Fresh Fruits Broken Bodies Analysis

Improved Essays
In Fresh Fruits Broken Bodies: Migrant workers in the United States the author, Seth
Holmes writes about how Free Trade has ruined the lives of indigenous Mexicans. Holmes goes into detail about how these trade ideas ate away at Mexico’s economy, leading to land wars and mass migration. Holmes, also delves into not only the economic cost of the neoliberal economic ideas, but also the human cost. Holmes also mentions how the indigenous people lost many of their own farms in United States owned farms and how that has forced citizens to leave and look for work.
Free Trade is one of those ideas that had such great intentions, such as making it easier and cheaper to purchase products from over borders due to lack of things such as tariffs.
However,
…show more content…
The land wars were in part due to the lack of resources caused by NAFTA, by killing of domestic industries and exporting those jobs elsewhere. Rather than distributing the gains and all profiting from this agreement, so free trade
Huynh 2 and in particular NAFTA has drained the Mexican economy and left what remains to rot. Much like Holmes I find that the ideas and agreements based on free trade had only gone on to hurt
Mexico’s economy and its citizens’ livelihood.
Free Trade in North America now is practically unanimous with the North American Free
Trade Agreement, now better known as NAFTA, its intended objective in the eyes of the United
States and Mexico was to stem the flow of migrants from Mexico. This was to be achieved by allowing more businesses to open and hire locals. However, after many years of NAFTA being in effect history has shown that it only helps to inflate the problem. Economically, Mexican industry can no longer compete with the Americans, as Alejandro Ramirez, general director
…show more content…
With four men to a house he collected
$800 monthly for a residence that had a fair market rent value of $300.”(492) This is not uncommon for those looking to escape poverty to accept these kinds of conditions because in the end it simply seems better for them this way to bring in money. This is how we became the big winners in the NAFTA agreement, we gain cheap labor, we gain a silent workforce that will not revolt in fear of deportation, and lastly we get to sell back some of the meat to Mexico crushing whatever farms are left in the process.For those that survive the aftermaths of NAFTA, they have no choice but to migrate north to America, the simple fact is there are no jobs left.
NAFTA has been a less than reliable treaty for Mexico due the cheaper pricing of imports the local economy and infrastructure has been eaten away and replaced with American companies cheaper alternatives. Which normally hire migrants to process the product. This
Treaty has also forced many migrants to move north for even the slightest chance at survival.
Much like Holmes states NAFTA has forced many to start migrating to the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Lacking Cultural Competency In the book Fresh Fruit Broken Bodies written, by Seth Holmes who has a PHD in anthropology, he writes about Triqui migrants, and how they migrate up and down the west coast of the United States. Risking their lives crossing the borders to work in US, therefore they face various obstacles and, being morbidity situations. The way the migrants are being treated in the hospitals and clinics is unreasonable the healthcare workers both in the US and Mexico lack ' ' cultural competency ' '. In the Inter professional Care Betancourt defines, Cultural competency ‘’as set of behaviors and attitudes and a culture within business or operation of system that respects and takes into account the person’s cultural background,…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Health care and basic amenities for life were not being made readily available forcing families to steal or subjugate themselves to “debt-slavery” to have enough food. Illegally entering the United States also helped many families have enough income to provide food. The Mexican government did not create enough jobs with adequate income to support families which led to many families moving to the United States (Sergie, M.…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Seth Holmes does a wonderful job shining a light on the current problems that migrant agricultural workers have in the United States. His balance of personal experience with background research allows the audience to empathize with the migrant workers as well as understand some of the systematic problems. Our group seems to thoroughly enjoy reading this book and we have discussed a host of different topics brought up in the reading. The talking points which I have connected with were about the individual reasons why immigrants are coming to the United States and how they relate to the systematic problems. Holmes has given me new insight into the reason why many Hispanics are immigrating as well as disproving many of the myths.…

    • 1083 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Maquiladora Case Study

    • 174 Words
    • 1 Pages

    In October 1996, after the implementation of NAFTA, the Secretariat of Commerce and Industrial Development ("SECOFI"), which reviews applications and grants permits for Maquiladoras, was given the power to deny or cancel existing permits if SECOFI determined that the Maquiladora's operations would have an adverse affect on the Mexican national non-Maquiladora industry.1 This was a protective measure to mitigate the effects of allowing Maquiladoras to sell their products within the domestic Mexican market. That same year, Maquiladora operations became subject to taxation on the value of assets imported into Mexico, or, as an alternative, compliance with Mexico's income tax law provisions on transfer pricing.2 The transfer pricing law allowed…

    • 174 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With the present day president of the USA, Donald Trump, NAFTA is being put on the line of keeping the negotiations going or not. “With America out of NAFTA, experts say, prices on everything from cars to groceries are expected to climb. Tens of thousands of jobs would be at risk as supply chains are torn apart” (Hutchins 27). Canada is so intertwined with the American economy that if the US backs out of NAFTA, Canada’s economy will plummet and jobs will either be lost or at risk. The CUSFTA set the groundwork for NAFTA in the early 1990’s allowing Canada to be a big player for exportations and…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    North American organizations, purchasers, families, specialists, and agriculturists have all profited from NAFTA. Every NAFTA nation swears off tariffs on imported merchandise originating in the other NAFTA nations. These standards empower customs authorities to choose which products fit the bill for this particular tax treatment under NAFTA. The arbitrators of the Agreement looked to make these principles clear to give assurance and consistency to makers, exporters, and shippers. They additionally tried to guarantee that NAFTA 's advantages are not reached out to merchandise imported from non-NAFTA nations that have experienced just insignificant transforming in North America.…

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Costs are lowered for farm products, too. NAFTA also help to increased higher wages in several careers in Canada, such as engineering, education and, etc. Moreover, it creates more trade opportunities in Canada and leads to an increase in productivity gradually. However, with the introducing of NAFTA, led to a dramatic amount of jobs lost in manufacturing industries in Canada which include automotive, textile, computer and electrical appliance; for Mexico labor was cheaper.…

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1994 the North American Free Trade Agreement came into effect,creating one of the worlds largest free trade zones and laying the foundations for the strong economic growth and rising prosperity for Canada,Mexico and the United States. Since then, NAFTA has demonstrated how free trade increases wealth,competitiveness,delivering real benefits to families,farmers,workers,manufacturers…

    • 1329 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Multiculturalism In Canada

    • 1037 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the past 70 years since the end of World War II, Canada has evolved from the soldiers following the orders of Great Britain to the modern bankers of the world. The change in Canada’s global image reflects the metamorphosis that has transformed this country. Canadian domestic legislation has developed the foundation of Canada’s national identity, one that values multiculturalism, human rights, diversity, and the welfare of its citizens. Canada’s trade and economic policy has helped establish Canada’s independency and has given the country a reputation for having good financial practices, establishing Canada as a prosperous country. Canada’s involvement in wars post-World War II, the creation of the Canadian Forces, and Canada’s role as peacekeepers…

    • 1037 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The physician anthropologist, Seth Holmes wrote, Fresh Fruit, Broken Bodies: Migrant farm workers in the united states in 2013 a book that displays the essence of Mexican migrant through an ethnographic sense. This book illustrates the suffering, violence and health problems that indigenous Mexican migrant’s workers faced. In common with what migrant workers dealt with the author also experience problems of his own. He wanted first hand research so he traveled on the bus from Oaxaca, Mexico to cross the border with migrants. On the way he met with Triqui families and even nine men whom he ended up traveling with.…

    • 1296 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    1837 Texas Treaty

    • 2220 Words
    • 9 Pages

    In 1836 Texas declared themselves independent from Mexico, but of course Mexico does not recognize this at first. In 1837 Texas asked the United States to be annexed into their country, but at the time the United States could not accept a new state because of two reasons. The first reason for this was that The States had just reached a balance between Slave States and Free States and with Texas wanting to be a Slave State they would upset that balance. The second reason is that Mexico made it so that if the United States annexed Texas then they would cut off all diplomatic relations. In that The United States basically ignores Texas’s requests to be annexed.…

    • 2220 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    First, although opponents acknowledged the low costs of Mexican labor, they believed increased supply of Mexican labor would hurt urban laborers and small family farmers. Because Mexicans were willing to work at extremely low wages, white laborers in urban environments and the transportation sector would be unable to compete (Reisler, pp. 247). Proponents of Mexican labor easily shot this argument down. They reasoned that unlike European immigrants, Mexican laborers only took jobs that were undesirable to white Americans (Reisler, pp. 249). Mexican labor would also continue the perpetuation of a plantation agricultural system in the Southwest (Reisler, pp.…

    • 1508 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some people may say that “America is the land of opportunity”. Especially the Mexicans in the 1940s. America seemed to guarantee economic opportunity for them when their country could not. As described in the Weekly Reader’s article, “The Bracero Program”, during World War II the United States needed farmworkers to harvest crops and feed the nation since men were fighting in Europe and many women working in the industry. At the same time, the unemployment rate and crop failures were increasing in Mexico.…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Barry R. Chiswick’s assumption of whether or not native born Americans would jump to “pick the lettuce” in a sudden halt to illegal migrant labor is far more complex than the reasoning that there is an existing population of native born Americans capable of executing such jobs. There is no question that Americans are capable of completing the jobs many migrant workers hold. The jobs are not meant to be specialty ones, which essentially allow for any average American to successfully complete them. In the article “The Worker Next Door,” the author’s argument that the halt of migrant labor would not result in a major economic catastrophe is flawed, because there are jobs that American workers will not and do not do.…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the 1990’s alone Mexican manufacturing wages fell 21%. Although not all of Mexico's problems are caused by NAFTA, many have a direct link to it. As an example, under NAFTA, about five hundred thousand jobless Mexicans have migrated into the U.S. per year forced to leave their jobs because of competition or poor wages. As a result of the problems NAFTA has caused, 25 percent of the population (about 32 million) lives in poverty, and on top of that one fifth of all Mexican…

    • 955 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays