Lou Ann Case Study

Improved Essays
Suspicions on Lou Ann
As it was said before, Lou Ann’s attitude was suspicious all the way. Her bitter relation with her husband was well-known by the time, but being so upbeat and cheerful in Jerry’s funeral? There was a missing piece.
Even more, she didn’t appear on court a single day of the trial. Not for Jerry, not for her best friend. Not even on the day of the verdict. She was the great absent in the courtroom.
Further strangely, the prosecutor’s theory was that both Lou Ann and Debra were confabulated in a conspiracy to murder Jerry for his inheritance and life insurance money. Debra was found guilty, but why was not Lou Ann investigated? It felt frightening that two women could carry out a homicidal scheme and walk free with such ease.
…show more content…
“I talked to jurors about why they would give her probation. They said they felt she was the scapegoat, that the widow was the one who had committed the crime.” So if the DA had prosecuted Lou Ann at the same time than Debra, the outcome might have been to be different.
Another problem is that as Jerry was never able to investigate if the money robbery was conducted by Debra Lynn Baker herself, the prosecutor could not use that as a motive. Rather, he used a much more wobbly motive: that Debra killed Jerry Sternadel so he could not divorce Lou Ann and she wouldn’t lose her rights to Jerry’s inheritance. Yet, the jury could not deny the fact that arsenic was found in a storage unit owned by Debra Lynn Baker under a false identification, which made it suspicious. But they believe she was a stooge rather than the leader of the operation. The sentence was called a “Travesty of justice” by the DA.
Still, it’s clear he made a big mistake by not charging Lou Ann Sternadel for murder, too.
Justice gets served… Sort of
So Debra Lynn Baker walks free with a little probation sentence and Lou Ann with mere suspicion and Jerry Sternadel’s
…show more content…
She was 56 years old by the time. Becky Sternadel, Jerry’s oldest daughter, said she was going to continue seeking justice for her father. "No, I don't think justice has been served (…) Texas prides itself on being hard on crime yet a convicted murderer gets ten years probation" She also declared to News Channel 6 "The criminal justice system in Texas has failed the Sternadel family since 1990"
"All my friends, my family, my mother, we all sent in protest letters to make sure she served all her time in prison and that's what she did. She served every single day," Becky Sternadel declared to the press the day Baker was freed.
But Becky inherited some of her father’s character and stubbornness and said she would keep brawling until every person involved in her father’s homicide is put in prison. "I don't honestly know what my reaction would be if I ever was to actually see her face to face but I did write her a letter to her in prison. I don't know if she got the letter or not. I told her I would never stop ever until she serves the rest of her life in

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The readers especially get to see how self centered Abigail is when she lies in court and the end result is John getting accused of witchcraft and getting sentenced to jail for it. Abigail let the man she loved die to save herself. She could have stopped it, she could have prevented many deaths, but that is not the way Abigail works, it is never her head and always others. Obviously Abigail does not care about the ones she loves but, her uncle Parris learned that the hard way. Abigail made a fool out of Parris she left him without hint of where she was going.…

    • 1143 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the first trial where John Proctor is defending his wife, he states “There are them that cannot sing, and them that cannot weep—my wife cannot lie” (Miller 1259). Earlier in the play he admitted to his wife “God help me, I lusted, and there is a promise in such sweat” (Miller 1259). John had committed adultery when Abigail was the Proctors’ servant, which explains why Abigail is out for Elizabeth’s blood. Due to the fact that John admitted his appalling crime to Elizabeth, he thought by admitting it to the court, and her confirming it, it would prove that she cannot lie and is innocent. He does such this; He confesses to Danforth and the deputy calls in Elizabeth to ask “Look at me!…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ree eventually tries to talk to the local crime boss Thump Milton but, he refused to see her. The only information she came about was that her father Jessup either died in a fire from trying to cook meth or skipped town to avoid trial. Also, she is warned by Merab to stop looking for information that should never be exposed. When Jessup fails to appears to his court trial, Ree tells the bondsman that Jessup have to be dead because “Dollys don’t run”, he does not believe her and tells her she must provide proof of his death to avoid the bond being forfeited or the house will be seized. The bail bondsman inform Ree that her family only have one week left with the house.…

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Also, during her trial, information was withheld due to Stanton’s personal persona, this evidence wasn’t realised until two years after Mary was hanged. The last reason why the punishment did not fit the crime is Dr. Mudd received less of a punishment when in fact, he helped John Wilkes Booth more than Mary. Even Though Mary likely knew about the kidnapping, it was unlikely she knew about the assassination. This is because Booth wanted to keep it very unknown and he could not risk…

    • 546 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She could have stopped all the accusations at this moment if she did not fall for the girls, but now Abigail is still free allowing more and more people to be accused and hanged. Not only that, but the person she came to defend is still in jail and now she accused another innocent person to witchcraft. Even though Mary Warren tried to save Elizabeth Proctor in court, she fails to do this and instead of saving her, she also accuses her husband of witchcraft. This is just another innocent accused of something they have never done because of Mary Warren. Cleary, Mary Warren is to blame as even though she tried to do the right thing she didn’t and instead did the wrong…

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The man was arrested and released that same night because the police department stated that there was not enough evidence to charge him with the murder. My mother was not going to settle for that, so she hired an attorney to try and set up an actual trial because she felt that whoever did this to her boys deserved to live the rest of their lives behind bars. By May 5,2015, the story was being broadcasted nationwide and the Department of Justice decided to begin investigating the shooting. The shooter was identified as Alex Derek Ward, a thirty-two-year-old male from Winterville, North Carolina. Before the first trial session, the lawyer told my mother and I that since this was a case dealing with an African American family versus a Caucasian male, he would have to pull every string that he could for justice to be served correctly.…

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wright should have been found innocent of killing her husband, John Wright, due to the lack of evidence in the case by the time it happened (1917.) Nowadays, in 2018, as a Juror, even while knowing the evidence that was hidden by the moment this crime occurred, would still declare Mrs. Wright innocent of any crime committed. The constant violent scenario she went through as part of her daily routine was the main reason that led her into killing Mr. John Wright, and this could be considered as an act of self defense against a psychological and physical abusive husband, reason why she should be free of any guilt and charge against her. Regarding Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters, even though nowadays hiding the bird would have been considered as withholding and tampering with evidence since the bird happened to be a main key of this case, I would declare them innocent of these charges since by the time this crime happened, the bird would not have been recognized as evidence of any matter for this…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wright was not mentally ill and that the murder was justified: “[Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters] reflect her husband would not have liked a thing that sang and would have silenced it as he silenced the singing Minnie. As they share and ponder, the mundane details of Minnie 's life lead Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters to comprehend what their husbands do not: the motive for the murder” (Holstein 283-284). That quote shows how the women knew who the murderer was and why she killed her husband. Considering they knew that, a person would think they would tell the sheriff of all the clues they had found. However, they chose to stay quiet because they believed the murder was justified: “Mrs.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Andrea Yates Case

    • 868 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Often times, I think the insanity defense is used consciously to escape penalties of the law. Or perhaps it can be referred to as the “defense of last resort,” when there is no question that the accused committed the act and the defense can think of nothing else to exonerate his/her client. Consider the case of Andrea Yates. In my opinion, Yates knew the difference between right and wrong at the time of the drownings. Yates did not believe she was washing laundry or putting out a fire.…

    • 868 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Although his use of unnecessary force and punishments showed very legalistic actions, his use of force not only violated the principle of Ren, but also the Golden Rule (Do not impose on others what you do not wish for yourself). Take a look at Dee 's punishments with Widow Djou. When she first entered the court, she failed to confess to her murder. Due to her continued claims of innocence, Judge Dee grew angry and started to whip and torture her, going against the value of humanity or even basic courtesy. " 'We shall see whether or not you shall confess under torture.…

    • 1500 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays