Migrant Workers Book Review

Improved Essays
Seth Holmes does a wonderful job shining a light on the current problems that migrant agricultural workers have in the United States. His balance of personal experience with background research allows the audience to empathize with the migrant workers as well as understand some of the systematic problems. Our group seems to thoroughly enjoy reading this book and we have discussed a host of different topics brought up in the reading. The talking points which I have connected with were about the individual reasons why immigrants are coming to the United States and how they relate to the systematic problems. Holmes has given me new insight into the reason why many Hispanics are immigrating as well as disproving many of the myths. Immigrants …show more content…
As hard as their live is as a migrant worker in the United States, it still is better than back where they lived. Although I found this hard to imagine at first, I began to realize that for many migrants they are making a rational choice. As one person in our group pointed out, even though it seems like they might be better off not coming to the United States, they are not going to sit in their homes without work and starve to death. They are going to try to actively pursue a better life, even if it is only slightly better. The United States is often presented as “the land of opportunity,” however, that does not apply so much to the migrant workers. One of the other problems of why there is such hardship year after year is that there is not an option, especially for indigenous people, for upward …show more content…
In my eyes, the largest problem is that the North Atlantic Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) does not regulate Agricultural trade. Since NAFTA does not put restrictions on government subsidies on agricultural, it ends up distorting trade between the United States and Mexico. Many Mexicans and indigenous groups cannot compete in the agricultural market. The price of US grown crops, like corn, is so cheap that it drives down the price in Mexico to unsustainable levels. Agricultural workers are put out of work and the jobs that are available are in the United States. Much to my surprise, the agricultural system in the United States actually encourages and needs migrant workers. Scott, one of the crop managers confirms

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Summary Many people migrate every day to get away from harsh, cruel, and unsanitary environments. Majority of them have a choice to either flee or escape to different environment, however, the Triqui people was not offered an option to stay or go. They were targeted and look upon differently because they brought lots of violence and ruckus. Therefore, because of their actions they were forced to leave the land and forced by global markets to migrate to an area that was less hospitable.…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “I’ll offer anybody here $50 an hour if you’ll go pick lettuce in Yuma this season, and pick for the whole season,” he said. Amid jeers, he didn’t back down, telling the audience, “You can’t do it, my friends.” (Thompson 82) Regardless the amount of being offered to most Americans, No one will accept the job and rather choose to work at fast food chain or retail than work in the field and get more pay. Most Americans will not challenge themselves to work in the field to gain more skills in agriculture and will let the undocumented do the hard work.…

    • 1228 Words
    • Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The physician anthropologist, Seth Holmes wrote, Fresh Fruit, Broken Bodies: Migrant farm workers in the united states in 2013 a book that displays the essence of Mexican migrant through an ethnographic sense. This book illustrates the suffering, violence and health problems that indigenous Mexican migrant’s workers faced. In common with what migrant workers dealt with the author also experience problems of his own. He wanted first hand research so he traveled on the bus from Oaxaca, Mexico to cross the border with migrants. On the way he met with Triqui families and even nine men whom he ended up traveling with.…

    • 1296 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Why do thousands of people every year immigrate into our country without proper documentation? In a myriad of these cases, the reason is to escape from hardship and suffering. One of the most common regions people emigrate from is Mexico, and the reasons for this are developed within The Distance Between Us by Reyna Grande. This book tells the true story of a girl that journeyed to the United States of America with her brother and sister, all as undocumented immigrants, in order to live with their father. The author of this memoir not only explains the privation she dealt with in her home land of Mexico, but she also demonstrates the racial division and other forms of adversity that were present within the United States of America, or El Otro…

    • 1201 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The US is facing a problem right now that make a lot of people debate about what is right or what is wrong in taking immigration. Thousands of immigrant have entered the US by many ways such as crossing border illegally, staying legally through visa but never come back to their original country when the visa expired .The number is continue to rise without stopping that make a significant effect on American life. Would you rather stay in a poor country with no hope or live in another rich country with higher standard of living in every aspect and a brand new future is waiting for you? The answer is simple that crossed thousand, millions of these immigrant’s mind.…

    • 199 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Slavery by Another Name This video starts soon after the 13th amendment is ratified and slavery is abolished (at least on paper). The cotton economy was severely hurt from the new need of payed labor. The farm owners had about half of their investments in slave labor.…

    • 1935 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Today the United States are commonly referred to as a melting pot due to people of all different races, customs and beliefs coming together and melting as one. When people come to the United States they generally have a vision for what’s called the American Dream; this dream either consists of hitting it big with wealth and materialistic things, or hitting it big and being able to provide for one’s family. In The Circuit self-written by Francisco Jimenez, the author narrates a story of how he and his family of migrant workers arrived from Mexico to California in search of consistent work to provide for the family. Over a span of years, Francisco comes to terms and reality of what the true American Dream is and how it can only be established…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I did not really know what to think when I started reading Labor and Legality by Ruth Gomberg-Munoz. I did not really know about the topic of Mexican immigration and their need to find work in the U.S. Honestly, most of my knowledge came from the media and what I had previously learned about how it was wrong that Mexicans were coming into the U.S and “stealing” our jobs away. However, this book changed my opinion drastically about not only the struggle that immigrant Mexican workers face coming to the U.S, but how we (the united states) as a country, only think about ourselves, instead of thinking of a broader world view of the situation. That, is what I am going to talk about in my paper, the U.S refusal to look at the immigrant network in…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Americans doubled their consumption of fresh strawberries. Last year California shipped 76 million boxes of fresh strawberries (a box, also called a flat or tray, holds a dozen pints and weighs roughly eleven and a half pounds), an all-time record” (Schlosser). According to Eric Schlosser, writer of the article “In the Strawberry Fields,” Americans have greatly increased their consumption of strawberries. But, at what cost?…

    • 1653 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    David Cole in “Five Myths about Immigration” simply takes about the five common myths of immigration in the United States. The five myths being that immigrants are overrunning the country, immigrants take jobs from natural born citizens, immigrants drain societies resources, aliens and immigrants don’t assimilate to our culture, and immigrants are not entitled to constitutional rights. All of these myths are displayed to be completely wrong and were created out of ignorance fueled by fear/lack of education on the many benefits immigrants have on United States society, economy, culture, and unity of our nation. Immigrants do not and are not overrunning the country in fact first-generation immigrants make up only had made up in 1990 only made…

    • 1093 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Yesenia Granados As a Mexican American I have grown up in a family where working in the fields is very common. My parents have worked in seasonal jobs since a very young age when they arrived in the United States. Both of my parents first started working in Florida where they picked tomatoes, pepper, cucumber, tangerine, orange, grapefruit among many other types of fruits and vegetables. At very young age I remember my parents taking me to the fields with them to work.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Mexican Migrant

    • 1733 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The World of Mexican Migrants Migration of Mexicans is not a new topic, regardless of their destination. It has been going on for hundreds of years. Each migrant has a different story, and a different reason for moving. Of the Mexicans interviewed by Judith Hellman, the author of the book, The World of Mexican Migrants, it is clear that many of them migrated to the United States in order to create new and better lives for themselves, help their parents as much as possible, and raise a family in which all members are, and stay together: this migration has changed the lives of these people by teaching them to hold down a job, stay out of legal trouble, and save and budget their money. Mexicans of all ages migrate to the United States, for many…

    • 1733 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When NAFTA was debated, the impact of agriculture to U.S. economy was unknown. The fact was that agriculture was a relatively larger sector in Mexico than in the United States: it accounted for 7 percent of GDP and 24 percent of employment in Mexico, compared to 1.6 percent of GDP and 2 percent of employment in the United States. Mexican agriculture was characterized by small scale enterprises, relatively low productivity, and high trade barriers on the main crops produced by subsistence farmers according to Burfisher & Robinson & Thierfelder (2001). To constrain the cost of this program, the government also restricted imports to maintain the high domestic market price. This scenario presented prediction that this would disrupt Mexico’s rural…

    • 225 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Fresh Fruits Broken Bodies: Migrant workers in the United States the author, Seth Holmes writes about how Free Trade has ruined the lives of indigenous Mexicans. Holmes goes into detail about how these trade ideas ate away at Mexico’s economy, leading to land wars and mass migration. Holmes, also delves into not only the economic cost of the neoliberal economic ideas, but also the human cost. Holmes also mentions how the indigenous people lost many of their own farms in United States owned farms and how that has forced citizens to leave and look for work. Free Trade is one of those ideas that had such great intentions, such as making it easier and cheaper to purchase products from over borders due to lack of things such as tariffs.…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Immigration has seemingly always been a major topic and controversial issue in political campaigns. There are a large array of considerations that must be taken into account when addressing this issue and forming a solution. With many people having different views on the matter it often times proves to be near impossible to come up with a solution that pleases everyone. However, with proper speculation and insight on the matter, there are ways in which the goal of having a stable immigration system can be achieved. With the origin of the United States revolving around immigration from Europe, essentially we are all immigrants to a certain extent.…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays