Fat Or Blame For Our Weight Analysis

Improved Essays
Fat or Fit – it’s your choice!
Who should we blame for our obesity? Do we really need the government to get between us and our waistline? (Balko, Radley, pg.561). Are we that mentally challenged that we are not capable on making better choices towards our own health? These are some of the issues that both articles examine. While Balko, Radley tries to persuades us with his article, Obesity: Who Is Responsible for Our Weight? In believing that individuals should be free to do whatever they want with their own persona (Pg.561). That we have the capacity to determine our own actions, and that the government cannot tell us what we can and cannot eat. While Kelly Brownell and Marion Nestle article, Analyzing A Visual: Obesity, believes that the
…show more content…
No one doubts that advertisements can influence people. However, advertisements do not force anyone to eat anything. Besides, any type of food can be good in moderation, and people are the ones who ultimately choose what they are going to eat. Likewise, Kelly Brownell and Marion Nestle believe that the fast food restaurants are the ones to blame for our obesity, because according to them, if we blame the victims (you, I and society as a whole) are like letting the food industry get away with a crime because for them fast food is poison. Likewise, Brownell and Nestle argues that “humans are hardwired, as a survival strategy, to like foods high in sugar, fat and calories” (pg.564). The idea that the government should protect us from our own weaknesses is nonsense. For Brownell and Nestle the government should create and enforce public policies to encourage healthier food choices that would help reduce …show more content…
They believe that the government should step into our lives and basically dictated us when to eat, how much, and how often should we eat it. On the other hand, the article of Obesity: Who is Responsible for Our Weight? (pg.561) by Radley Balko argues that “Worse, socialized health care makes us troublingly tolerant of government trespasses on our personal freedom” (pg. 562). Balko argues for less government intervention. In addition, he believes that the government needs to make obesity a personal responsibility; after all, we are what we eat, and it is one’s own personal responsibility to choose

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    "(Zinczenkonov, 2) Zinczenkonov thinks the government should require fast food restaurants to put the nutritional information on their products. Balko argues that we should make healthy choices and the government should not be babysitting us. He also argues that government interventions will hurt those who are living a healthy lifestyle. "Our lawmakers enacted a huge entitlement that requires some people to pay for other people's medicine. "(Balko, 1) We end up paying the health care costs for people who are sick as a result of their obesity.…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sugary Drinks In America

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The media need to advertise healthy things instead of junk food and sodas that are tempting and appealing. This causes people to be more evoked to the junk and unhealthy stuff they see. It puzzles me to this day why a salad or something healthy is an arm and a leg versus a burger that can be a dollar at a fast food restaurant. Maybe if we educate kids and adolescents about the obesity rate and health problems in America that is leading to death by the sugary drinks, fast food, and junk that is out there; it will decrease the rate of obesity etc… I stand firm on educating people about healthy food, exercise, and about the health factors related to obesity from indulging in junk food and sugary drinks. I believe people still are going to live an unhealthy lifestyle and eat/drink what they want no matter if the government intervenes or not.…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The writer points out about how this change in private health will just increase chances of more involvement of federal restrictions on the consumer’s liberties and our freedom to choose. This is so because a society where people are held responsible for the action of each other will more likely accept other restrictions put on them. Balko then proceeds to criticize how a lot of nutritionists and organizations encourages people that their condition is not their responsibility and “we’ve got to move beyond ‘personal responsibility.’”(468). The writer thinks that it’s not appropriate to count obesity as a “public health” issue and it is a personal matter and decision of what we choose to eat. Similarly, Maxfield too dislike the involvement of critics and writers in trying to control our eating choices.…

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fat Or Healthy Vs Obesity

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages

    No one doubts that advertisements can influence people. However, advertisements do not force anyone to eat anything. Besides, any type of food can be good in moderation, and people are the ones who ultimately choose what they are going to eat. Likewise, Kelly Brownell and Marion Nestle believe that the fast food restaurants are the ones to blame for our obesity, because according to them, if we blame the victims (you, I and society as a whole) we are like letting the food industry get away with a crime because for them fast food is poison. Likewise, Brownell and Nestle argue that “humans are hardwired, as a survival strategy, to like foods high in sugar, fat and calories” (564).…

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Who is responsible for so many Americans dealing with obesity? While many Americans want the government to find who’s responsible for obesity and to inflict laws to control the obesity some feel it is each person’s responsibility. In Balko’s article What You Eat Is Your Business he pointed out that the government shouldn’t get between the American’s and their health, but hold the people to their own responsibilities on their health. He feels that having the government step in will cause people to be less responsible for their own health because they know they’re not paying for it. However, Zinczenko in Don’t Blame the Eater argues that fast food companies are the blame on Americans’ obesity.…

    • 1537 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The resulting income should be earmarked for a program that encourages a sound diet for Americans by making healthy food more affordable and widely available” (Bittman). Although the author has a good point because yes you could tax unhealthy food but in reality it has one fatal flaw. Taxing food because you do not want people to consume it is unconstitutional. People are free to eat whatever they want. Americans are not known for liking high taxation especially when it come to what they eat.…

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    So as a country, alternatives and powerful influences must be introduced in order to decrease obesity. Michael Pollan’s article “Unhappy Meals” in The New York Times, has lots of certain advice to steer away from the tricks of processed foods and have America move into a healthier lifestyle. He suggests that processed foods imply they are based around important nutrients to help support human health, when in reality…

    • 2977 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In my experience, when the tax of the items I usually buy is higher, I would definitely switch to something cheaper. The lesson I have learned is that poor people will always switch up to other things if the items they usually buy has a higher tax percentage. In “What You Eat Is Your Business,” Radley Balko argues that putting taxes on foods to decrease the obesity is wrong, and instead, the government should “foster a sense of responsibility in and ownership of our own health” (1). In other words, rather than imposing taxes on foods and soda, Balko suggests that the government should lead the consumers to the right path by educating what is good them. To response to Balko, in “Ounces of Prevention...,” the authors argue that higher tax percentage will reduce the sugared-beverage consumption, which is the largest risk for obesity and diabetes (Brownell and Frieden 1).…

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Obesity is a problem. Whether it is a problem that affects all of us, as suggested by David Zinczenko in “Don’t Blame the Eater” or each our own, as proposed by Radley Balko, action must nevertheless be taken. Balko makes good points in his article, but Zinczenkos credibility makes his essay stronger. Balko’s proposition is not realistic and I believe it does not put into consideration the best “of the people.” His idea of reform would only benefit very few people and does not take into account people with health problems.I believe Zinczenko understands the issue better and proposes a more realistic proposal. If the government did more to prevent toxins, such as the one big company’s choose to put on their menu, we would be in better shape.…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He provides several supporting reasons for his central claim throughout the article. Balko explains that anti-obesity initiatives, such as requiring more detailed food labels, banning junk food from vending machine in schools, and promoting “fat tax” on high calories food are way too wrong and gaining federal support with no specific outcome. Besides, he states that American’s well-being becoming a matter of “public health” rather than a matter of personal responsibility. Moreover, Balko argues that America’s health care system is moving toward the socialism and that people are becoming more responsible for others and less for themselves. For instance, Balko writes, “Our lawmakers just enacted a huge entitlement that requires some people to pay for other people 's medicine”.…

    • 1194 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics