Compare And Contrast Herbert Hoover And The Great Depression

Improved Essays
The Foes of the Great Depression Imagine a family that barely has a sufficient amount of food or water to live on. Imagine this family’s parent attempting to get a job to make money, but they cannot. Now, imagine this situation happening to millions of families across America. The very thought is devastating. However, two leaders rose up to try to fix this problem. Herbert Hoover and Franklin D. Roosevelt used different economic and domestic policies during their presidency to reach a common goal: conclude the Great Depression. Herbert Hoover came in as president with many ideas in mind to change the economic state the country was in. Herbert Hoover was the 31st President of the United States and served from 1929-1933.(4) Hoover entered …show more content…
FDR and Herbert had very few similarities. They both had a plan to take on the Great Depression and other reforms to save America, but their approaches are what set them apart. Hoover was for American individualism, and counted abundantly on the citizens to help one another to get through the Great Depression. He took an approach that was considered weak for most and had a lot of faith in the people. Hoover went to encourage businesses and organizations to change for the benefit for the citizens. He failed to be a strong leader and his faith in American individualism prevented him from seeking government help even when it was absolutely necessary. Herbert wrote about the dangers of investing too much power in the federal government. He did not bring the Great Depression to a conclusion, but he did have a few domestic achievements. FDR took the approach that Herbert wrote about that was dangerous. Roosevelt followed a fiscal policy and was more aggressive in solving national problems. His economic reforms dramatically lowered unemployment rates and gave momentum to the citizens that would lift the United States from the Great Depression by the beginning of the second World War. Both presidents had a positive effect on the country. Herbert’s faith in the people and belief in American individualism helped shape the way our government runs currently. FDR, however, had more of a rapid positive effect that the citizens experienced. Herbert’s took many years before historians even realized the benefits of his presidency. The 31st and 32nd presidents of our country were two different people, with one common

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    He wanted citizens to help fix the economy. He assumed that too much interference by the federal government would terminate individuality and self-sufficiency among the citizens. The actions that Hoover took did not have a positive effect towards the economy; his plan did not work as premeditated. Both President Herbert Hoover and president Franklin D. Roosevelt wanted to take the United States out of the depression and make the country prosper in all aspects. They chose different ways of doing so.…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Foes of the Great Depression Imagine a family that barely has a sufficient amount of food or water to live on. Imagine this family’s parent attempting to get a job to make money, but they cannot. Now, imagine this situation happening to millions of families across America. The very thought is devastating. However, two leaders rose up to try to fix this problem.…

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The U.S government should have the power, like FDR, to intervene and stabilize the American Economy during the crisis. Next, the well being of the American economy should be a priority of the American government. FDR had a try anything approach which was better than Hoover’s. In addition, FDR actually tried and attempted anything that was beneficial to the economy. Lastly, FDR did the best he could when the economy was at its lowest and created many programs that benefited workers.…

    • 1229 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Because Wilson refused to tolerate monopolies, he did not advocate for the same level “healthy competition” that Roosevelt had advocated for. Instead, Wilson called for more equality…[as he believed] there must be no squeezing out of the beginner, no crippling his credit” (Wilson). In his proposed program New Freedom, Wilson called for a meritocracy; believing in the small entrepreneur, Wilson encouraged Americans to come up with “invention[s] which would improve the kind of machinery” being used (Wilson). A successful entrepreneur that created good for American society was described as having American “brains” (Wilson). Wilson used Andrew Carnegie as an example of American “brains;” while most leaders of big…

    • 1060 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    For example, Kennedy’s personality did not aid in congress’ belief in his reform programs because they did not pass, but it did help with the nation’s perceptions of him because of how genuine he was. President Johnson, on the other hand, used his hard edge to…

    • 1241 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Not being able to buy new clothes or live in a house where everyone doesn 't share a bedroom. This is what tore families apart. Without money, no one can do anything fathers felt they could not support their families and would leave sometimes so now the mom was stuck taking care of the children alone and looking for a job. The crash made Americans realized how quickly their lives could change, and how much wall street affected the economy making Americans learn a…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One president Hoover was regarded as a “do-nothing president.” He insisted no one was starving; however Hoover was in denial. Some small poor towns were called Hooverville because they showed how he did nothing to help the poor. Also Hoover did not believe in government handouts, so nothing he did to help the poor. Once the public seen that Hoover didn’t have the political knowledge they thought he had, they began making signs of families in ditches and making jokes about the poverty that he was doing nothing to help solve. Unlike Hoover who ignored the growing poverty, Roosevelt created The New Deal.…

    • 465 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The SSA is one of the “New Deal” programs. This program is to provide money to the following people: old age, survivors, disability, and intervention (OASDI). This shows the government becoming more powerful because it shows how the government made a program that automatically taxes income to support those who need it. In conclusion, FDR’s “New Deal” did have an effect on society both then and now. Even though all of the solutions/programs may not have been effective they still helped to make a difference in society during the Great Depression.…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Government should always support it no matter what. At the beginning of the Great Depression the Government didn’t really intervene. Maybe it was because Herbert Hoover was in office or maybe it was because they had no idea what to do. Slowly they started to see the effect that the Great Depression was causing to America and decided to step in. Hoover did try to improve America but he didn’t try as hard Roosevelt.…

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the film Jimmy and his wife couldn’t afford much.Lastly they showed food troubles. In the film Jimmy's wife had to ration the food out. It also showed job struggles. In the film it was hard for Jimmy to get/keep a job. As u can see this film did a good job of representing the plight of the average American during the Great…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays