Is The Quality Of Journal In The Physical Review?

Improved Essays
1. Please summarize your assessment of the paper: YES MAYBE NO Does the paper contain enough significant new physics to warrant publication in the Physical Review? (X) ( ) ( )

Is the paper scientifically sound and not misleading? (X) ( ) ( )

Is the paper well organized and clearly written? ( ) (X) ( )

Are the subject matter and style of presentation appropriate for the Physical Review? (X) ( ) ( )

Is the length appropriate? (X) ( ) ( )

2. Please evaluate quality of Research and Presentation:
…show more content…
Recommendation: ( ) Publish without change (please give reasons in report). ( ) Publish after authors have considered the optional revisions mentioned in the report. ( ) Publish after authors have made the revisions mentioned in the report. (I do not need to see the manuscript again.) (X) Revisions are necessary. Return to me on resubmittal. ( ) Revisions are necessary. On resubmittal, send to: (Use as much space as needed to list names of alternative reviewers.) ( ) Manuscript is more appropriate for another ( ) journal (specify): or ( ) section (specify): ( ) Do not publish; see report. ( ) Other; see report.
************************************************************************ REFEREE REPORT: MANUSCRIPT # AU11474
PAPER
…show more content…
Rev. A 88, 032317 (“Steady-state entanglement of two superconducting qubits engineered by dissipation“).
(4) Please specify the superscript “m” mentioned on the 7-8th line in section II.
(5) In the context of local feedback scheme (as mentioned just before Eq. 16), is there any condition on the photon detection also? If there are more than one photo-detection clicks required for this scheme then is your method takes into account the time-delay between the recording of more than one clicks (jumps)?
(6) Please comment further on the significance and experimental feasibility of M-type configuration of trapped atoms (as sketched in Fig. 1(b)). Meaning, what are the possible benefits of starting from M-type atomic configuration in your work? Why not to choose a “V” type configuration of the trapped atom/ion right from the start?
TYPOS and GRAMMETICAL SUGGESTIONS
(1) On page 1, the second paragraph the authors wrote: “Cabello for practical use reasons introduced the N-particle N-level singlet state |S_N>”. It will better if the authors re-state this sentence for instance: “For practical applications, “Cabello introduced the N-particle N-level singlet state

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Isotope Lab Report Essay

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Using the equation; Average atomic mass= (Natural abundance as a decimal)(Sum of the masses if its isotope) We are able to calculate the atomic mass of isotopics. This report presents the procedures for the beanium experiment, the experiments results, and analysis of these results to visualize and understand isotopes. Purpose The purpose of this experiment is to gain a greater and…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Gating Pulse Synthesis

    • 1722 Words
    • 7 Pages

    4A and the coupling electron energy outline spectrum at τ_OAP=0 fs is shown in Fig. 4B. The ZLP has been subtracted from both the spectrogram and the outline spectrum for better visualization of the coupling peaks. The gating time window emulates the attosecond optical gating pulse which permits the generation of subfemtosecond electron pulse. The ratio of the number of attosecond-gated electrons respect to the total number of electrons of the original electron pulse represent the attosecond optical gating efficiency which depends on the original electron pulse duration.…

    • 1722 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Ligand Field Theory (LFT): LFT is a more comprehensive and sophisticated theory is now evolved from the combination of CFT and MOT. Cotton defined LFT as the theory of the origin and the consequence of the splitting of the inner orbitals of transition metal ions and their chemical environment. The CFT assumes that the orbitals of the ligand atom do not overlap with the orbitals of the central metal ion under consideration. However, sufficient experimental evidence shows that there always some overlapping between ligand and metal orbitals. It has been proved that the metal complexes have some degree of covalency in them as against what was thought by the CFT modelists.…

    • 1014 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His new model better described the structural components of the atom than Dalton’s featureless atom. Thompson used a Cathode Ray Tube, which was a sealed glass container, and shot a stream of electrons across the glass tube. When the particles stuck to the other end of the tube, it created a patch of light that indicated where the particles landed. Thompson discovered that by using a magnetic field, he could move and deflect particles. He found that particles would always move towards the positively charged side.…

    • 1041 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    1b) is exploited to generate sub-femtosecond electron pulses (Fig. 2a). This technique is based on photon-electron coupling on a nanostructure3. This leads to the gain or loss of photon quanta via electron packets, when the electrons and the photons are temporally overlapping on the nanostructure surface. That can be resolved in the electron energy spectrum as discrete peaks on the higher and lower energy sides of the zero loss peak (ZLP) separated by multiples of photon energy (nћω) (Fig.…

    • 1768 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The electron that gain or loss energy due to the coupling only exists in the presence of the optical laser pulse. In another word, the optical laser pulse acts as a temporal gating of these electrons and the time window of this gating is the optical pulse duration. These gated electrons can be filtered out providing a magnificent enhancement of the temporal resolution in electron microscopy. Another optical laser pulse can be utilized to trigger the ultrafast dynamics of matter which can be envisaged by gated-electrons in different modes i.e. diffraction, electron…

    • 1738 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This problem is important because when new elements and compounds are discovered, scientists can figure out their characteristics They do this using KMT (Kinetic Molecular Theory). KMT states that in the substance as a gas behaves like hard, spherical objects that are always in constant motion with no attraction. The stated information is the staple of multiple gaseous theories. Some examples are frequency of the collisions, the distance between the particles in the container and the gas’s volume, and the temperature of said gas. The behavior of these particles affects their properties.…

    • 1765 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Those two properties need aid proportional in that they need aid continuously both exhibit in the same extent should each other. Mass-activity standard might provide for us majority of the data around those vitality At it can’t illustrate how those responses transform. In this way this demonstration goes starting with atomic force. To uncover atomic vitality Likewise be compelled What 's more will change over it on Different sorts about vitality atomic reactors would utilized. That is the reason atomic force plants are set up.…

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Small: The Atomic Theory

    • 2086 Words
    • 9 Pages

    No matter what gas sample was tested in the tube, the negative particles always had the same characteristics. The positive ions behavior would change depending on the sample of gas in the apparatus. This demonstrated that atoms contain smaller particles with positive and negative charges. JJ Thomson (1856-1940), taking and perfecting this knowledge with his experiment, is recognized with calculating the ratio of electron charge to mass and the first model of atomic structure to account for the positive and negative sub-particles. Thomson measured the amount of magnetic force needed to exactly counterbalance the deflection of a strong beam of electrons projected between charged plates.…

    • 2086 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Brilliant Essays

    "Local determination of the constitutive law of a dense suspension of noncolloidal particles through magnetic resonance imaging." Journal of Rheology (1978-present) 50.3 (2006): 259-292. Bricker, Jonathan Mark. Rheology of noncolloidal suspensions of spheres in oscillatory shear flow and the dynamics of suspensions of rigid fibers. Diss.…

    • 1910 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Brilliant Essays