Herbert Hoover's On The New Deal And Liberty: Analysis

Improved Essays
In 1936, Herbert Hoover wrote an article called “On the New Deal and Liberty” that focused on the critiques of Franklin D. Roosevelt’s solution to the economic climate. Some of the things that Hoover accuses Roosevelt of doing is jeopardizing “fundamental American liberties”, functioning out of utter opportunism, with no clear purpose of strategy, or was collaborating to enforce “European ideas” on the United States. Hoover and Roosevelt almost have the complete opposite views on what should happen during the United States economic crisis. Hoover believing that we the government should take a step back, Roosevelt believes that the government must intervene. Roosevelt also stresses that taxation is needed for the economic crisis to be fixed, …show more content…
If we constantly decrease costs and prices and keep earnings the production of plenty will be more and more widely distributed..The depression produced by war destruction temporally checked our march toward the promised land” (Foner, 176). What Hoover is saying hear is that The New Deal does not take into consideration that if we do not do these things then we will suffer. War is the reason our economy is in ruins and we must do everything we can to get us out of it. This is huge because the way that Roosevelt looks at it is we must have the people pay taxes. Roosevelt believe that we must take these three steps: Relief, Recovery, and Reform. Relief, meaning that the government must provide federal payments for those who are unemployed, so that they have food and shelter. Recovery, is having programs designed to put citizens to work, such as the WPA (Works Progress Association) that would offer jobs to the unemployed in hope of the more people making money, the more money that would soon go back to the economy. And finally, reform, this is the few things that were set up to make our economy increase, like Wall Street, Social Security, and the FDIC that would make sure that the American people would get their money from the banks even if the banks went bankrupt. This is problematic in Hoover’s eyes …show more content…
Roosevelt thought that taxation on Americans was perfectly fine because the government needed that money to pay back its debts from war. Without taxation the government would barely get money. Hoover says, “Freedom to work for himself is changed into a slavery of work for the follies of government” (Foner, 176). This means that he believes that citizens should not have to pay taxes because if you work hard for your money, you should be able to keep it. This is important because this is a huge difference between the two with the interference of the government. Roosevelt believes that the government must intervene in this economic crisis because if they do not, then it will continue to go down. On the other hand, Hoover believes that the government is the problem. The government is the ones causing all the issues for the American people and if they were to be out of it, then it would run more smoothly. This all goes back to President Ronald Reagan, who had his own strong

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The sixteenth amendment is one of the most controversial statements that has aroused the American people with its ability to grant the government to control your financial state and also disable you to do certain things when they need money to use for no good reason. Do you want your money in someone else 's hands? Or do you want your own money to be able to control? The money that is given to the government through taxes is supposed to be used to support foreign affairs and have the federal government assemble a decent society to be prosperous. The government is more destroying the society rather than building it up.…

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    High taxes push companies to move abroad and make business elsewhere. This results in the loss of jobs and other financial investments. In reducing taxes Republicans believe that the economy will grow and prosper. In a Republicans stand point, those who have worked hard and succeed in investing shouldn’t be punished. Democrats, contrastively “believe the wealthiest Americans and largest corporations must pay their fair share of taxes.” Democrats are against those companies who walk out on America and don’t pay taxes, they believe that everyone should pay their fair share instead of hiding business abroad.…

    • 1221 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Conservative Movement

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Conservative Movement arose to answer three major concerns. The first concern of the Conservative Movement was to repeal New Deal programs. Over the years this transformed into more of a fight against “big government” and New Deal programs were the central pillar of “big government”. The next goal of the Conservative movement dealt with the destruction of Communism and creating a foreign policy that exemplified this desire. According to the Conservative Movement, Communism was seen as a threat to America and the rest of world, and conservatives saw liberal foreign policy on Communism as weak and wanted to change US’s foreign policy to be more aggressive.…

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The main difference between Hoover and Roosevelt’s method was that Roosevelt used federal funds and federal authority to design multiple of programs that would make the economy better, and would end the great depression. In the first 100 days of getting into office he sent many bills to congress, to cause an immediate fix on the situation. Roosevelt gave jobs to those that were unemployed, brought back the economy back to normal, and also created long term programs that improved the economy gradually. On the other hand, Hoover did not really take advantage of federal power; instead he encouraged volunteerism. He wanted citizens to help fix the economy.…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    However Roosevelt did disagree with the free market people, he believed that there needed to be more intervention on the state level. Roosevelt was a man who believed that the government could make reasonable decisions because he was the one who said “reason over passion”, by this I believe that he means that he thinks that the government can make decisions for the public whereas from a capitalistic point of view they think the economy should run itself without the help of the government. Roosevelt thinks that the government can make the biggest impact on the economy. Roosevelt during the Great Depression provided jobs to the country by making jobs by building bridges, dams, highways, and schools, this is an act of reason over passion because Roosevelt uses reason to create jobs for the people of…

    • 1524 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Woodrow Wilson faces problems of the United States Wilson thought that the government was having privacy problems, that there was too much government involved in big businesses, that the tariff was too high and was causing Americans to lose money, and that the United States was stuck in a cycle when it came to government. To fix these problems he wanted to bring the government back to the people of the United States, he wanted to bring back competition to solve government involvement and the tariffs, and he wanted people to stand up for themselves and vote for who they actually want in the elections. Wilson had many other problems and solutions in his book but theses were some of the main ones that stuck out to me. During Woodrow Wilson’s…

    • 1770 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Great Depression Dbq

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The policies of Hoover, who double income tax, and Roosevelt, who initiated the New Deal, crippled the free market’s ability to recover. Chesterton especially rails against the policies of Roosevelt, who slashed the value of the dollar by half, doubled the debt and raised unemployment. Using this debt, Roosevelt paid workers through the Civil Works Administration and the Works Progress Administration to do “silly things”, keeping capital and labor away from industry, where it was no badly needed. Eventually, the Supreme Court overturned his laws and opened up the United States for international trade during the economically critical period of World War II. In Chesterton’s opinion, it is the decrease in regulation and government policy that finally allows the economy to recover in the…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hoover did all he thought would help fix the troubling times. Congress tried to pass bills to help the suffering people, but hoover was stubborn and rejected these because he stated, “Prosperity cannot be restored by raids upon the public Treasury.” (History.com Staff). Hoovers idea was to create jobs and let america pull itself back together, instead of the government intervening so much that it would look like capitalism. Hoover claimed that the causes of the Great Depression were out of his control (Biology.com Editors). Franklin Roosevelt came in after Hoover and took over in the presidency.…

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They were William Howard Taft, Theodore Roosevelt, Eugene Debs, and Woodrow Wilson. The election turned out to be a competition between Wilson’s and Roosevelt’s views. Wilson thought the danger was in increasing economic concentration, and Roosevelt saw the danger in increasing government power. Wilson created a program called “New Freedom.” This was supposed to make democracy better by restoring market competition and stopping big businesses from controlling the government. Roosevelt responded to “New Freedom” with a program called “New Nationalism.” This program pointed out the unavoidably of big business and hoped to use the government to stop its corruptions.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, states like Virginia were not happy with Hamilton’s idea because they had already paid off their debts and saw no reason why they should be taxed by the federal government to pay off the debts of other states. This plan made people skeptic because they thought it would leave speculators who had bought bonds for as little as 10 or 15 cents on the dollar with enormous profits in the ends. Hamilton’s last objective introduced in his plan was to create a national bank of the United States, which was modeled after the Bank of England. A national bank would collect taxes, hold government funds, and make loans to borrowers and the government. It would act as the government’s fiscal agent and provide a sound paper money supply.…

    • 539 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays