Case Study: Maetta Vance V. Ball State University

Improved Essays
bearing on her actual job. Also, in combination with when Anna was not selected for promotions due to the rumors, although she was highly qualified, indicates a direct and severe violation of the Title VII rights. The refusal to hire an employee due to questionable integrity sparked by rumors is grounds for a hostile work environment.
Michael refused to address the rumors because he found them amusing, that is also grounds hostile work environment in an indirect manner. Michael was retaliating against the fact that he repeatedly asked for money and was denied; speculating that ego came into play (which is subjective and not enforceable). In spite of Anna’s request to Michael to stop the rumors, Michael refused. Although she did not formally
…show more content…
Ball State University, the Supreme Court agreed with the university adding an element to the definition of a hostile work environment. In this case, Maetta Vance cited that she was treated unfairly by her co-workers. Incidents occurred such as refusing to shake her hand, having a cold demeanor and slamming kitchen equipment when she was around, thus, over the years, resulting in a hostile work environment.
Mayetta’s employer acknowledged the harassment and provided evidence to suggest that they attempted to resolve the issues that Maetta was experiencing. Conflict resolution is a critical part of employer and employee relationships. The employer in this case could have benefited and prevented a lawsuit by tuning into conflict resolution skills. Most tense situations and conflict bring about strong emotions in people. The inability of the employer to resolve the issue in a healthy manner lead to outside resolution.
In this case, the Supreme Court defined a supervisor as someone who is "empowered by the employer to take tangible employment actions against the victim (Garofalo, P., 2013." Therefore, the persons affecting Maetta were not considered to have supervisory positions, as they did not have the formal powers to terminate

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Abbey Randt Case Summary

    • 1408 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Minnesota Courts apply the principles developed in the Title Nine cases in analyzing suits brought under the Minnesota Human Rights Act. Under both the Federal and State law on plaintiff and employment context must establish 1) membership in a protective class, occurrence of an unwelcome harassment, that the harassment was based on plaintiff’s status in the projective class and the harassment affected a term, condition or privilege of employment or recreated a hostile work environment. Isaac Vogal Violated Corporate Policies Against Harassment and Discrimination According to the company’s employment handbook all employees and staff are expected to treat people…

    • 1408 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Due to the facts found by Mr. Robinson and the hearing outcome, he ordered that Mr. Sterne be restore to his original position and rank, and be compensated for any back pay and benefits that he had lost since his demotion. Additionally, Robinson found that there was irregularities with how the discipline was handed out and there was no due process and progressive discipline before demotion and loss of pay, thus Sterne was discriminated against an was due his return to his past position with back pay. This case again shows, specific issues with retaliation being taken against subordinates without due process and could actual fall into a Title VII Civil Rights Act case, but the District of Columbia has a Civil Process for adjudicating employee…

    • 1242 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “The elements necessary to establish a § 1983 . . . violation will vary with the constitutional provision at issue. But common to all §1983 . . .…

    • 337 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Bukowski v. Clarkson University In 2012, the case of Bukowski v. Clarkson University made it all the way to the highest New York state court. This case involved the plaintiff, Shawn Bukowski, suing his school on the grounds of negligence by the defendant (Lippman, 2012). Shawn Bukowski was a pitcher for the baseball team at Clarkson University, where, during an indoor practice, was hit by a line drive in the jaw and sustained an injury. Bukowski felt that Clarkson University and their baseball coach had acted negligently and put him in unreasonable risk of harm, because there were conditions on the field that enhanced his risk to sustaining this type of injury (Lippman, 2012).…

    • 2119 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Legal Analysis Union Pacific Did Not Discriminate Against Complainant on the Basis of Gender The Complainant raises two issues: 1) that she was denied a promotion and 2) dismissed from her position. She alleges that each of these events occurred based on her gender or for filing a prior complainant. She believes others were treated more favorably then she.…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The West Virginia Board of Education v. Barnette case that was argued from March 11,1943, to a decision made June 14,1943. The case was filed when a member of Jehovah's Witness, Walter Barnette, was opposed to children in public schools being forced to salute the flag at activities. Barnette had fought other cases for his religion that didn’t like saluting symbols. Since children caught not saluting were expelled or charged as a delinquent, Barnette said that making kids salute the flag was unconstitutional, violating the first amendment.…

    • 215 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rosenberger v. University of Virginia Rosenberger v. University of Virginia was a case that focused on wanting eligible funding for student religious publications. Although, the university provided funding for other organizations, the student religious organization for publication did not meet the criteria, according to the University of Virginia. Facts The University of Virginia has several organizations on its campus that allows publications to be printed according to their specific requirements. There was one particular organization at the University of Virginia that created a Christian magazine Wide Awake founded by Ronald Rosenberger, that did not get this opportunity.…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Ross Dress for Less has had a lawsuit filed against them for wrongful termination of an employee. This employee had worked at Ross Dress for Less for almost 6 years. In the lawsuit, this employee claimed that she was harassed very badly. The employee who filed the lawsuit against Ross Dress for Less states, “I was harassed so severly by District Manager - Annmarie Lombardi and Zone Director, Hank Rogalski that I was hospitalized on August 18, 2009 with shortness of breath and severe chest pains. My health was being affected by all the stress and berating that I was being subjected to.…

    • 280 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Supreme Court decisions on sexual harassment, particularly in the Faragher case, have increased concerns about the nature of an acceptable policy and complaint mechanism. In that decision, issued on the same day, the Supreme Court ruled that, when there was no direct adverse job action involved, an affirmative defense against claims of supervisor harassment can be made. There is research relevant to the issues of effective policies, investigation processes, and what constitutes a reasonable or unreasonable failure to use an available complaint mechanism. However, further research, written in a way that makes it more accessible to lawyers and the courts, would be of…

    • 104 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some of the cases that have set legal precedence in the areas of retaliation and sexual harassment include the following: City of Los Angeles, Dept. of Water and Power v Manhart, (1978). In this case the supreme court ruled that in administration of company pension plan Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 made it illegal for an employer to discriminate against any individual because of an individual’s sex (Egan, 2010). Meritor Savings Bank, FSB v. Vinson, (1986). In this case the court held that Titlve VII prohibits sexual harassment in employment, even if the harassment does not cause a direct financial injury. This was the first time the court recognized a cause of action in regards to sexual harassment based on the creation of a…

    • 324 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    An employer's job is to make sure all of their employees are protected and to provide a safe work environment. Janet's employer could have made reasonable accommodations to avoid environmental triggers of seizures such as installing anti-glare filters, reducing the brightness, or a training on how to handle someone who has seizures. Janet's collogues started to avoid her out of fear and lack of their knowledge of epilepsy. The employer should have conducted a training program or send out information on how to take care of someone who is suffering from medical conditions such as seizures right in front of them, without violating Janet's privacy. The lack of sensitivity training towards coworkers lead to the physician who is knowledgeable of epilepsy, to ask the administration to fire her.…

    • 1509 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Evan Miller has had a rough upbringing. He has had emotional abandonment from his alcoholic and drug abused mother, his abusive father and forced to be placed in multiple foster cares throughout his childhood. Miller is a prime example of an abandoned, troubled minor, whose true destiny has been destroyed due to these circumstances. The problems he has faced steered him to being depressed and unsatisfied, using drugs, alcohol and four suicide attempts to trying and fulfill the emptiness he has been feeling his entire life.…

    • 1439 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As an employee or an employer, discrimination in the workplace is a difficult issue to deal with, it can be complicated and misunderstood. The legal and ethical issues involved can be arduous, and extensive but is imperative to the work force. For many years I worked as a the only female in a construction supply company, but it was only recently did I personally experience the ethical and legal issue of discrimination. For 13 years I worked for a small privately owned construction supply company, in July of 2012 the owner of the company decided to retire and sell the company to a large corporation based out of North Carolina.…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction An ethical dilemma in the workplace is sexual harassment and can be a sensitive issue for all parties involved. Additionally, a hostile work environment is one which is “permeated with discriminatory intimidation, ridicule, and insult” (Kimble, 2016, pg. 319, 320). This paper will focus on the issues of these two dilemmas. Ethical Dilemma – Sexual Harassment and Hostile Work Environment…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Sexual harassment in the workplace is a hazard encountered in the working place across the world. It reduces the quality of working life, jeopardizes the well-being of both working men and women, and imposes costs on firms and organizations. The issue pertaining to sexual harassment in the workplace has been addressed by several international groups like the United Nations (UN), the International Labour Organization (ILO), the European Union (EU), the Caribbean community (CARICOM), and the organization of American States (OAS) as a human right violation, a form of violence, and discrimination. Since sexual harassment in the workplace pollutes the working environment and can have a devastating effect upon the health, confidence, morale and performance…

    • 1769 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays