Compare And Contrast Daoism And Confucianism

Improved Essays
Rong Song
Yuanchong Wang. Kathryn Lenart
Hist137
10/18/2015
In such a warring period of China, world was turbulent, from state to state. King, in order to consolidate his country and power, had to carry out reforms to adapt to various national situations. In order to be a strong, rich and powerful kingdom, it must have embraced reforms by practicing Legalism. Legalism enhances the authority of government, standardizes unity of a country, instructs people’s arrangement of their lives and stimulated their initiative.
In Legalism reform, the most significant leap is the enactment of law. Legalism enabled a ruler to build up ruler’s authority. Legalism, contrast to Daoism and Confucianism, emphasizes the widely implement of law. Under the authoritative
…show more content…
On one side, as a tool of political power, law also imposed restriction on power. To some degree, they play the role as ‘check and balance’. The existence of law restricts unreasonable execution of power due to personal emotion. On the other side, laws bring power into reality and let it be exercised properly.1 Even though Legalism differs from Daoism and Confucianism it doesn’t affect the morality of enacting those laws. By the co-existence of morality and authority, legalism, ruling by law, lays the foundation for a governor. Early before the prevalence of Shang Yang’s reform, he offered the reward of fifty bronze pieces for anyone who is willing to move the wood from south gate to north gate. People didn’t even try because they didn’t believe how easy to earn such an amount of money by only moving a wood. However, only a man of poor finally decided to attempt to do the task. To their surprise, Shang Yang fulfilled his commitment by awarding this man fifty …show more content…
By the executing of laws, a kingdom will become more orderly. According to the founding father of Legalism Xunzi, laws, by separating the reward and punishments, keep people in line.3 Difference between Legalism and Confucianism is that Confucianism proposed the benevolent governing by example and Legalism advocated the necessity of reward and punishment.4 Benevolence in governing is not a feasible way to build up a powerful country because forgiveness should have certain limit and cannot only base on humanity. Humanity always mixed with personal emotion. An emotional pardon will lead to discontentment of society. An authoritative governor should not change his law by personal intention. If he did, indignation from unfairness would be aroused and the harmony of society would be difficult to maintain. Legalism, by implementing the law, clarifies the standard line of justice and evil. In this way, people will have the same standard sense of evil and right. Common sense manifests the integration of human thought. Even though School of Legalism advocated the human natures were inherently cunning and selfish and human tended to behave criminal. Since morality doesn’t exist, the only way to lead human into a righteous road is by Legalism. The emergences of revolutions are mostly from accumulated social unfairness. If a King cannot be believed and respected by his people, he cannot be in power for a long

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Thin law is primarily based on the idea of procedural laws that make up a legal system that is meant to limit arbitrary power, whether it is tyrants or other legal figures. Thick law is substantive, that encompasses a much wider range of individualistic laws that protect human rights yet limit the power that a population as a whole has. Fuller’s theory on legality is congruent with thin law as he heavily emphasizes the 8 features that a legal system should encompass. The main features being clarity and constancy, which reside with a thinner rule of law; stating that laws should be concise, and citizens should have a clear view as to how to follow and conform to the law. Fuller discusses these key features as a relative control for the legal system to act upon, allowing judgments to be derived from these procedural laws giving a sense of rigidity and specificity.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Classical India Dbq Essay

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Their empirical system was decentralized with lesser provincial leaders spread throughout the country. This allowed for greater unity and solidification until the era of the warring states. The philosophy of the ruling Zhou, one example of which was King Mu, was known as the Mandate of Heaven. The Mandate of Heaven had many facets that determined how kings ruled over China, such as governing conscientiously and being fair and wise to one’s subjects. The consequences of disobeying such tenants was the loss of power, either through invasion or mutiny.…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    but it’s for the whole country. Therefore, everyone should be rewarded for doing the right thing by following the laws. The legalists believe the Confucianists don’t study affairs pertaining to law and government. Thus, the Confucianists don’t inform the prince about current laws and keep him up to date. Also, the idea of legalism is that to not commit any crime, even if they are minor.…

    • 1573 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Judge Dee Quotes Analysis

    • 693 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Legalism was based off a fixed system of laws that defined a specific fixed penalty for each certain offense. Legalism had no bias or changing of the penalties, no matter what class or circumstances, there wasn’t even an exception for the ruler who was considered to be above the law. While working a case judges had to find out what the crime was and then the punishment was given immediately, since penalties were fixed. On page 59, when Judge Dee begins to suspect Mrs. Djou of killing her husband due to having an affair with another man, he tells her that a woman killing her husband is one of the most terrible crimes to be committed.…

    • 693 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Legalism had a very strict and harsh mindset behind it, and that is exactly what it turned out to be, strict and harsh. Legalism was executed in this way because people were too selfish to set a good example for each other. Therefore, people weren’t really allowed the chance to set an example for each other because when they were told to do something they would do it with no excuses or exceptions. If you failed to do the task you were given you would be severely punished and your ruler wouldn’t hesitate to do so. Hanfeizi created Legalism and he believed strict and harsh was the only way to rule and create a well organized society.…

    • 663 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    China has one of the longest known histories in ancient world history. As civilization developed, so did the ideology of philosophy, society, and the world. There are three philosophies, and one religion that played a significant role in establishing Chinese history. These philosophies are Confucianism, Legalism, and Buddhism. Each has its own meanings; each had its own ways of seeing the nature of human beings, society and the universe.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the Period of the Warring States, from 403 B.C.E. - 221 B.C.E., political confusion aroused in China. During this time, many thoughtful people sought to restore political and social order by reflecting on the proper roles of human beings in society. As a result, three philosophical schools of thought emerged: Confucianism, Daoism, and Legalism. Although all three of these philosophies were formed to restore order to China, each one had very different ideals about how to cure the ills of society. Whereas these three philosophies agreed on forming a cure for society, they had very different ideals on the way of human nature.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Legalists believed that peace and order can only be obtained through a strong government. They also believed that humans were evil and needed a strong forceful hand in order to do the right thing, and in order to do the right thing harsh punishments and tough laws needed to be created. Because of Legalism brutal enforcement of laws, many commoners turned to Confucianism and Daoism, even though the government followed legalism. The only reason that Legalism adopted this government was to gain control of other…

    • 1619 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both Han Feizi and Confucius did not hold an important government position. Kongzi believes that if someone is a filial son and a good brother, then he is already taking part in government position so there is no need to speak of participating in government. Han Feizi did not hold an important position in the government of his state due to the fact that he was a stutterer who could not speak his own counsel. Differences: The Ruler ”…

    • 255 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Dearest leader, I urge you to follow the philosophy of Legalism to run your great empire on. Legalism is the best and most sound way to run an empire. To begin I would like to tell you about this philosophy and how it can be put into place to run your vast empire. You see humans are all naturally selfish and corrupt, every person's going to do what's best for them even if that means taking down your great emperor my Emperor. Whether it's committing murder or stealing some rice every person must be held accountable for their actions.…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the other developments that a common language allowed was the development of a code of laws to help govern the empire. Laws helped to reaffirm power structures in the empire as well as protection of human rights, an idea that has lasted to present times. The ruler often used laws to express his will throughout the empire and these laws were distributed by the officials of the ruler were higher ranking than the citizens. Goodspeed discusses this structure in the Babylonians, “The constitution of a state ruled by a king with such prerogatives and position is naturally summed up in the ruler. The citizen, while he expects protection and justice, is a subject; the officials are the king’s dependents; his will is law; and the strength of…

    • 1736 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As Tamaha states: “law is distinct from custom and morality in that it is an institutionalized apparatus that makes a superior claim to maintain normative order through the application of physical force within a territory.” “ Law is not a necessity for society to exist, however social order and moral codes, often enforced by other members of the group, are. “Before this, there was a kind of primordial soup in which custom, morality, and law were indistinguishable.” Until these stringent guidelines for appropriate human behavior are separated from rules regarding custom and morality, they cannot be deemed…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Legalism In China

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages

    (Wu 1). People that lived in a civilization that used legalism as their form of government had to be careful to not fall out of line because there would be consequences for not following the rules that come with the legalism beliefs.…

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pros And Cons Of Confucius

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In World History, it is important to understand not only what has happened, but also the culture in which it happened. The world in which the sayings of Confucius were spoken, written, and understood is a world much different than the one we live in today. That being said, we do see some of these basic principles in our daily lives, but to truly understand these sayings, the readers must place themselves in the shoes of the men and women who lived in the time of Confucius. One of the popular themes in The Analects is Confucius’s view on government, and in this text he lays out a blueprint for a paternalistic authoritarianism through the way he explains an effective government, and through the way he explains an effective ruler.…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Essentially, the emperor of ancient Rome have dominant position in the society and the emperor have superior rights that the civilians. Moreover, the emperor have the right to control the people’s life. He can decided whether he should take away or maintain one’s life. However, the political system of today’s China are similar to ancient Rome in some aspects. Although the leader of today’s China didn’t have the right to decide one’s life directly anymore, the inequality phenomenon are still exist and the gap between the civilians and the leader are vast.…

    • 1545 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays