Karl Marx And Weber's Theory Of Modernity

Great Essays
Karl Marx is the first of a series of 19th and 20th century theorists who began to call for an empirical approach to social science. Theorizing about the rise of modernity accompanied by a decline in traditional societies and advocating for change in the means of production to allow for social justice. Marx 's theory of modernity to reveal their beliefs of modern society, as are affected by the development of the productive forces of modern industry and capitalist relations of production and between wage workers. Concept of modernity refers to the post-feudal historical period that is characterized by a shift away from feudalism to capitalism. Modernity is focused on the impact of the rise of capitalism has on social relationships, and notes …show more content…
Weber disposition of a modern transformed modern society in a metaphorical iron cage. Iron cage represents the involvement of the whole society to a modern, mechanized transforming the company initially thought to be controllable, with the ability to detangle from the machines at any time, such as housing, which can be removed. Throughout history, however, Marx notes that this splices become permanent and the individual has been locked in a cage of modern society with more social realization of a control manifest in excessive bureaucracy. Karl Marx and Max Weber made significant contributions to the field of sociology, and both theorists support their argument. I think that Marx was right in terms of its conception of social structure being the creation of man, and therefore in the realm of change under the leadership of a man.; However, I believe that there are limitations in the idealistic nature of his utopian dream. Maintaining a utopian goal as a social change exposes inherently distorts the analysis of the sociological phenomenon, because there is neglect examining the social problems of the micro, from day to day, orientation basically proving the existence of male Eurocentric bias historically found within sociology. I also agree with Weber connection between the Protestant work …show more content…
Marx believed in historical materialism and class struggle, which shows that the private ownership of the means of production allowed the bourgeoisie to retain power over a larger powerless proletarian who provided labor to the means of production. As a consequence of this inequality of power, Marx concludes, social and moral problems were inherent in the capitalist system, which forced the competition and create unnecessary antagonisms, essentially isolating the proletariat in their social status across generations.
The Marxist view of capitalism and work in parallel in many ways with Max Weber 's perspective on these issues, with subtle differences resulting from the cause of capitalism. For Marx, the theory of historical materialism to the conclusion that all human institutions, including religion, were based on economic fundamentals, with the implication that the economic fundamentals come first. In contrast, Weber 's The Protestant Ethic disputes that claim and instead implies a religious movement as responsible for supporting capitalism is not yet fully discount the theory of

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Marxism The Crucible

    • 1524 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Imagine living in a world where no human oppresses another. Imagine living in a world where no one is poor and no one is rich. Imagine living in a world where the social class system is non-existent. Karl Marx, a 19th century philosopher, foresaw the image of this apparent communist utopia forming in every society; he expected the maltreated working classes to fight back against those who have immense, misused power. He believed that material possessions have a powerful enough influence on our lives to be considered the sole reason of historical change.…

    • 1524 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Weber establishes that the spirit of capitalism is imbedded in the Protestant ethic. He explains that those who are financially successful have roots in Protestantism. This can be explained by “…the spirit of hard work, of progress, or whatever else…

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Marx and Weber were great sociologists, but they had entirely different concepts when it comes to sociology. Marx had the socialist perspective when it came to sociology. He believed that the relationship between people is based on how much money that a person makes. And he believed that the middle class or as he called it the “working Class” has to ban together and rise up to revolt against the upper class.…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Everyone sees the world differently. With this, it means that every aspect of the social world will differ depending on the person. There are many ways to view the world. Some chose to see it in a positive light, while other believe perceive it in a negative manner. Sociologist like Durkheim, Weber, and Marx all viewed the social world in a different way.…

    • 952 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thomas More portrayed the society of Utopia as a perfect society, a society that all the writers strive to create in their own ways. More described Utopia as a society where there is no private property ownership. People live in homes without any locks for a total of ten years before they rotate to go to another house using a lottery system (Utopia Book II 7). Furthermore, everyone is treated equally and there is an abundance of everything as Raphael described, “Utopians have plenty of everything, including time to contribute to society and improve their minds” (Utopia Book II 9). Since there is an abundance of everything, people are not greedy.…

    • 1694 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Max Weber is one of the philosophers best explain to us the peculiar economic system we live with us called capitalism. He was born and raised in Germany where he saw the dramatic changes in the industrial revolution. Cities where growing and companies were forming a new managerial elite replacing the old aristocracy. Weber spent his life analyzing this changes and he develop some key ideas with we could better understand the workings in future of capitalism. Why does capitalism exist?…

    • 396 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Karl Marx was a German philosopher, economist, sociologist, journalist, historian and revolutionary socialist who died in 1883; thus, leaving behind his legacy through his theories. Contemporarily known as Marxism, it is understood that “Marx holds production to be both the most fundamental and the most encompassing of human activities” (Wood, 1981, p.32). Marxism exploits sociological and economic development through his theological approach to capitalism; this is not “an explanatory concept” but rather one to describe and diagnose the ramifications of capitalism by examining its ethical parameters (Wood, 1981, p.44). A capitalist society defines a ruling class which sells the labour power of the working classes in return for a working wage. Further…

    • 1494 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The period of industrialization influenced the three classical sociological theorists, Marx, Durkheim and Weber. Marx thought of industrialization in the most negative of ways compared to the other sociological theorists. With the rise of industrialization, the social classes changed to who was related to the mean of production, so the owners of the factories and machinery were called the bourgeois, who had more power than the proletariat, those working in the factories, creating the product. With this class distinction, Marx believed that it would lead to problems and conflict between the classes, because each class had their own interest, for instance, the bourgeoisie might be more interested in creating a product faster and cheaper, while…

    • 1399 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Weber Vs Nietzsche

    • 593 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Nietzsche perspective on contract and punishment is more compelling to me than the other thinkers. I also think that Nietzsche and Marx are overlapping in some areas, and also Marx and Weber. Nietzsche perspective sounds compelling to me, because he is explaining the moral words we are using based on its origin. We use moral concepts the way how it has been used a long time ago, and we use those concepts based on its history “, the moral conceptual world of ‘debt’, ‘conscience’, ‘duty’, ‘sacred duty’, has its breeding ground – all began with a thorough and prolonged bloodletting, like the beginning of all great things on earth” (41). The words get it is meaning from the way that it has been used.…

    • 593 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Both Weber and Foucault conceptualised power and domination in different ways. Weber saw power in terms of authority that emanated and descended from above via powerful agents whereas Foucault saw power as an agentless horizontal force (Rudolph, 2006, p. 3). The differences between the three social theorists and their respected theories is that Marx focuses on economic power, particularly social and economic relationships and how it contributed to production. It was Marx’s belief that the ideal achievement of socialism led to equality and liberation. Weber contrasts to Marx by concentrating on status and rationalisation, believing that Marxism meant that the state had too much control and it potentially could lead to loss of freedoms for the individual.…

    • 1874 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    In Max Weber’s arguably most influential work, The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, Weber argues that a specific religious ethic shaped how Capitalism spread across the globe and transitioned into the modern age. Influenced by the idea of the ‘calling’ or one’s worldly task determined by God (39), this ethic actually incentivized people to work more in their mundane, secular occupations in order to accumulate physical wealth as an indication of God’s favor. Overall, this essay will be a self-discussion of the various ideas Weber introduces as well as other topics that caught my attention while reading his work. One aspect I like about Weber is his approach to understand modern Capitalism as a product of religion.…

    • 1764 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Marxism in The Hunger Games If there is any perfect representation of Marxism in film it is in The Hunger Games. For this case study, I will be focusing on the first movie of the trilogy. This paper will overview the way Marxism is shown in The Hunger Games using a few examples from the movie. In this paper, I argue that The Hunger Games’ plot line has Marxism theories extremely exposed and almost blatantly exposed. Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels developed Marxism in the early 1900s.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The most fundamental and important of these conflicts is that between the Bourgeoisie (those who own and control the means of production in society) and the Proletariat (those who simply sell their labor power in the market place of Capitalism)”. (Theories, 2009) One of the reasons that the philosophy of Karl Marx and Marxism is so misunderstood is the connection that society makes to…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    page 184 " the most important opponent with which the spirit of capitalism, in the sense of a definite standard of life claiming ethical sanction, has had to struggle, was that type of attitude and reaction actuations we may designate as traditionalism" Weber believed that there had to have been a in between stage in order for people to stop practicing their traditional spirit of religion and transfer over to the spirit of capitalism and he believed it was the seed planted by the Protestant religion that help transform Western society. Where traditionally people would work long enough to support a traditional life they lived in a farm based or rule society where they could barter for services. Protestants believe that the harder you worked the more God would bless you. Proving to be successful economically showed that you were in God 's favor and that you would go to heaven. You live to work for the goal of unlimited wealth.…

    • 1206 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Their system of administration combined both their own as well as Roman elements. The new social order saw the dominance of the military commander, who became the monarch & a new nobility, drawn from warriors and an educated, Romanised elite. Peasants, who constituted their armies, became impoverished due to continual warfare. This led to their enserfment to feudal lords. There existed 2 kinds of groupings in feudal Europe- serfs and lords in villages and craftsmen & journeymen or apprenti who were part of the guild organization in towns.…

    • 2286 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays

Related Topics