Essay Comparing Cyrano And Christian Lie To Roxane

Improved Essays
With their graves dug and tears shed, we as a reader have a question at hand. Something to ponder is whether our handsome heroine Christian or valiant victor Cyrano is more exceptional . After deep consideration neither is worthy of being held in higher esteem than the other. In the story both heroes show a failure in being honest, confident, and beautiful. The heroes have failed in showing these three main traits they require to prove themselves worthy.
Now first and foremost, both heroes time after time show us just how much they lack these qualities, but their honesty is what is being criticized as of now. Cyrano and Christian lie to Roxane throughout the play about each of their abilities to love when they agree to work together as one person to win the heart of our lead female.”If only I had a handsome face”(Rostand 101), This is the line that initiates Christian and Cyrano’s agreement. “If only I could express myself gracefully” (Rostand 101), this line is Christians half of his reason as to why he decides to lie to Roxane, because he feels like he incapable of carrying himself as a gentleman. These men may have reasons as to why
…show more content…
“I’ll give her my letter If I feel there’s the slightest hope” (Rostand 72). Cyrano had planned to give Roxanne a love letter in his name but was foiled when she confessed her love for Christian. Furthermore Christians words of “ No! no! I say. I am aweary of these borrowed letters, -Borrowed love-makings! Thus to act a part, And tremble all the time!- ‘Twas well enough At the beginning!- Now I know she loves! I fear no longer- I will speak myself.” (Rostand 118) show that he was finally ready to man up and express his love unassisted. Both Christian and Cyrano are clearly both heros who fought and died for what they loved but, romantically they were buffoons whose romantic endeavors were and always will be in

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    He aims in his commentary to make Cyrano’s morality a joke, and with that he reveals his patronizing nature, as if he is above such petty things as morals. In the use of the “three musketeers and Don Christ Quixote”, characters in literature who are renowned for their righteousness and morality, he brings Cyrano’s stance on fame and success to the level of those characters- admirable, but ultimately ridiculed and fictional. It is clear that he does not care much for the- to him, fanciful- beliefs of his companion and is considerably exasperated by the reluctance of his acquaintance to prosper. Le Bret is condescending and conceited in the extreme, in supposing that his ideals of prosperity are any better than Cyrano’s vision of a life free from the “dirty road to advancement”. He notes that Cyrano has great potential, telling him that he’d “wing up to the top”, but is unaware of the thing that he values the most in his art-…

    • 454 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A man transcends those things that compose him, greater than the sum of his parts; but, suppose a man builds himself off of a foundation of lies, to himself and to others. Mr. Duffy of “A Painful Case” and Gabriel of “The Dead” serve as chief examples of this deception by living lives designed to impress upon others a view of a certain kind of man: one versed in matters of the mind and of society. They both engage with women betrothed, by oath or soul, to others, they dislike Dublin and her people, and they both find that they simply aren’t the men whom they believed themselves to be. A man may think himself the archangel, when he merely fails to see that he forgot to get out of character; so it is, also, with those seeking the title “übermensch.”…

    • 502 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On the other hand, lying can also become something of a requirement. At the end of Act IV, Christian has forced Cyrano to tell Roxane the truth, and let her choose who she still loves. However, right before it happens Christian gets shot, and in his last moments Cyrano tells him, ”I told her everything. It’s you she loves!”…

    • 323 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Is it Catullus' own irony coming to light here in the invocation of concordia, which will be all-too-absent from the marriage, or is it ironic prophecy on the part of the Parcae? It is hard to imagine the latter, given the triple reference we have already seen to their truth, and the refrain’s reminder that they are not just foretelling the events they sing of, but actively spinning them right then and there. Why go to such great lengths to highlight the truth of their song, only to have them present such a patent untruth? On the other hand, if the irony is Catullus' own gloss on the Parcae’s words, why has he abandoned the task of faithfully recording their veridicum oraclum?…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Cyrano de Bergerac, by Edmond Rostand, there are two characters that help the audience understand the characterization of the main character, Cyrano. Two characters that help do this especially well are Le Bret and Carbon de Castel-Jaloux. Due to their close friendship, Cyrano often reveals his secrets and feelings to Le Bret that he shares with no other character in the story. When Cyrano is in the company of Carbon and the cadets, the audience sees best the side Cyrano shows to the world, that of a brave, daring, courageous hero. There are several points in the play where the audience can see just how close Le Bret and Cyrano are.…

    • 1163 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    (Combine)The longing and need for love can cause people to go to great lengths to achieve it, even if they are not always right, for example, deception. Throughout the course of the play, Christian falls madly in love with Roxane, but is too petrified to speak his own words. He seeks out Cyrano for help and he accepts. Christian has Cyrano write poems of love for him to give to Roxane “promise me he will write everyday?” “I do promise” (107), Cyrano promises that Christian will because he knows that all along the words are truly his.…

    • 1314 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    ”- H. Jackson Brown, Jr. Even Cyrano said it himself “My happiness to make you happier,Even though you never know I gave it you.” This is a selfless act, and this is another reason why he was such a good man. He could not tell her that he loved her, because he felt like he was ugly so he knew she would think that also.…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The moments before Christian is killed, Cyrano comes close to admitting it was he whom had written the letters Roxane desires so much. With what would’ve been new information, Roxane would have had the chance to chose who she truly loved. Yet, as readers, we never come face to face with her decision, which, in return, faces Cyrano with the dangers of what he’d done in deceiving not only Christian, but also Roxane. As Roxane mourns over his dead body, Cyrano states, “I too must die, since, without knowing it, she’s mourning for me in him,” (act 4, sc 10). It is possible Cyrano meant that he must now too die in the battle with Christian, however, it could also be presumed he meant that what he’s wanted for so long, Roxane’s affection, must die with him.…

    • 2056 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Later, I dreaded the thought of seeing mockery in the eyes of a mistress. Thanks to you, I’ve had at least a woman friendship, a gracious presence to soften the harsh loneliness of my life” (221). These words comfort Roxanne as she was feeling extremely guilty for loving the wrong person. Cyrano soothes her by saying that he really only started living when he…

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Cyrano de Bergerac, by Edmond Rostand, is the story of Cyrano de Bergerac, a tragic hero. To be considered a tragic hero, a character must have to evoke pity from the audience, have a downfall, and possess admirable traits. Cyrano accomplishes these elements, making him a tragic hero. Cyrano a Soldier, and a poet is in love with his cousin Roxane, but he is too ashamed to admit it because of his big nose. Cyrano struggles with his desire to be admirable in all things; this includes helping a cadet, named Christian, who fell in love with Roxane.…

    • 1311 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I Love Roxane Analysis

    • 879 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Roxane later falls in love with the person who writes the letters not the person taking credit for them. Christian and Cyrano are incomplete men. They both have strengths and their weaknesses come to…

    • 879 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Salt To The Sea Analysis

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the novel Salt To The Sea, the author, Ruta Sepetys develops many themes and ideas. One of these themes is courage. She develops this theme primarily through three main characters. These characters are Joana, Florian, and Emelia. As these characters try to reach safety and freedom, they are faced with many trials that require courage to overcome.…

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Canterbury Tales is a book of stories told by a group of pilgrims as a storytelling contest. The story takes place at an inn where all the pilgrims meet. The pilgrims are met by a gentleman name Harry Bailey. Bailey thought it would be entertaining to challenge the pilgrims to a contest. Bailey suggested that the pilgrim travel together and during their travel each pilgrim tell four stories, two stories on the way to Canterbury and two stories on the way back from Canterbury.…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Men, Women, and Giovanni Boccaccio’s “The Decameron” Introduction In the fourteenth century in Europe, amid the disastrous times of the Black Death, a gathering of youthful Florentines composed of seven ladies and three men, choose to escape to look for asylum and departure from the disease in an estate outside of the city of Florence. This is the fundamental casing utilized by the Italian writer Giovanni Boccaccio to let us know one hundred stories of life, adoration and fortune with “The Decameron”.…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Helen Rocha Per.2 SAHC:HR By looking at the Knight's and Miller's Tale in Geoffrey Chaucer's work of fiction Canterbury Tales 1476, one can see the distinctions between love and lust, and the tragic and comic endings desire, temptation, and ones emotional necessities may lead the human mind to. The Knight who portrays humorous aristocracy among pilgrims, introduces a courtly love tale that represents his social class. The Miller on the contrary represents the middle class in Medieval England, and coveys a fabliau tale, completely distinct from the Knight's tale. Both tales introduce the conventions of romance, and upshot of desire. While one tale engages on a spiritual meaningful convention of love, the other engages in sexual drive and the humiliation lechery may bring to ones table for the rest of their living.…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays