Hard Determinism Analysis

Better Essays
Victor Odili
Philosophy 1301
Jeff Glick
October 16, 2016
Compatibilism and Hard Determinism In his work, Holbach explains Hard Determinism as a theory where humans do not have a legitimate free will. Hard Determinism conveys the idea that we are fully determined, we do not have free will, and that no one is morally responsible for their actions. As stated by Hard Determinism, the activities of man are never free, but the received ideas which are planned to make others fulfill their desires ("Notes on Determinism and Indeterminism," n.d.). For a man to be free, he should not encounter any restrictions or obstacles. According to Holbach Men are not free agents in any one instant of their life; they are necessarily guided at every step
…show more content…
Every event that occurs has a cause and progression that is predetermined and, therefore, becomes part of the natural law (Hoefer). Based on Hard Determinism, Man’s life conforms to natural commands upon the surface of the earth without any opportunity of ever being able to swerve from it even for an instant. Therefore, man’s life is controlled by a set of rules and obligations on earth that make it impossible to turn away from it and to become free …show more content…
Another difference is that compatibilists think that people are morally responsible for their actions as so with libertarians. Hard determinists believe that people are not morally responsible for their actions and that perspective is not morally right. The similarity between compatibilists and hard determinists is that they are determined in agreement with free will with some reservation for Compatibilism. Works cited
"Hobbes and Republican Liberty.” Notre Dame. N.p., n.d. Web. 16 Oct. 2016 .
“Notes on Determinism and Indeterminism.” N.p. N.d. Web. October 16, 2016. Available at
Hoefer Carl. “Causal Determinism.” The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Web. October 16, 2016. Available at
Holbach Paul. “Hard determinism: The case for determinism and its incompatibility with any important sense of free will.” Pdf.
McKenna Michael & Coates Justin, D. “Compatibilism.” 2015. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Web. October 16, 2016. Available at

Related Documents