Nfl's Role In Civil Disobedience

Amazing Essays
Chase Cummings

ET Essay
Thoreau and Emerson, a group of transcendentalist who brought great ideals with them, through a time of struggle in the mid 1800’s.
The NFL, or National Football League, where stars can shine doing what they love for millions of fans.
Just as Emerson and Thoreau present their ideas in Civil Disobedience, the players in the NFL still emulate their ideas, maybe not all of the ideals, but they all feel they consist of a “majority of one.”
A first example of an NFL player protesting and emulating Civil Disobedience and the idea expressed throughout is Marshawn Lynch. Marshawn Lynch is a runningback for the Seattle Seahawks, and is known for his dynamic running and ability to power over people, which he receives the nickname
…show more content…
Brandon Marshall is a former Chicago Bear player and current wide receiver for the New York Jets; however, his form of “protest” takes place when he was a Bear. Marshall suffers from Borderline Personality Disorder, which means it can make you act out in places that you don’t want to. This affected him greatly over the years as he went through the beginning of his career moving from team to team as he had a couple domestic violence cases which were the result of this disorder. Brandon Marshall protested the NFL policy that "Each team must designate a dominant base color for its shoes, either black or white (with shoelace color conforming to the dominant base color of the tongue area of the shoe)." He wore in two cases bright neon cleats which resulted in a fine for both times. This sounds very familiar to Lynch’s case as presented above, and shows the same argument can be made. Thoreau uses a similar story with a different topic, the government, and shows that to never back down as long as you have a purpose to not do doing so. So what is Brandon Marshall’s purpose to wearing these obnoxious neon cleats? He uses them to wear awareness of mental illness. In response to the fine, Marshall posted this on …show more content…
One example of this is the use of PED’s (Performance Enhancing Drugs) in the NFL. In a more recent case the San Diego tight end, Antonio Gates, was charged for using PED’s. The NFL strictly prohibits the use of these as they first off, give that player an unfair advantage against others, and secondly are extremely dangerous to one's health. The people who use these don’t even know that they are protesting. In Gates’ case, he “[has] never knowingly ingested a substance that was banned by the NFL." This “accident” was to try and give Gates an unfair advantage by rehabilitating him faster from the injuries he suffered last year. The Gates’ case seems completely different from Thoreau’s ideas, and for the most part it is but there is one way it is very similar. In Civil Disobedience Thoreau says that it is important that each person do what they believe is right. Sure, Gates may have known the PED’s he was taking were illegal, but he felt that he was doing the right thing by taking them. When you take into account how old he really is and how much of a beating that these NFL players take, it seems like the correct thing to do. Going out on a further stretch one might propose the cases with Adrian Peterson and Ray Rice. Both violated the NFL’s policy of abuse and outside the league protocol. Adrian Peterson was charged with beating his child, and

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    That year was full of incidences involving domestic violence and substance abuse among athletes. In regards to this ad, the decision to not air it was most likely made by the NFL and not their sponsors. The advertisement promotes the NHL, which is one reason it was most likely chosen to be thrown out, and the second was the bad publicity it would stir back up for NFL players. Instead of this advertisement being pulled because of being unethical it was pulled because it was too transparent in regards to the misconduct among the players in my opinion. This is Ethical Egoism at its finest by the sponsors of the Super Bowl.…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The NFL had been aware of the concussions but did not do anything to help their players. Team doctors were told to sign off on players health to make sure they were able to play in the next game no matter what. Team doctors had to do whatever it took to make sure players are in the next game. With concussions being basically an invisible problem, not a physical injury, it was easy to cover up the problem from the public. Greed has played a strong part for why recognizing the dangers of concussions took longer than anticipated for Dr. Omalu.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The players’ health was at stake, and awarding cash prizes breached our ethical code, and more importantly, violated NFL policy. Sportswriter Peter King followed the League’s proceedings, and reported that “Such bounties… violate the NFL’s constitution and by-laws and the collective bargaining agreement, all of which state, ‘No bonuses or awards may be offered or paid for on-field misconduct’” (King). The ‘bounty-rule’— as it came to be known by the media, was embedded in the NFL’s foundational coda, and reflected an emphasis on moral play. This belief has a fatal flaw: neither document outlines any such ‘bounty-rule.’ King’s misattributed quote comes from a memo released by the League which outlines the bounty policy (NFL Communications). This memo is an interpretation of NFL Constitution and By-laws sections 9.1 (C)(8), and 9.3(F) and (G), both of which address Non-Contract bonuses (NFL Communications).…

    • 1380 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Domestic Violence in the NFL has become a terrible problem over the years, it has escalated and the NFL is having a difficult time controlling it. Dating back to the O.J Simpson trial in 1994, the NFL had no plan for these types of cases. The old NFL Commissioner Paul Tagliabue thought that if it didn’t happen on the field it didn’t affect the NFL organization (Barrabi). Imagine that kind of a response now? Our society would be outraged more than they already are about this issue.…

    • 1630 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Nfl Rules History

    • 1543 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Safety over Entertainment Football has evolved into a very popular sport in the United States of America. Evolution of the rules in the National Football League has been necessary because if they had never changed, player substitutions would be prohibited and communication with the sidelines would not be allowed. That is a major part of the game today, and has had a positive effect on the game. The rules have changed in the past in order to make the game more entertaining and safer for the players. With that same intention, more and more rules are being changed but some people have come to the conclusion that, more rules will only ruin the game.…

    • 1543 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When compiling a list of the all-time great quarterbacks in the National Football League one may mention names such as Joe Montana, Dan Morino, Peyton Manning, John Elway, or Otto Graham. Due to the controversy surrounding his team and his play in the past decade some may decide to leave a name off of this list. This name is Tom Brady. While it is certainly reasonable to question his spot in history because of this controversy, what is undeniable is Brady’s remarkable skills at the quarterback position. To many these skills would include arm strength, accuracy, and athleticism.…

    • 1299 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The NFL called Kaepernick's actions “distracting” and “embarrassing” which are definitely understatements. Although, I do have to add, as for me, a citizen of the United States of America and the granddaughter of a veteran can also agree of the words spoken on behalf of the NFL. Now is the time where we try and find a solution to this problem. Making a deal with the NFL and cutting the athletes pay for every time they kneel seems too nice of us, although everyone knows how much those athletes adore their money. We could pull from the source of the money and drop all sponsorships these players have if they kneel during the anthem.…

    • 1114 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    NFL Scandal Research Paper

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This comes from the good number of ESPN analysts that were just siding with the NFL. Many people believe that it was an unfair suspension to give Tom Brady (4 Games) this also shows in the fact that the NFL TV ratings have never been lower this year and Tom Brady is not there to save them. Another reason is this looks bad in the reputation of the NFL is the fact that the first trial was thrown away by the judge as there was not enough evidence that there was any deflation of the footballs and to have Tom Brady be suspended. However Roger Goodell had the case reopened by a new judge from here Bray’s suspension was upheld and he missed four games this season. It especially looks bad with the fact that people pay good money just to go see in Tom Brady play and it was…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Corporal Punishment Essay

    • 1185 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Peterson 's public battle to be cleared of the charges of abuse and to be allowed reinstatement to the NFL have proved to be a catalyst in the fiery debate over what constitutes child abuse. Although it is understandable why Peterson is confused about his actions being termed as abuse due to the community he was raised in, it does not condone the use of physical violence as discipline. The type of penalty which Peterson exercised as punishment is detrimental to his child 's development and misses the target of instruction and preparation for the real world which the punishment is supposed to…

    • 1185 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    A main problem with the continuous collision between the brain and skull is that it causes CTE from anyone ages eighteen and up. While Gladwell talked about the medical issues, Bissinger explained why he thought college football should be banned. Bissinger believed that “grown men had the right to decided because they know the risk, college football players do not. All they receive is a scholarship and some perks, but no real information. (Bissinger)” Bissinger is mainly argumentative about banning college football because the young athletes looking for scholarships are not informed of the risks of playing in college.…

    • 595 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays