Examples Of Intuition Driven Romanticism And The Raven Paradox

Superior Essays
Matthew McGee
Epistemology
Final Paper

Q1 Goodman 's “grue” example and Hempel’s Raven Paradox are very similar. The Raven Paradox posits that for any given object x, when we assert that it is neither black, nor a raven, we are confirming the hypothesis that “all non-black things are non-ravens” (pg, 70). From this we can also make the logically equivalent statement that “all ravens are black.” This is an unexpected conclusion according to Goodman. Furthermore, our statement about the given object x logically entails that anything that is not black is not a raven, and anything that is not a raven is not black. A logical fallacy that would seem to follow from this statement is that "all black objects are ravens. Obviously we can reject
…show more content…
In other words, intuition driven romanticism relies in part on intuitive human feelings as evidence that produces explicit or implicit normative claims. The authors see intuition driven romanticism as one version in a tradition of romanticism in epistemology, which they hope to …show more content…
Their consensus is that IDR fails the “normative test.” As they point out, different groups of people, i.e. different cultures, or even similar cultures across long periods of human history, will invariably possess differing intuitions. Therefore, when these intuitive inputs are filtered through an IDR “black box” they will produce valuative and regulative norms, some of which may be might even be antithetical to our own. All of which is another way of stating that human beings are different from one another, across the planet and across time, and that if they base their norms and values on intuition or similar romantic based foundations, they may very well arrive at a system of beliefs not just different from our own, but one that we might find abhorrent. The authors thus conclude that intuition driven romanticism is not a sound basis for empirical

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    “Separate but equal” is only equal for those in power, the beneficiaries of such acts, it cannot and will not uphold the Thirteenth, or Fourteenth Amendment. The equal protection clause established by the Fourteenth Amendment, becomes a continuation of the Thirteenth Amendment, in that it establishes and expands the rights of Blacks. Yet, in denying that segregation violates both the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Amendment, in that we willfully withhold the full protection of the rights guaranteed by the most fundamental document to American ideals of basic…

    • 1238 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Being able to receive objects through sensible intuition is what allows us to understand them. In the ‘Transcendental Aesthetic,’ Kant discusses how, in terms of sensibility, our minds are passive and receptive. Space and time are pure forms of intuition that enable people to be receptive. These forms of intuition are what make it possible to have synthetic a priori propositions (A39/B56). This is important to the entire book because Kant wants to show that synthetic a priori…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This statement is offensive; his entire article is actually very offensive. Kamiya points out that a difference between black and ‘black ' exist, when there is no difference. Kamiya should have said what he meant; which is that there is a difference between ‘proper blacks ' and ‘ghetto/ethnic blacks '. Sadly, the truth is that it does not matter if a black person is proper or considered ethnic, both types will have to deal with the same types of racism. One of the main reasons that racism…

    • 1372 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Essay On Black Privilege

    • 1800 Words
    • 8 Pages

    To be sure, black privilege in the context thus referred is a black person’s ability to adopt a consciousness or awareness entirely disparate of that of a white person’s in its formation. Black privilege is a schema of epistemology that is made almost exclusive to black people– and to add, alongside other marginalized people of color. For example, in Sherman Alexie’s…

    • 1800 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I think that the answer should be yes and no. Why would I say that? I would say yes because, people who have disparate types of life have contrasting experiences with racism. I would also say no because, no matter what racism will be racism. It all depends on how people treat people with racial diversity.…

    • 699 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Areas of forgiveness can also involve self-forgiveness and group forgiveness (Hirschorn, 2009, Peterson & Seligman, 2004). Hope Hope can also be feelings of optimism, future orientation and future mindedness. This is a representation emotional, cognitive and motivational standing towards the future. Hope involves putting expectations on the best outcome and putting in the work for that very purpose. Belief in such good outcomes is important in having hope.…

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In this essay we will be focusing on Roger’s views of Humanistic psychology and theory of personality. Roger’s theory of personality is a holistic and phenomenological approach to the description of individualism, Carl Rogers, humanistic psychologist and psychotherapist, where his approach can be defined as “A psychological model that emphasizes an individual's phenomenal world and inherent capacity for making rational choices and developing to maximum potential” (Gerrig, Richard J. & Phillip G. Zimbardo., 2002). Phenomenology was an important aspect of his approach where it refuted purely objective measures that were seen as less introspective in choice of a more subjective value, which allowed for deep introspection and rich information from an individual (Orbe, 2009).…

    • 2130 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cultural relativism may be defined as a theory that advocates the idea of subjective morality. To extrapolate, this theory entails that “different cultures have differing moral codes” and these variances are merely arbitrary. Although this is a seemingly sufficient theory, there are key issues with this school of thought. James Rachels suggests several issues with accepting cultural relativism. He criticizes cultural relativism by stating that the theory is absurd as it entails severe consequences if practiced.…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Narrative Post Racism

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Thusly, I do agree with Anderson’s conclusion that post racialism, for the most part, would leave racism in-tact. One could even say that this is already happening—and not just with race. In the same way that misunderstandings about disability make disabled individuals invisible (as mentioned in N. Ann Davis’ article, “Invisible Disability”), which leads to more ableist assumptions by society, or misunderstandings about the woman’s experience allows for uncorrected sexism, these methods, seemingly born out of a misunderstanding of the function of race, would make the racially marginalized invisible and allow…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    ~ (M0  R0) = 1,  ~G1 = 0. Thus, the argument for Queerness as he posits is logically valid, as no possible cases have premises that are all true and the conclusion false. So, building from this logically valid argument, one can evaluate the individual kinds of queerness, which is divided into two main categories; first the metaphysical (motivation and reason) and second the epistemological. For this paper, one will evaluate the motivational queerness, “moral judgement requires that we motivated to act in accordance” . The link between moral judgment and motivation is one in which moral judgement requires the facts to produce the motivation required to act and classify something was wrong.…

    • 981 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays