Compare And Contrast Chris Treadwell And Into The Wild

Superior Essays
The stories of Chris McCandless and Timothy Treadwell’s journeys to Alaska, provokes the common person to ask at the end of it all: Are they men that people should look up to, or are they just individuals who bit off a little more than they could chew? The author of Into the Wild, Jon Krakauer, reveals Chris McCandless to be an introvert who feels the need to remove himself from a typical life in society and begin his own adventures to figure out who he really is. In an effort to show the issues of living in the wilderness on your own, director Werner Herzog introduces Timothy Treadwell and his disturbing transformation during his 13 summers in the wilderness. McCandless and Treadwell both had different motives for venturing into the wild. …show more content…
At the same time, their similarities of trying to break the mold, live outside of society, and be themselves is shown throughout the book and documentary.
Both McCandless and Treadwell had similarities and differences. Their reasons for leaving society stemmed from similar things but shared their differences. McCandless left because he wanted to escape society and his personal issues. A few years before he left on his adventure he had discovered a long hidden family secret. He discovered that his father had another family besides his own. He was unable to look past this and was stuck in a toxic circle of not being able to forgive his parents, feeling as if they had lied to him his whole life. This
…show more content…
When it came to family, neither one of the men had a strong connection with them. When McCandless started his adventure he split himself completely off from his family. His father comments, “How is it, that a kid with so much compassion could cause his parents so much pain?” (104). His parents were confused on why McCandless didn’t keep their feelings in mind. This was partially because of how he felt about his father's actions, but if he viewed them in a good light he would have at least told them his plan instead of having them worrying for years. In addition, his mother commented , “He told us what he thought we needed to know and nothing more. He was that way about everything” (120). McCandless’ distant nature didn’t go unnoticed by his family. However, Treadwell's parents were very distant with him. His dad said, he “spiraled down”, but didn’t know how to help. Treadwell went off his medications and took other harmful drugs. They were supportive of his decision to go to Alaska but knew that he had other deep rooted issues which could have caused his obsession. During the film, Treadwell barely makes mention of his family showing their unimportance to him. Both men had distant friends. McCandless had friends in high school and college but didn’t keep in contact with him. His most relevant friends near the time of his adventures would be Wayne Westerberg and Jan Burres. He met these people on his

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Chris Mccandless Analysis

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Christopher McCandless did not make the right choice in not letting his family know he was alive and well. Nothing hurts more than the loss of a loved one, the passing of Chris devastated his family. Chris left with the intention of not wanting to be found, Chris caused stress on his family because they had no idea if he was alive. The least that Chris could have done to communicate with his family would be to send them a postcard once in a while to let his family know he was still living. I believe Chris made the wrong choice in not telling his family, it caused his family emotional pain.…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although strengthening the relationship with his parents after high school, it eventually deteriorated to where he would become angry more often and become more withdrawn. As a result, this showcases how McCandless could not relate to the life his parents had nor the life his parents had set for him. In an essay written through the psychological view of Into the Wild the author states that “you don’t need human relationships to be happy, God has placed it all around us” (Room 701, 2008). This statement evinces how McCandless chose to go and venture off into what “God has placed around us” to look for happiness rather than relying on “human relationships” to provide him with happiness. This provides the possibility of the lack of love he felt from his parents to be the reason as to why he chose to run away from society.…

    • 869 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The epigraph concludes that Chris wanted to free himself from worry and stress, but displayed no concern of his family while turning away from society. In response to Chris’s death, his sister Carnie stated, “I just don’t understand why he had to take that kind of chances” (Krakauer 91). While Chris McCandless was wealthy as a child, he was not happy. He believed those in need were more deserving of wealth than he was and was against the idea of his family spoiling him. Chris may have been mad at his father for living a “double life”, but the true motive behind his odyssey was he wanted to forget this spoiled childhood and prove to his family he could live without material.…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In most cases parents would notice right away if something strange is going on in their child's life, but in this case McCandless’s parents had no clue. Walt, McCandless father and Billie his mother were blind when it came to interpreting their son's intentions. They may have wanted the best for their son, but that is not what he desired. McCandless had mutual feeling for his parents, when he left he didn't think about how his parents would feel because at the time they didn't pay much attention to how he felt. He held a grudge on his father because he continued to have a private relationship with his first marriage wife after he was with Billie, McCandless mother (Krakauer 84).…

    • 644 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since his father did not establish a relationship which him this lead him to question his importance. It is implied that Willy is reminded of the abandonment by his father when the flute plays right before he takes his life. It was evident that being left behind by his father lead him to constantly doubt himself. He did not realize his importance to his own family and ultimately abandoned…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Other Moore Analysis

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Because no action was taken to adequately prepare him for life (via education), Wes Moore resorted to dealing drugs in order to support his family. At one point in the other Wes Moore’s life, he tries to quit the drug game, but fails because he is unable to find a job. Moreover, Wes Moore is unable to find a job because of the lack of education due to the low expectations placed upon him in his life. As a result, Wes Moore is stuck in a cycle of failure, because he was expected to fail from the very beginning; his life has already been shaped by the expectations placed upon…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His father demonstrated his sense of unease by giving him the better of the two guns, in hopes that if he would need to kill something big he could. Speare tells us, “It was the first sign that he had given that he felt uneasy about leaving Matt here alone” (4). Also, He gave Matt the watch; although it was not very helpful in means of self defense, Matt’s dad gave it to him as a gift in case he never would see him again. When he left he was clearly ignoring the uneasy feeling he had. This could have leaded to regret if Matt had of been severely hurt or killed.…

    • 493 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Telling lies and losing his sense of war-changed self afflicts him. Krebs’ family and society pressure him into “renormalizing.” When attempting to reintegrate him into the community, his family ignores the past years that Krebs has spent at war and instead views him as “Harold”, Krebs’ previous teenage self who never grew up. In “Soldier’s Home,” the war experience…

    • 1282 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Holden feels he has to deal with everything on his own because that is how it’s always been for him whether it is with Allie’s death or in school. Freud would argue that the lack of love and support from his parents and Allie’s death has caused his inability to create or give in to any sense of attachment. It has led him to believe he is “alone’ and deny the need of companionship. Holden claims people never notice, he says, “Everybody says that, especially my father…people always think somethings all true. I don’t give a damn…sometimes I act older than I am…but people never notice it.…

    • 1282 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Whereas, the people in the town who weren’t enlisted, didn’t experience these tragic events themselves which disheartened Krebs because they didn’t understand first hand the impacts, challenges and consequences of this war in particular. He also demonstrates this idea through his mother and younger sister. In conversations with his mother, she tried making small talk about the war with him but he noticed how she wasn’t really interested or didn’t want to know. He believed that his mother wouldn’t have understood anyways. He implied that he resented her doing this because he was ready to talk about his experiences at war and his perspective but his mother didn’t want to hear about the truths of war, and possibly didn’t want change.…

    • 1119 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays