Difference Between Cbes And Simmias

Decent Essays
Summarize: In this dialogue, Socrates and his friends, keep talking about the soul. Cebes and Simmias are still confused about Socrates argument. Simmias compare it with a harmony, lyre and string. The harmony is something invisible, without body, beautiful and divine in the attuned lyre, whereas the lyre itself and its string are physical, bodily, composite, earthy, and akin to what is mortal. If destroyed, it destroys the attunement of the instrument. Cebes is also not convinced with the idea that the soul is immortal. He makes an analogy between a tailor and a cloak. A cloak has less chances of living than a man, and a tailor will make many cloaks over his life. Cebes and Simmias objections brought a lot of confusion and doubt for everyone.

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In other words, he suggests that the soul, as a whole, has parts that are divided up into areas much like the body. For example, consider the virtue or desire to be healthy. Socrates suggest that while there is a desire to be healthy, there is also an opposite desire to be unhealthy. These opposite capacities are the kind that exist simultaneously. Since they exist at same time, Socrates would say that they are in direct opposition to each other in the soul.…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    That is not something that is up for debate and not something that can typically be changed. People are born, they live their lives, grow old and then die. Thetis was not one to accept this fact. With each and every of her children, she tried to burn away their mortality and make them immortal, able to be with her forever.…

    • 2055 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cebes likewise showed himself against Socrate by proclaiming that the soul can't exist in light of the fact that for the soul to be…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By this, Plato meant that reason did not overcome spirit, spirit did not over come appetite and so on. The soul was essentially balanced. Plato believed that a soul that is in disorder is miserable and that person will never achieve happiness. He compared the soul to that of a city. An ideal city is that where all parts of the city are working together.…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Exposition: In Phaedo, there’s a conversation between Phaedo, Echecrates, and other various people. They discuss the theory of forms and the arguments for the immortality of the soul. They begin to discuss the immortality of the soul. This is called the cyclical argument; the first premise of the immortality of the soul is that all things that have opposites come from their opposites.…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Phaedo, Simmias believes that the soul is similar to the harmony made from an instrument. Socrates points out two statements that make Simmias rethink his views on the soul and the body. As Socrates turns down Simmias 's theory of the soul, not only is he able to convince Simmias, he is also able to make great arguments that support his ideas on how the soul cannot be relatable to the attunement of an instrument. Simmias 's opinion on the soul is that the harmony that is produced by an instrument is similar to the relationship between the body and the soul. Simmias mentions that the soul exists before it enters into the body of a person however the soul is composed of elements that do not exist yet.…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The body, while seemingly clearly definable and understandable, is a concept that humans have struggled to define and understand for much of history. Social conceptions of the mind of spirit shaped philosophers’ understandings of the relationship between the mind and body, as well as attitudes toward the body. In his essay “The Concept of the Body,” Eliot Deutsch presents readers with four popular modes of conceiving of the body. These models, popularized at different points throughout history, are the prison, the temple, the machine, and the instrument. Through reading Plato’s dialogue Phaedo, one gains perspective on Socrates’ conception of the body, as a prison.…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “He will require to grow accustomed to the sight of the upper world. And first he will see the shadows best, next the reflections of men and other objects in the water, and then the objects themselves.” (Pg. 869; 21) Given what Socrates is saying, to me it rings parallels of life and death, learned and unlearned. From the start of life there is a shadow in our mind, but until we learn through our senses the shape of a vase, we then understand it then we label it so mentally, as we can then call it that. It shows how in our mind, there is a blank canvas of gray matter and until we become accustomed to sights and senses we can then categorize each accordingly allowing our world be colorful with detailing objects all around…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    This previous quotation not only prove the immortality of the soul, is also proves that the soul and the body are separate. Since the soul waits for the cycle of the body, it shows that they are…

    • 1568 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    But when it comes to the attunement of an instrument on the other hand, it would be impossible to have attunement before the assembly of the instrument itself. Therefore Simmias’ argument is contradicted and upon hearing this Simmias agrees and takes back his objection to Socrates original argument. After reading this section about the attunement of the soul and Socrates response to his argument I believe that Socrates made the more coherent argument. Although Simmias had a good point when talking about the attunement of an instrument and how it would not be in existence after the object itself was destroyed, Socrates argument has more of a backing than Simmias. The most well grounded of his arguments relates back to the theory of recollection as stated in the paragraph above.…

    • 490 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    For when a man dies, it is merely the body (the moral part) that dies, while the indestructible, deathless soul remains immortal. True, for Aristotle, the soul cannot be immortal. Yet, he has not lost the ability to distinguish between the soul and the body, by claiming the soul cannot exist without the body. The soul and the body are yet distinguishable as form and actuality, and as matter and potentiality (respectively). What Aristotle offers us that is different, is a clearer understanding of soul and body as a…

    • 1885 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Glaucon Justice Analysis

    • 1584 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In order to show that human’s soul is plurality, Socrates uses the principle of opposites – a single thing is never characterized by opposites at the same time, in relation to the same thing, and in the same respect. Since this principle must be true, it is impossible for one thing to be conflicted. Sometimes, it appears that a thing is beautiful and ugly at the same time; whenever such situation occurs, it must mean that there is more than one thing. For example, there will be no contradiction if a chair is beautiful and ugly at the same time, as long as it is beautiful in respect to its form and ugly in respect to its color. Otherwise, a chair must be either purely beautiful or purely ugly.…

    • 1584 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Final Argument emerges from Socrates’ response to Cebes’ objection, which questions whether the soul is truly immortal and can exist after death. Socrates’ argument involves the Theory of Forms, and he begins by describing the Forms as self-predicated and as causes of sensible things. Plato is…

    • 1675 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Socrates’s Main Concern: The Soul Taken from the Chapter no. 2 of the book The Philosopher’s way written by John Chafee. Introduction and Background: The purpose of this thesis is to identify the main key ideas of Socrates concern with the betterment of the Soul.…

    • 1956 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    His strongest empirical argument against the immortality of the soul goes as follows: "The soul, therefore, if immortal, existed before our birth: And if that state no wise concerned us, neither will the latter." Plato 's response to this argument would likely be that events prior to our birth, do in fact concern us because we are reminded of them every time we see approximations of forms. This rebuttal is troublesome, however, because it seeks to refute a physical argument with a metaphysical argument. Although these arguments are difficult to compare, they both offer a legitimate stance, in support of their respective…

    • 1519 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays