Of German Mothers: Movie Analysis

Great Essays
The Nazi party, which ruled Germany during the 1930s and 40s, was plagued with radicalized thinking about issues of race and German identity. During the Nazi regime, Germany was responsible for killing millions of Jews, blacks, and other minorities based only on their physical appearance and stereotypes associated with each race. However, after the end of War World II and the fall of the Nazi party, Germany entered a time of rebuilding known as the “Stunde Null” period. Scholars initially believed that Germans left their previous racist ideologies and laws in the past and created a democratic anti-racist society. Recently, though, scholars have reexamined historical evidence that demonstrates that Germans never entered this period of Stunde …show more content…
In Of German Mothers, Fehrenbach commented that, “despite their legal designation as German citizens, their very presence challenged race-based definitions of national identity” (Fehrenbach 2001). This theme is illustrated in the 1952 film Toxi. In the closing scene of the movie, Toxi, the main character and an occupational child of mixed descent, was finally accepted by her white German guardians after several attempts to return her to the orphanage by other family members; however, when her black American father arrived, the family willingly allowed Toxi to go back to America with a complete stranger. At the time of the film’s release, many Germans saw the ending of Toxi as a happy one; but this suggests that Germans believed that Toxi never belonged in German society in the first place. This example shows a form of subtle racism, where Germans failed to see a mixed race child as a true German citizen due to her appearance alone. Although in the ending of the film, no explicit discrimination and exclusion comes from her adoptive family, the family still attaches to the idea that skin color can trump national identity. The family allowed a little girl who lived in Germany her entire life and was culturally German to be taken away to an unfamiliar country with a stranger. The family essentially denied Toxi’s right to remain in her homeland of Germany by depicting her as …show more content…
First, although the treatment of black GIs was often better than their treatment in America, this changed with the help of white GIs who reintroduced racial discrimination in Germany that induced German men to begin slut-shaming German women who interacted with black GIs. Second, the film Toxi depicted Germans’ views about the status and legitimacy of occupation children; although occupation children were legal German citizens, they were often viewed as illegitimate and non-German. Third, in the book Invisible Woman, Ika described the emotional toll of indirect racism in the orphanages and how it led her to feel out of place in her own country. Finally, attempts to depict occupation children and other blacks in a positive light through stories actually reinforced negative stereotypes. Although some scholars believe Germany escaped its racist Nazi past during “Stunde Null”, the problems associated with racism in the post-war period are very prevalent when examining historical examples. Racist behaviors and tendencies did not disappear with the fall of the Nazi party, but were only hidden from direct

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The processes in which the Germans were involved in to overcome the tragedies of World War II were vast and long. There were many complications present when the war ended; Germans found themselves questioned politically and mentally by their own compatriots, as well as outsiders. This essay will argue that the film The Murders Are Among Us depicts the complications involved in the German process of “overcoming the past,” post-World War II, through its characters. In particular, this essay will cover the development and practice of this process by discussing the three main characters of this film, Dr. Mertens, Cpt. Bruckner, and Susanne. These three characters represent all three types of people living within Germany. They all have different standpoints, and contribute as a group to the main theme of the movie and Germany as a whole.…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After the great depression of the 1930’s and after World War I, Germany suffered greatly from the depression as the country had agreed to take full responsibility of the war reparations, as Germany was politically and economically unstable. As many German citizens were unemployed and poverty rates increased, many Germans were looking for a leader who can solve the country’s economic disaster. Hitler became the leader of the Nazis in 1921 and created new plans and rules about how Germany can become a great country again. His speeches and commitment to rebuild the country caused many Germans to vote for him. But Adolf Hitler also wanted Germany to be a superior Aryan country (pure race of northern Europeans), as he opposed disabled people, gypsies,…

    • 1408 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the 1930’s when Hitler came into power Germany had been facing serious economic hardship. He proposed that he could help Germany to become stable again but they had to get rid of anyone who stood in the way of Germany’s advancement. Hitler believed that the Aryans were superior to all people and believed that by ridding Germany of non-Aryans would help to end the struggles they were facing. He believed that Germany had become impure and corrupt due to race mixing and that the Jews were enemies who sought to take over Germany by destroying the nation state and establishing Jew…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Suzy Zail’s historical fiction, ‘The Wrong Boy’, explores how the hellish environment of Auschwitz has compelled victim's of Hitler’s Holocaust to be stripped of their identity. The novel portrays how barbaric conditions allowed for dehumanisation, removal of personal attributes and any remnants of human dignity. Zail presents how the labelling, isolation and inferiority have caused the characters to lose their cultural identity, charisma and self-respect.…

    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “For us there are only two possibilities: either we remain German or we come under the thumb of the Jews. This latter must not occur; even if we are small, we are a force. A well-organized group can conquer a strong enemy… We will be victorious over the Jews,” were Adolf Hitler’s words in his speech in Munich. To a certain extent, audience in today’s society would characterize his words to be on the more extreme end of identification, where it allowed his listeners to “dissociated from the others” (Jews) and grant them the permission of “symbolically kill those with whom they do not identify with.” Hitler’s words proved identification- a three-step process which “allowed people to share views they need in order to collaborate to think of themselves…

    • 198 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Nazis, who came to power in Germany in January 1933, believed that Germans were "racially superior" and that the Jews, During the era of the Holocaust, German authorities also targeted other groups because of their perceived "racial inferiority"ed…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The document is written from the perspective of a German intellectual, which is useful in providing information regarding racial biases and attitudes of the elite. The works of the intellectual community typically influenced the attitudes of ordinary citizens in society through the distribution of print publications and mass media. This informs us of the ideology and material being spread to the public to propagate nationalistic German values. As the document is propagandist in nature, it does not describe or acknowledge the consequences of war in terms of human devastation. It uses vague terminology and presents a one-sided view of the relationship between Germany and Britain. The document reveals ideas of racial inequality and social Darwinism prevalent in Europe in the 1900s. It is important to identify that the resentment and tensions between different nations was deeply rooted in historical events spanning from pre-war times. This has perpetuated even until the end of World War One, manifesting into destruction of a larger scale in World War…

    • 1634 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Different sized television screens oddly placed in a vertical manner showing a man talking with an annoying attitude about prejudice. Then the two choices of doors to walk through, either prejudice, or not prejudice. The not prejudice did not open, and a lady let us in through the prejudice door, saying that is the only one open, since everybody is prejudice about something. We were each given a picture of a child to later find out how the Holocaust changed their lives. The group was guided through what looked like a typical German street in the 1940’s, with store windows and radio announcements, highlighting Hitler as a great leader. Videos of the order of the German army seemed immense, the shooting down of people falling in their pre-dug graves, and pictures of starved bony bodies added to the increasing feelings of disgust, and grief-struck we felt. Footage of German school children brainwashed with anti-Semitic teachings, cheering for Hitler as if a great ruler, civilians picking up guns and shooting innocent Jews made me realize the immense manipulating power of hate and the devastation destruction it is capable of carrying…

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    German civilians feel as though they are unfairly attached to the events of the Holocaust, especially those “who were either not in positions of power in the Third Reich or who belong to succeeding generations” (Bartov 793). Because of this, the Nazi has become “the new enemy of postwar Germany,” meaning much like the Jew during World War II, the Nazi “lurks in everyone and, in this sense, can never be ferreted out” (Bartov 793). At the same time, the Germans believe the Nazi and all Nazism stood for is vastly different from the beliefs of contemporary Germany and individual Germans that some choose to entirely ignore the historical significance of that portion of their nation’s history, regarding it as myth more than…

    • 1909 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Nazi reign in Germany is a key event in the 1900’s. Hitler could not do all of it by himself, she he hired Leni Rifensthal as his camerawomen. Hitler’s terror effected everyday people and made them fear him. This paper describes how one woman made a huge impact and played a large roll in Hitler’s power and fame. The question answered in the following research paper is: How did Leni Riefenstahl play a role in Hitler’s propaganda machine? I will answer this in several parts and explain what propaganda is, how Hitler used it and what Leni did for Hitler.…

    • 1951 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    After Germany lost the war in 1945, several Allied soldiers stationed in Germany began to start relationships and marry German women. In German society it sinful to have a biracial relationship. Some German women eventually became pregnant from African-American Allied soldiers, which created a new group in the German society called Afro-Germans or “Occupation Babies”. Many of the fathers of the Occupation Babies did not raise them because Allied soldiers were eventually sent back to their own countries, leaving the German mothers to raise them. Occupation Babies were segregated, treated unequally and unfairly. This personally happens to Ika Hügel-Marshall, who is born an Afro-German. Ika Hügel-Marshall writes her memoir Invisible Woman Growing…

    • 1722 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    World War II, along with the Holocaust, is one of the most historically meaningful periods in history. The Nazi soldiers, under the direction of Adolf Hitler, were responsible for the genocide of millions of Jews and other undesirables in Poland and the death camps of Auschwitz and Birkenau. Maus: A Survivor’s Tale, I: My Father Bleeds History and Maus: A Survivor’s Tale, II: And Here My Troubles Began, are graphic novels written my Art Spiegelman. Chronicling the story of the Holocaust through the eyes of his father, Vladek, Maus I and II depicts humans drawn in animal form to tell the story of the struggles and horrors suffered by the Polish Jews at the hands of the Nazis. A recurrent theme throughout both novels is the idea of race and nationality,…

    • 1374 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    “Stunde Null”, translating to “Zero Hour”, was a pivotal time in German history. With the collapse of the Nazi regime, the german people faced “Niederlage” (defeat), something that didn’t take place before then. Unlike in the first World War, the german people were expected to “Bedingungslose Kapitulation” surrender unconditionally. Germans had lost their rights and Germany was carved up. Germany had lost its sovereignty, there was no German government, no representation of the german people and german territory was occupied by the allied forces. It was a time marred with great defeat and great shame. The term “Stunde Null” was a used to mark both an ending of World War Two and the start of a ‘new’, non-Nazi Germany.1 It was in part trying…

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    myth of a common descent and other criteria for what Weber refers to as an ethnic group (Weber 1920, 385; 389). This is not to erase the importance of regional differences in Germany. Rather than being comprised of many different ethnic groups, Germany was considered a conglomeration of different groups that essentially came from the same descendent. While this played into the rhetoric of Nazi Germany, one must be careful not to place this belief in common ethnic decent only on the development of National Socialism, as iterations of Germanness through group ethnicity was already present in the foundation of the Weimar Republic (Joppke 2011, 47).…

    • 952 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pride In Germany

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The burden of the Holocaust in German identity, while proving to bring out a change in the world, may be becoming crippling rather then uplifting. The lessons of guilt turning into fascinations, the forced identify to conform to the villains of history causing resentment, creating a movement that produces citizens of alt-right. To understand the depth Hitler’s legacy has modern German, is to understand the identity and psyche that is carried with Germans today. The Holocaust has and continues to play an immense role in the creation of German identity. Through most outlets of German society the Holocaust remains present, dictating political actions, arguments, and negating outside opinions. What my research has pointed to is that while Germany has embraced fully the role as a perpetrator, going to expansive lengths to create positive in the world, the burden of this guilt, and hate of ones past, could create a new wave of racism and violence against “outsiders” who threated to bring this guilt back…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays