Ethical Decision Making Case Study

Improved Essays
Tosha Kadakia
Effectively Influencing Decision- Makers by Marshall Goldsmith

In my analysis, I discuss how individuals can utilize selected guidelines intended to help them be more successful in influencing decision makers.
Developing the ability to present ideas and to educate decision makers expands the opportunity for potential success for a company. Often times, an employee is more knowledgeable about the ins and outs of his assigned unit and the associated specific tasks than the decision maker because the employee spends more time in the narrower branch of the organization. The mismatched knowledge between the employee and the decision maker creates the perfect opportunity for the employee to teach the decision
…show more content…
As seen in the WorldCom case, Vinson’s silence about unethical accounting played a major role in the organization’s downfall. For me, standing up for what I believe is ethically justified is more important than financial success. Just because the decision maker has more power does not imply that he will always make the most ethical decision. Just because the employee has a position in the company does not mean he will always make the most ethical decision either. It is in the best interest of the employer and the employee to pursue what will ethically help the corporation, not jeopardize its stake. In order to promote fair ethical practices, a model of ethical decision making needs to be implemented to line the goals of the entire organization. Since decision makers and employees may not always be ethically aware, the ability to promote these practices by encouraging ethics-based modules, proposing mandatory ethics training, and learning to empathize within the entire organizational structure are crucial. Training the entire organization, from highest ranked leaders to average employees, bridges the ethical gap between what one perceives as right or wrong. Deloitte University serves as a cornerstone of bringing together Deloitte professionals from all hierarchical levels to educate them about ethics, integrity, and moral decision making. The decision maker also needs to empathize with his employees by …show more content…
An employee’s commitment to the organization shines through his ability to serve as an advocate and to believe in the organization. Throughout the last few years as a volunteer at Heartland Hospice, I have constantly been told to be a “patient advocate.” This means that I should always serve the interest of the patient and support his or her medical decisions. Working in hospice care has challenged my position as a patient advocate. Many times patients refuse their treatment and medications to pass away sooner. The difficulty of accepting the fact that I have done everything I can to help the patient remain in this world even though the patient refuses to accept the help is a conflicting battle in my mind. However, I am learning to support a patient’s decisions and entirely follow up with the consequences. Likewise, an organization may choose another route than the employee’s proposed ideas, but as a part of the organization, an employee should serve as an organization’s advocate and support the decisions it makes. Commitment to the organization’s ethical choices advances employee loyalty and may increase job satisfaction as well as

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Ethical leaders should also be prepared to face the challenges that moral decisions bring. Leaders should put ethics ahead of everything they always do. Several activities can be done to improve the ethical culture of an organization. Ethical culture is important to the mission and goals of every organization. The organization should frequently conduct seminars to educate their staff and employees on what is important and the things that should be avoided in the organization.…

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Applying ethical behaviors and moral beliefs into the business environment is known as business ethics. Recently, in the business world, ethics have been a topic that is acquiring a lot of attention (Lewis, 1985). Furthermore, when a company maintains high standards of ethics, everyone within the company will benefit. Ethical ideas may vary from a company to another. Managers’ ethics and how they are influenced by their morals plays a big role in the company’s decisions.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The organization needs to make sure that people are actively practicing the organizations ethical culture and values. It is important for an organization to have someone to oversee employee’s ethical behavior and enforce them to practice it in their daily business activities. All great ethical programs begin with a CEO who believes that ethics program is important and should be followed and practiced before all other…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    One of the key functions of ethical leadership is purpose. The ethical leader needs to provide a firm mindset and show a drive and initiative. This keeps the organization focused and provides consistency throughout the company (Johnson, 2003). Knowledge is another key function of an ethical leader(Johnson, 2003). One who has great knowledge in tasking functions of a company, delegating responsibility and dealing with decisions is a very import function of a leader.…

    • 1398 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thus, in order for any type of organization to succeed, organizations need both good management and ethical leaders. Ethical leadership as a substantial term to an organization requires a manager to understand the core values and live them in all aspects of life for the benefit of all. Ethics are the principles, values and beliefs in defining the right and wrong behavior. On the other hand, leadership describe a leader whose behavior is guided by strong positive values. However, ethics and leadership are connected with each other, and as Cuilla & Gini (1998), noted, ethics is the heart of leadership.…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ethical activities are felt first from the top management than to the subordinates. In whatever situation, the leadership has to exercise ethics in that business (Michaelson, Pratt, Grant, & Dunn 2013, p.79). If for example, a choice is to be made between an action that is ethically correct and one that will attract profits for the organization and the management chooses the ethical decision, then they are setting a high-minded culture for the entire organization. It means that the enterprise is not just driven financially, and the junior staff will emulate. Values are vital in any organization because they act as a principle of guidance.…

    • 1750 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ph.D. professors Edward Stern, Dan Worrell and Jean Stead wrote in the Journal of Business Ethics that, “Managers cannot expect ethical behavior from employees if they do not behave ethically themselves. Managers are the most significant role models in the organizational setting; thus they have a major socializing influence on lower level employees” (p. 238). This quote proves that having strong ethics can benefit our customer satisfaction and employee job satisfaction, and that starts by positively reinforcing our ethical behaviors as leaders to our workers. This is what it takes to create the ethical climate that we must strive…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Halbert, & Ingulli ethical principles are essential to the organization in a number of ways because it helps to achieve several aspects of the operational and behavioral discipline that leads to the success, growth, and profitability of the company (2006). Ethics principles provide a guide to make decisions as well as provide the criteria through which these actions will be measured or perceived and judged by others. The ethical principles in the workplace instill the discipline and the respect within the organization; these principles and standards give provisions to strict measures that would be applicable to the persons who go against the standards and the requirements within the organization. Also, according to Ferrell, Hirt, & Ferrell `the bottom line is that managers need to be aware of what constitutes ethics, values, of the four approaches to ethical dilemmas and how organizations can promote ethics` (2014, p. 78). Ethical principles also are the best ways of executing and advancing the business goals and objectives effectively and efficiently.…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Secondly, organizational leaders must articulate what is the right thing to do within the context of their everyday challenges. Ethics must not be separated from their day-to-day business. If ethics is the way the organization operates and not just a reference manual or a training program, leaders must clarify it to their employees. As a matter of fact, all activities including training programs, client meetings, or important senior managerial strategic session, must include ethical conversations. Ethics should be the emphasis and foundation upon which all other organizational segments are…

    • 1229 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Business should be done by the agreement of both parties while being guided by their moral rules. Doing a good business does not mean always agreeing instantly. Decisions of both parties should be according to individuals judgements about being moral. Besides not all expectation of other people are good for which as a businessman we have a moral responsibility to promote the common good and not just to acquire profit for our ownsake. G. Business decisions involve economic realism, not moral philosophy.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays