Guatemala Rhetorical Analysis

Superior Essays
On October 13th, McMaster had the honour of hosting Dr Catherine Nolin’s presentation on Transnational Ruptures in a Time of Impunity. Dr. Nolin is an associate professor and chair at the University of Northern British Columbia. She is also a social geographer with two broad areas or research interest: migration studies and justice in Guatemala. Nolin has received various prestigious awards, most recent one being the 2007 UNBC Excellence in Teaching Award Recipient. She organized a trip to Guatemala with graduate students to document the violent development of Canadian mining in Guatemala.
Dr. Nolin explained the conflict Guatemala has dealt with before sharing her journey. Guatemala is recovering from thirty-six years of internal conflict
…show more content…
Canadian owned mining companies hired corrupted security to protect their work in Guatemala. Dr. Nolin documented the Canadian mining case with graduate students and journalist James Rodriguez. The sad reality is that without the help of Dr. Nolin and her team, the violent happenings surrounding Canadian mining would not be known to Canadians. The most affected by Canadian mining are the indigenous communities in Guatemala. Dr. Nolin was asked by the Lote 8 community to listen to their version of what happened when Canadian industries began mining in Guatemala. Their community was evicted by the Canadian hired mining security and whoever refused was tear gassed. The families’ home were dismantled and their lives destroyed. The indigenous men feared for their lives and escaped, leaving their wives and children behind. The men believed the security would not touch women and children, but unfortunately they were wrong. Many children and women suffered under the Canadian hired security. Indigenous women were raped and attacked by the military several times. The women endured the agony of being abused in order to save their …show more content…
Nolin and her team to be part of the fire ceremony. At the ceremony, the community asked Nolin and her students to take their experience and share it with Canadians. Dr. Nolin was determined to work with James Rodriguez to take her knowledge of the violence the Canadian mining industry has caused in Guatemala. As Nolin and the students were leaving the community, they passed a sign that read “Development is the New Name for Peace”.
Dr. Nolin and the graduate students traveled back to the mountains of Lote Ocho and asked for true Canadian connection in the attacks. They asked the women who was raped and abused by a private security of Canadian company. Without hesitation, the women raised their hands and stood by their testimony. Knowing this may have consequences, the women who raised their hand agreed to give their names and take a picture to provide evidence for trials. The indigenous women have traveled to Toronto to speak in trials. Several documents must be completed before a verdict can be

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    “Tarmageddon”, an essay authored by Andrew Nikiforuk, demonstrates how the tar sands have negatively impacted Canada both economically and environmentally. The environmental factors are elaborated by explaining Canada’s contribution to green house emissions and acid rain when they were once a global leader against such pollutions. Nikiforuk compares Canada as being second worst for climate change next to Saudi Arabia since they started using bitumen. He highlights the politics surrounding the issues and includes the impact of the tar sands on public policy by stating that Canada no longer has a policy on climate change and have abandoned their targets. He goes on to include Prime Minister Stephen Harpers contribution to the corruption that branch out from the province of Alberta and his personal connection as “the son of an imperial oil executive” (AR.189).…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Department of State official, this article is very much unbiased, as it is a report from an outside source from Guatemala. The account describes how the kidnappings in the country were mostly carried out by Guatemala’s government in order to interrogate the victims, mostly male Indians, about their actions and kill them later. However, the U.S. State Department had admitted in the statement that they did not have very accurate data on Guatemala’s human rights conditions. The information gathered may not be credible; nevertheless, an outside viewpoint of the situations in Guatemala is still helpful with its unprejudiced…

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This paper will review “A Right to Treaty Education by Sheila Carr- Stewart as well as looking at a short article simply entitled “Schools” which was written by the Treaty Seven Elders . Both readings were published within five years of each other (The Treaty Seven Elders in 1996 and Carr-Stewarts’s article in 2001). Although both readings are about the educational systems the government of Canada provided for the indigenous people, one article (A Treaty Right to Education) focuses on the historical documents surrounding the issue of foral education provided by the Europeans. The other article (“Schools”) has a strong focus on the people who survived these schools.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Hector Tobar wrote a book about the predicaments that befell the Chile miners. The author provides a detailed narrative of thirty-three miners who were working in a mine that later trapped them in August 2010 (Tobar, 2015). The miners who were buried underground miraculously survived the horrific ordeal, of starvation, dehydration, and horrible living condition (Tobar, 2015). The content of the book reflects the challenges that face the nursing profession and patient care in healthcare setting. Furthermore, Tobar, the author uncovers the working condition and environment that the miners were subjected to before the mine collapse.…

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thousands and thousands of women are seeking asylum in the United States, not because of war or discrimination, but they are seeking protection from a more personal danger: abuse from their husbands, boyfriends and male relatives. One woman recounted being raped, strangled and thrown against a wall by her husband, father of her twin boys. Two teenage girls discussed about being forced to become sex slaves for gang members. If the women do report the abuse to the police, they risk their homes being destroyed by gang members. “In my country, nobody pays attention to what women suffer,” Juliza, a victim of being sexual abuse by her husband said in a telephone interview with Pamela Constable who covers immigration issues and communities for the Washington Post .…

    • 634 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This essay discusses the aboriginal protest against tar sand projects in Canada based on two academic journals written by McCreary and Blomley respectively. In this paper, I will focus on the Enbridge Northern Gateway Project in Canada, which is mentioned and analyzed in both journals. Enbridge is a Calgary-based energy transport company that has proposed the project. The Northern Gateway Project is a pipeline that connect Alberta and Pacific coast of British Columbia in order to transport bitumen extracted from the Alberta…

    • 82 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    City Of Thorns Case Study

    • 2124 Words
    • 9 Pages

    In the book, City of Thorns: nine lives in the world’s largest refugee camp, by Ben Rawlance, the stories of the lives of nine refugees present the struggles and frustrations of the tangled lives in a refugee camp with on-going conflict. There is a lot of different issues occurring throughout their experiences in the camps, some very horrific and life threatening to these individuals. Although the book focus more on the men in the camps, the experiences the women goes through demonstrate that there is a global health issue with maternal and child health care services. These experiences are shaped by the situation of being a refugee and living in a conflict zone and they outline the type of intervention they find most important and appealing.…

    • 2124 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mexico is infamous for its vast mining system. With almost 10 billion ounces of silver mined, Mexico is one of the largest exporters of silver. ( Brown 1). Some of the earliest activity dating back as far as the sixteenth century. To date there over 200 mining companies who have projects in mexico.…

    • 946 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Secret Path Summary

    • 72 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Mr. Wilson had us watch “The Secret Path” and three articles about learning first nations perspective. And all three articles are dealing with a similar topic that first nation people have been treated unfairly related to one person -- Charlie Wenjack. While the video provides both positive, all the loving sense between Charlie and his family, and the negative, by showing the residential school and moreover, after he runs away, his death.…

    • 72 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Athabasca Sands

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Athabasca oil sands, more commonly known as the Alberta tar sands, are large deposits of heavy crude oil in the North Easterly reaches of Alberta. According to Alberta Energy, the oil sands are the third largest crude oil reserves in the world. Only two countries, Saudi Arabia and Venezuela, possess reserves greater than Canada (Alberta Energy, 2012). Arguably, the capital gained from exporting Athabasca bitumen or crude oil (a form of petroleum) promotes job and economic growth, and also contributes royalties toward Albertan education and healthcare. On the other hand, the growing reliance on the Athabasca oil sands makes the Canadian economy incredibly susceptible to collapses in global oil prices.…

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Native Americans have faced multiple issues from political, emotional, and even physical (Pember, 2016). These are just some of which popular media does not show (Pember, 2016). One of the issues that people do not know about that occurs mainly in reservations, and amongst Native American women and children is, sex trafficking (Pember, 2016). Sex trafficking, is the recruitment of individuals to be bought or given out for sex (Pember, 2016). Although, sex trafficking occurs amongst all races, statistics show that a total of ninety percent of individuals who have been recruited, are individuals that are of Native American descent (Pember, 2016).…

    • 1380 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Chixoy Dam Guatemala

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The World Bank funded the building of the Chixoy Dam in Guatemala, a project whose adverse effects are still being felt to-date. This dam was meant to develop a reliable source of energy but instead turned out to be a burden to Guatemala and its people. Most of the methods used to force people out of their native lands during the dam’s construction were brutal and in complete violation of human rights. Intimidation campaigns and the military were used to silence resistance. Over 400 men, women and children were killed either individually or in masses as they resisted the relocation to resettlement villages.…

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    British Empire Contradiction

    • 3001 Words
    • 13 Pages

    History Ideas To look at the british empire as a contradiction because it restricted choices, but also created opportunities for many people across the world is a viewpoint of a binary nature, one could critically evaluate the merit of this argument, The british empire became the process of enabling narratives to branch out from their brackets. For strange, unusual and unlikely things to occur to people. Specifically those that were colonised, to be more than the oppressed to inform their lives through much more than just reaction. They became these individuals of great significance for the way that they changed society. a change necessary enabling people to resist and live in a society dominated by these authorities still intact in our…

    • 3001 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Multidisciplinary Approach

    • 1424 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The basic human rights awarded to all human individuals in this world include, first and foremost, the right to equality and the right to life. Yet, these rights have been violated for centuries, escalating in the twentieth century “an era characterized by a phenomenal increase in the frequency and intensity of human rights violations…” (Ferllini 2008, 7). This period essentially caused the establishment of legal parameters, through the intervention of international law, in order to prosecute those who committed such crimes. Anthropologists and archaeologists joined the fold in the 1980s when investigations of abuses were conducted in Latin America, a place where violations occur almost continuously (Ferllini 2008, 7).…

    • 1424 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a book told in the fiction context, King Coal by Upton Sinclair describes the gruesome, harsh reality of working in the coal industry in the 1910 from mining issues such as the hopes of getting a job in the industry of coal in the western states of the United States, the harsh mining conditions, and miners being taken advantage of by their bosses. The book discusses two mining in general locations where all the stories are told by Sinclair himself: Rocky Mountain and Pedro (6). The author 's purpose in writing the book is to expose the truths of the mining industry in terms of a narrative to engage and capture the audience 's attention and emotions to truly fathom the time back then and what it means to survive by the means of living on the edge of nothing.…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays