Carr Vs Elton Analysis

Improved Essays
The debate between E.H. Carr and G.R. Elton signifies the conflict between the “Old School” of historical studies and the Revisionist model. Carr proposes that there exists within historical studies the need for interpretation, and that there is no such thing as a universalized “truth” or “fact”. This is evocative of the Postmodernist phenomenon to critique and rethink approaches to history, which I will discuss later in this paper. Elton, on the other hand, emphasizes the universal “truth” within historical studies. He insists that there is no such thing as “subjectivity”, and all facts within historical sources are indeed just that – facts. History is composed of an objective reality that can neither be interpreted in different ways nor can …show more content…
Carr’s model is representative of the contemporary study of history and allows for interpretation whereas Elton’s model is an antiquated one and does not allow for in-depth analyses of historical events or discourse. In this paper I will examine the need and mode for Carr’s model in contemporary historiographical studies. Elton, although distinguishing history from the natural sciences, proposes a scientific rationalization of historical studies which suggests that there is one “truth” that can be discovered in a historical context. Elton encompasses the “social” scientific school which seeks to explain human action through quantitative analysis, which are the “facts” that he proposes. He assigns this quantitative value to the “truths” which he believes is evident in sources. I stated previously that this is an antiquated model because it does not acknowledge the role of power …show more content…
Carr represents an alternative path for the academy to become more inclusive of other histories, whereas Elton’s model relies on the perpetuation of old ideas. Moreover, Elton’s model only allows for a single, universalized understandings of historical texts. This is very counterproductive to understanding history, as that would only allow for a single perspective to be taught and disseminated. Elton likes to approach sources uncritically, and cherish the “truth” within them without contextualizing where it comes from, etc. to the point where Carr refers to it as a “fetish”. Yes, sources are important. Yes, it is important to acknowledge the truth found within these sources, however one must still be critical of these sources. There are no natural “facts” within history. These facts are purely constructed by interpreters are history. To this extent, I completely disagree with Elton. Truth isn’t discovered, it is

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Cruelest Miles Analysis

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The author wants the audience to understand that all the historic facts was not to bore an audience but rather interpret it to fit in today's…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Is it a collection of facts, all true and precise details…” (1). These questions suggests that, like everything else, history is a “truth” that cannot be viewed without considering perspective. Is history an idea or an open wound? Is this name “history” like Linnaeus’s stately tree, a tree that was not ordinary and that one could choose as one’s name?…

    • 1226 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His materials and his process and all his apparatus exist to enable him to show how a given event came to take place.” In other words, Butterfield writes with the purpose that historians should explain with historical facts rather than to prove who is right and try to push their own personal agenda to interpreting historical…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    John Fea attempts to answer the question posed in the title of his book, “Why Study History?” He answers this question in eight chapters that talk about the different aspects of history. In chapter one, Fea talks about the role of historians as “revisionists.” Though history can be revealed through simple facts, it is meaningless without a story. Historians try to identify the story behind the facts by following the five C’s: change, context, causality, contingency, and complexity.…

    • 374 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sojourner Truth Summary

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Historians in the academic field may disagree with each and many not always come agree in something, however, they need to have consensus in finding out what is really…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    However, history is interpreted differently and perspectives are changed as each generation…

    • 1508 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Some history events are essential evidences that illustrate ideas of how the event begins and ends. Some historians take a time to write books and articles about important events to demonstrate deep details that readers may not know about. Many historians have constructed an event to their own ideological beliefs to infiltrate those beliefs to the readers. Moreover, a Presidential history or a biography topic can be constructed with a lot of interpretations that results in arguments and delegations between historians. Robert Dallek wrote Flawed Giant Lyndon Johnson and his time 1961-1973.…

    • 1534 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Rhetorical Analysis of "The End of Men" Hanna Rosin is an American author and writer who has written "The End of Men", an article that was posted on "the Atlantic" in 2010. The article mainly focuses on the emergence of women as an authority in the American society. This reality aware the audience, or the American citizens and other workers around the world, how the end of men may happen in the near future and the rise of women should not be neglected. The author uses historical records and statistical data as evidences, in order to identify her view towards this social trend. First, the author uses a historical record as an evidence to convince the audience of her idea.…

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nicholas Carr vs Kevin Kelly Imagine a world where the internet, electronic devices, smartphones, or any type of technology that you have ever known, did not exist. How could you live without these tools? Technology has been innovating society for the past centuries. People all around the world have been benefited by the new products that technology has to offer. It is almost impossible to imagine a society without technology.…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In fact, while making a reputation about someone, we must be objective by not engaging our feelings and opinions and act like detectives, examining people’s motivations and assumptions while describing others, we must not judge anyone; therefore, we should also suspect our own motives. That is how historian must work to avoid being judgmental and subjective,…

    • 1442 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Smith’s word choice, argument style and various sources allowed her to write a piece that anyone could understand regardless of their interest and prior knowledge of historical science. For the most part, Smith’s article is able to keep the reader interested while also providing information on the historical background of the seminar and archival…

    • 914 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is several information I learn through this class. All this information was mentioned in the chapter of the books we used for this class. Most of the information I have learned was about History, History’s textbooks, Publishers of textbooks, and the story of America. History is a course that is supposed to tell the stories of the past to the present generation.…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The writings of history have been significantly influenced by the time periods during which they were written. Indeed, during these time periods, political institutions with regard to political power have greatly affected the ways in which history has been interpreted. The rise of the nation-state as a political entity during the late 18th- 19th centuries had greatly altered historiography, for, with history emerging as a modern discipline, history began to mirror the ideals of, and acts as a font of, the polities of the time periods during which it was written. In both historian Thomas Babington Macaulay’s “Minute on Indian Education” and historian Lynn Hunt’s “The Many Bodies of Marie Antoinette,” the correlation between history and power…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When things are connected through a chain of historical facts…

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Actually, historical metafiction sees history as a story, through which we…

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays