America has changed greatly, from being a place inhabited by whom explorers called “Indians” to a place where people of diverse background now call home. All but one thing has not changed; people have continued to refer to America as the “Land of Opportunity.” Various push and pull factors triggered the need to come to America. Examples of the push and pull factors would be the Potato Famine for the Irish or Gold Mountain for the Chinese and a s a result, America was highly spoken of. As the Japanese described it, America was a place where “money grew on trees,” (Takaki, 233).…

    • 1067 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Immigrants have created America to be what it is today, and have forever been working together as one to protect and be patriotic before this country was even founded. Two articles, written by Anna Quindlen and John F. Kennedy both have views on immigrants becoming American citizens, and how everyone in this country is so different, but we’re held together by our patriotism and desire to be a true American. In “A Quilt of a Country,” the author, Anna Quindlen, writes all about how America is made up of many different cultures and races. She compares America to a quilt.…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Miranda Richards Ms. Keck Composition 1/A2 29 November 2014 What is an American? Harold L. Ickes, Secretary of the Interior for President Franklin D. Roosevelt, delivered an impactful speech that reminded Americans what it means to be an American. This speech was delivered during I am an American Day in New York City’s Central Park on May 18, 1941.…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Diversity Synthesis Essay

    • 493 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Strategies: Theme: “‘I have learned that diversity in human experience gives rise to diversity in thought, which creates distinct ideas and methods of problem solving.’” & “And here in America, we don’t give in to our fears. We don’t build up walls to keep people out because we know that our greatness has always depended on contributions from people who were born elsewhere but sought out this country and made it their home...” Questions: Theme: The First Lady, Michelle Obama, decided to centralize her speech about the idea of diversity due to the presidential candidate speeches going on at the time.…

    • 493 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The United States is often perceived as a melting pot for all ethnicities to have equal opportunities for success and wealth. The extent in which this total equality has been implemented into actual reality is rather sparse. As history supports, ethnicity and race are still associated with social and economic oppression and abuse. For members of the population to maintain the ancient idea that America is primarily a white country significantly causes new generations of Americans to wrongly regard and negatively perceive the next wave of immigrants. According to Lillian Rubin’s article “Is This a White Country or What?”, many American citizens are opposed to immigration, even though they too come from immigrant families.…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    It’s Simple: Have a Heart America’s history began with the immigration of colonists. As our history has lengthened, more immigrants have come to search for freedom, independence, and opportunity. The colonists searched for the opportunity to have freedom, the Irish searched for a better life, and now Hispanics look for a home without violence (622); the only difference between the immigrants of today versus the immigrants of yesteryears is that more Americans now are against immigration. Instead of viewing immigrants as contributors to the American economy, Americans believe that immigrants are stealing American resources and jobs (617).…

    • 1229 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American dream is often characterized or described with luxuries and fame, although this is not the wrong approach to the infamous American dream, this is the dream of the citizens of this country. But if we take a different approach and ask immigrants what their American dream is, we discover a different perspective of the American dream. For many immigrants in the country , like myself, the American dream involves prosperity and the opportunity to reach higher education. Unlike U.S born citizens, undocumented immigrants have to work twice as hard to achieve any form of stability in the U.S, due to the fact that many needed resources are non-existent. The inevitable contrast between these two distinct approaches to the American dream,…

    • 1293 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays