Compare And Contrast Dewey And Montessori

Great Essays
(a)
Dewey and Montessori educational philosophies John Dewey and Maria Montessori both were the famous scholars on early childhood education, their philosophies were similarly to advocated learn by doing, child-centered and education needs to value the social interactions between the children and the environment. Firstly, Dewey and Montessori were both advocated learn by doing, they believed that human beings learn through a ‘hands on’ approach. Specifically, Dewey stood for pragmatism, which means believing the reality must be experienced. John Dewey said that “Education is not preparation for life; education is life itself.” (Dewey,1916) It means education must including the daily life skills but not put the emphasis on academic knowledge,
…show more content…
Dewey believed in child-centered approach, he thought children should be allowed to explore their environment, it initiates them to learn through their spontaneous. However, he was alarmed by the excesses of “child-centered” education. He argued that too much reliance on the child could be equally detrimental to the learning process. (Rhalmi, 2011) Therefore the teacher is also important to the children’s development. For Maria Montessori, her philosophies of child-centered were also similarly to Dewey. In Montessori classroom, there is no focal center of the classroom, this reflects that the teacher is not the focus of the children’s attention. Children can choose their own work of their interest, and set their own pace without interruption. During the work period, teacher support and monitor the student’s work and provide individual and small-group lessons. This may show the teacher takes the facilitator role in Montessori classroom, instead of educator. In other words, the teacher should not give a hundred percent of freedom to children, but the freedom within limits allows for the natural development of self-regulation, so that children are self-initiate to the classroom, and have intrinsic motivation. According to “The Absorbent Mind”, Montessori though that the school environment must be rich in motives which lend interest to …show more content…
Dewey said that “I believe that the school is primarily a social institution. Education being a social process.” (Dewey, 1897) According to “The School and society”, Dewey thought that the school must helping children to see the connections between their classroom activities and what was going on in the world outside the school. (Dewey, 1913) Dewey thought that the school should help students learn to live and to work cooperatively with others, he also thought that the students should be actively involved in real-life tasks and challenges. For Maria Montessori, her philosophies of the social interactions between the children and the environment were also similarly to Dewey. The multi-age classroom is a core component of Montessori education, children include different ages, so that it enables children to experience the society earlier and develop their leadership skills. Besides, in Montessori classroom, children are taught how to regulate their own social interactions, teacher demonstrates the best way to respond to arguments or new situations, giving the ability to act confidently and pro-socially when the actual problem arises. In a self-regulating classroom, the natural social tensions are resolved mostly by the children themselves. (Montessori Northwest,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Midterm Exam – The Child and the Curriculum John Dewey’s The Child and the Curriculum, written over a century ago, poses a question that can still prove relevant to teachers in this day and age. His primary question that he attempts to tackle in his paper, is simple: should education be tailored to a child’s specific needs, or to a set curriculum? Throughout the paper, he argues that the tug of war between child and curriculum is ultimately futile; choosing one over the other will still prove detrimental. Ultimately, Dewey says “all depends upon the activity which the mind itself undergoes in responding to what is presented from without” (Dewey, 1906, p.39). In other words, Dewey believes that experience is the key to learning, and the ideal curriculum should focus on…

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    There are lots of different international approaches and perspectives to children’s learning. Some of these approaches are old and some of these approaches are new. The theories have some similar points, however they do contrast each other too. Montessori Montessori believed that children should have hands on experiences to learn and, they should have real life natural resources to enable this. Montessori also said that children should have the same equipment and resources as us but in child sized.…

    • 1201 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Personal Philosophy I believe that all children are unique and bring their own knowledge and experiences to any educational environment. I believe the early childhood environment is a place for children to be free agents to; develop, learn, grow and express themselves, while having the confidence and respect they as a person are entitled to. Furthermore I also belie that all children have the right to learn and their learning be abundant with experiences, knowledge and quality, as well as feeling a sense of belonging to their community and learning environment. These beliefs are important to my teaching and my philosophy of early childhood eduction.…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Introduction to Reggio Emilia approach and Montessori method The Reggio Emilia approach emphasises on building relationships, respecting each child and the learning the power of the environment. The Montessori method, is based on self-directed learning and hands-on activities. History and significant features of the approaches The Reggio Emilia approach was developed by psychologist Loris Malaguzzi, together with the parents in the villages around Reggio Emilia in Italy after world war II. After the war, people thought children needed a different learning approach. It was believed that children’s personalities form in their early years of development.…

    • 991 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this essay, Fishman and McCarthy describe Dewey’s views on the goal of education and on what teachers should teach their students. He issued his challenge to teachers in 1932, as the United States faced a major economic depression and as Hitler and Nazi Germany was rising to power. He felt that education should provide students with the tools to be exemplary citizens in society to help the others and give towards the general good as well as find their own happiness. It is the job of the teacher to help their students develop character and morality. Teachers should prepare their students to be sympathetic and empathetic.…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Dewey remarked (1898 p.78) “that school must represent present life, life is real and vital to the child as that which he carries on in the home, in the neighborhood, or on the playground.” Dewey and the Head Start program agree when it comes to that quote, and allow for the students to live, and go through daily lives and emotions in the classroom. They are not forced to sit down and learn, because at that age, it would be nearly impossible for them to sit, focus and understand anything that the teacher tried to teach them. This is not because they do not want to learn, these kids really enjoyed doing what they get to do throughout the day, it is because of who they are and where they come…

    • 1434 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I Norma Villasenor, as a future educator of Early childhood Education hope to be able to sow the seeds of love in children and interest in learning. As well as inspiring their minds towards learning through creativity. Motivating children to learn from an early age is a fundamental value because, they are the future. I think that it is possible for children to begin to value themselves and retain their self-esteem. I believe that teaching my future students with patience, dedication and enthusiasm is the key to a better education.…

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tina Bruce Influence by Freidrich Froebel and his concept of freely chosen play , Tina Bruce theory is mainly regarding free flow play and the importance of this for children, and come up with specific characteristics of free flow play; play is freely chosen by the child, it is solely controlled and directed by the child, it is based on first hand experiences, it can involve rehearsing, role play, imagining and pretending, children will be wholly involved in their own play agenda, and finally free flow play creates the opportunity for coordinating feelings, ideas and relationships. Tina Bruce suggests that this type of play is extremely beneficial for a child’s personal growth and that their development thrives from this type of play because…

    • 1255 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    John Dewey’s My Pedagogic Creed is written during a period when the industrial revolution was strong and rampant. The education system at the time seemed to be aimed at producing as many workers as possible to increase the wealth of the economy by teaching a specific set of curriculum that disregarded the child’s psychological and social needs. Dewey says that education is comprised of both psychological and social factors and that it can only be effective if these two factors are taught synergistically; they are mutually exclusive and one without the other would be disastrous to the student. Dewey creates an effective argument through the use of inductive reasoning, which provides his audience of teachers, administrators, and anyone in a position…

    • 1045 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Curriculum Models: HighScope Model and The Montessori Method In this paper the author will focus on HighScope Model and the Montessori Method and comparisons between each approach. The HighScope Model believes that a child is an active learner. The children are given scaffolded learning that is developmentally appropriate, and the curriculum is based around interests of the children.…

    • 813 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Theorist Paper Maria Montessori vs. Albert Bandura Clarissa L. Eashmond The University of Southern Mississippi Abstract The theorist paper will discuss, compare, and contrast the theories of Dr. Maria Montessori and Albert Bandura. This theorist assignment includes the research of how each theorist began their work, and how children learn according to their ideas and observations.…

    • 1145 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    “The purpose of education is to enhance individual effectiveness in society and give learners practical knowledge and problem and problem-solving skills.” John Dewey (2008). Dewey's emphasis on the importance of democratic relationships in the classroom setting necessarily shifted the focus of educational theory from the institution of the school to the needs of the school's students. According to John Dewey the needs, experiences and abilities of students are essential. Progressivism focuses on the whole child and not the teacher or the curriculum.…

    • 1387 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is because, according to Dewey (1986), the experimentation method does not follow the old education system which is based on the built of a ready-made process, and instead is developed on discovering knowledge founded on experience (Dewey, 1968). He objected the need for specialized learning in children since it was derived out of external interests (Dewey, 1968). Dewey’s response would also include that his approach aims to include the school system with the essentials of the society to motivate the values of freedom and discovery (Dewey, 1968). He explains this by saying that schooling should not be based on matters of discrimination so that these children form a balanced and critical-minded society with an improved quality of life experience (Dewey, 1968). Dewey response would also include, that the physical, moral, and intellectual development process of children is a clear example of the principle of continuity (Dewey, 1968).…

    • 1222 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For instance, he believed that students should be active learners rather than just receiving information (Flinders & Thornton, 2013),” As a science student I can relate to this theory because I thrive in classes that requires me to be hands on with what I’m learning. For instance, in my anatomy class instead of using only text books and pictures to teach the class, we were also given a variety of hand on activities. We were assigned activities that required us to dissect animals and identify systems that we learned. John Dewey’s theory also relates to Maria Montessori ideas because they both believed that student’s environment should encourage them to be independent learners, therefore by giving them the opportunity to discover what activities and learning techniques works best for each individual, students will be encourage to create their own learning experience (Miller, 2011). For instance, growing up, I did not understand my learning habits until I started college because, throughout middle and high school most classes did not incorporate Montessori or Dewey’s ideas.…

    • 942 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Ireland there are an extensive variety of curricula in use, including Montessori, Frobel, play based and Reggio Emilia approach. Although all different approaches to childcare they are underpinned by Aistear, the early childhood curriculum framework (NCCA, 2009) and Siolta, (CECDE, 2006) our national quality framework for early childhood education. The Montessori method is based on the teachings of Maria Montessori, she had many principles and areas of interest these included the cultural area based around history, geography, science, arts and crafts, music and animals this type of learning is also similar to Aistear’s learning goals of identity and belonging aim 4 “children will see themselves as capable learners” (NCCA, 2009) and exploring…

    • 1458 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays