Similarities Between 2016 And The Election Of 1800

Great Essays
The presidential election of 2016 and the presidential election of 1800 were two of the most divisive and partisan elections in the history of the United States, and many of the lessons learned from the election of 1800 have carried on through the years and become relevant to this election two hundred and sixteen years later. While the election of 2016 is widely regarded as unusual, the election of 1800 was also unusual in its time for some very similar reasons, and Edward J. Larson’s book, A Magnificent Catastrophe, describes that election in dramatic detail. Similarities between the two elections included rampant partisanship, divisions within parties, negative political attacks, and the occasional scandals, though the impacts of these were …show more content…
Many people who have heard of these scandals are at once astounded at the sheer number of them, but also at the content of them, and this has lead some to believe as well that the 2016 election is unique. When compared to the election of 1800, it is actually still difficult to refute those beliefs. While the election of 1800 surely had its own impactful scandals, such as rumors of Jefferson’s slave mistress or Alexander Hamilton, the leader of the Federalists at the time, publicly admitting to having an extramarital affair, they did not occur in the same numbers as those in the 2016 election. In fact, the sheer number of scandals caused by Trump’s controversial language and political views alone is likely to be more than the number of all the scandals in the election of 1800 combined. The only relevant correlation between the scandals of these two elections is that these supposed scandals did not make a dramatic impact on the election. Of course, almost everyone in the political world thought Trump’s various scandals had effectively sunk his chances of winning completely, yet as it turned, out the scandals did not seem to matter at all in the polling booths as Trump won the election. Clinton’s own scandal regarding her misuse of an email server could arguably have had a big hand in her loss to Trump, though it seems unlikely that it was a game changer considering she did win the popular vote. Similarly, the scandals of the 1800 election did not seem to have much impact on the results either. Hamilton’s public affair most certainly discredited him, but it did not necessarily impact his party’s candidate in the election; if it hurt anyone, it would have been Hamilton’s preferred presidential candidate for the Federalist party, Charles Cotesworth Pinckney, whom Hamilton was

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Being a Democrat, I was assigned to create a speech against this bill. One of the main points I made during my speech was the quality of the voters would drop (Shineman). This is not saying that certain people should not vote based on class, race, gender, or any other defining characteristic, though. This just means that the people who would vote just to get the money would be on average less informed than voters in the past. People who are uninformed about the potential presidents of our great nation will believe whatever the media says about them, and as most everyone in the United States knows, the media is full of half-truths and ,rarely, outright lies.…

    • 1311 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Today’s election works the same. Although, citizens are not specifically told that our votes are vandalize, us, as Americans realize that certain outcomes just do not make much sense at all. Also, today’s election and the election of 1800 are similar because both parties falsely accuse and disrespect one another in order to receive the popular vote amongst the people. For instance, in today’s society both elected candidates call each other “bullies”, “bigots” and several other harsh expressions. Oddly, this particular behavior intrigues civilians to vote for their preferred candidate.…

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In my opinion, the vice presidential debate ended up being a lot more childish than I had expected. I expect childish from Donald Trump, because that is how he has put himself out there from the very beginning. However, Mike Pence took the same approach. At one point, he fired off a comment about how Clinton and Kaine “should know a lot about an insult driven campaign”. To me, this is very childish because I don’t see the campaign as insult driven at all.…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wheeler talks about the dismay other countries had regarding the 2000 presidential election results, “It was difficult for many in both fledgling and established democracies to understand how citizens of the United States, the champion of democracy, could accept a decision to install a president who did not win the popular vote.” The electoral college diminishes the importance of the votes of people but it also reinforces the idea of a two-party political system by making it almost impossible for a third-party candidate to be…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many loyal party voters feel as if Obama did not do enough to change the nation, especially when dealing with issues such as legalization of marijuana and immigration reform. These unhappy voters may vote move their vote to a third party or they may not show up at all, vastly weakening your chances of getting elected. His approval ratings are currently lower than most presidents usually have at this point in their term, at just 49% instead of the usual 53% (Presidential Approval Ratings, 2015). This is a small difference though, and there is time for this rating to change depending on the outcome of the Supreme Court ruling on immigration reform, economic variables, and how conflicts in the Middle East play out over the next few…

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The book A Magnificent Catastrophe by Edward J. Larson is about the election of 1800. This is the United States of America's most extraordinary and influential election that they have ever held due to all that it meant to the country. This election was the first election that had their own presidential campaigns no matter how chaotic and twisted the electoral process may have been. This election was so important that Larson called it “The Second American Revolution”(Larson 22). Larson called the election this because it filled many of the holes that were still in the government that was about to be formed.…

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The progressive movement however advocated for restrictions on immigration since many immigrants came to America and caused strain on the environmental resources. Immigration according to this article has never brought prosperity to the United States and therefore citizens advocate for restrictions of immigration to take place (Williamson & Chilton, 26). Just like other nations have suffered from immigration, unite states cannot be exceptional since the immigrants invade the country. Through ideological thinking immigration is not necessary since it is seen to bring more problems instead of actually benefiting the countries. Though immigration is seen to promote cultural diversity nations and especially Americans still do not support this immigration since it is not of beneficial to…

    • 1726 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    50 Years Ago Immigration

    • 1521 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The progressive movement however advocated for restrictions on immigration since many immigrants came to America and caused strain on the environmental resources. Immigration according to this article has never brought prosperity to the United States and therefore citizens advocate for restrictions of immigration to take place (Williamson & Chilton, 26). Just like other nations have suffered from immigration, unite states cannot be exceptional since the immigrants invade the country. Through ideological thinking immigration is not necessary since it is seen to bring more problems instead of actually benefiting the countries. Though immigration is seen to promote cultural diversity nations and especially Americans still do not support this immigration since it is not of beneficial to…

    • 1521 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Trump's Speech Analysis

    • 1108 Words
    • 5 Pages

    4. The effectiveness of ethos in Trump’s speech A stereotype about politicians has been embedded in people’s mind. Politicians in America were considered as mere talkers, having not enough power to change the statue quo. Since many voters have seen through those political games, they started to lose confidence to the politicians and have been criticizing of deception and hypocrisy of politicians. In American presidential history, there were many scandals happened to the presidents, such as Watergate scandal and Lewinsky scandal, which finally led to the erosion of presidents’ popularity and reputations.…

    • 1108 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kludgeocracy In America

    • 1377 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Confusion over such a seemingly basic issue can have disastrous results. For example, when Hurricane Katrina hit New Orleans in 2005, there were miscommunications as to whether the levees were the responsibility of the state or federal government because the system is so convoluted. Confusion over one basic issue of responsibility because of the unclear political system had detrimental effects that the people of New Orleans are still trying to overcome, ten years later (Teles, 3). In a system so convoluted that even those involved are not certain of their own responsibilities, how can citizens possibly be expected to be well informed as to the specifics of their government? The average American knows which party they support and has a general idea as to why, but the…

    • 1377 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays