The Tempest Compare And Contrast Ariel And Miranda

Superior Essays
Yaniga ansforming Shakespeare’s invisible spirit into a romantic hero, and in doing so, re-contextualizing the original character’s attributes and actions.elationship to the level of the sublime, in keeping with the foundations of Romanticism, and so the artistic expression of such a relationship would require a character to match. It’s significant that out of the whole Shakespearean repertoire, stocked with couples such as the ubiquitous Romeo and Juliet, the well-matched Beatrice and Benedick, and the ill-fated Othello and Desdemona, Shelley instead selected Ariel and Miranda, two characters who hardly interact, let alone share a relationship, over the course of their play. In depicting a connection which Shelley believed to be the height …show more content…
“With a Guitar, To Jane” is Ariel’s dedication as he gifts her with the titular instrument, describing in length the nature of their relationship, and nature itself, which imagines new depths for a character who is given little dimension by Shakespeare.
It may be his marginalized, and somewhat isolated role in The Tempest which makes Ariel uniquely qualified to fill the role that Shelley’s poem necessitates. There are several means by which Ariel is separated from the rest of the cast, the clearest example being that he is the only nonhuman in a play that delves into the question of what a human is. He introduces himself in the first act having created the titular storm and then transported himself back to Prospero to make his report; this ability to fly, teleport, or otherwise travel through the air (this power is not specified by Shakespeare but has been interpreted creatively by many adaptations) gives the audience a sense that Ariel operates on a plane that is, if not higher, than at least very different from
…show more content…
Ariel of The Tempest is an ageless being, a detail that does not impact the plot of the play except to provide historical reference for the island and an imagined future for what might happen to the island once Prospero leaves. But in the hands of Shelley, that timelessness provides a tragic, romantic weight to the story of Ariel and Miranda, as Ariel is forced to consciously live through Miranda’s death repeatedly; as he describes, “When you die, the silent Moon/ In her interlunar swoon/ Is not sadder in her cell/ Than deserted Ariel” (Shelley). The pain that Ariel experiences as an immortal being is compared to the pain that Shelley experiences in his love for Jane; indeed, the timeless quality of the poem emphasizes the power of love itself, in its ability to withstand the test of centuries. Shelley also makes use of Ariel’s canonized connection to nature. The extent of Ariel’s backstory provided in The Tempest is that he was imprisoned “into a cloven pine” by the witch Sycorax, and he did “painfully remain a dozen years”; but because Ariel seems happy to be left to himself with the island at the end of the play, it’s likely that his incarceration was only painful because of an inability to move around and be amongst the whole of the island (Shakespeare 17). The play alludes to the idea that

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Ariel tells Prospero he believes that he will forgive them, after he sees them in the state they are in he will have compassion and…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The complex nature of discovery means that each uncovering can be confronting and provocative. Many individuals find that discoveries result from an unprecedented natural event or an inspired reappraising one’s inner and outer surroundings. Shakespeare’s 1611 play The Tempest explores the dynamics between the significance of new knowledge and how certain experiences become catalysts for the ultimate themes of the play: reconciliation and forgiveness. Similarly, Joel Schumacher’s 1990 movie Flatliners uses a supernatural theme, structure and cinematic special effects to demonstrate how while ideas of discovery vary, each experience is a potent undertaking, intimately related to new perceptions of ourselves and our relationships with others.…

    • 977 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Salem Alfarraj Extra Credit “EC Media-Influences” Disney movies are a great way to teach children about morals and values that can help shape children’s characteristics and identity development. Children feel taken away to a fantasy world and parents certainly appreciate those movies for the benefits they carry and the lessons they teach. However, a great deal of Disney movies host gender roles and stereotypes that affects our generation. The Little Mermaid and Frozen are some of the movies we will analyze and explore to see how gender roles, gender behavior are being portrayed; and how these movies teach children the meaning of relationships and sex appeal.…

    • 1279 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Caliban and Frankenstein’s Creature are both considered to be monsters due to their physically abhorring appearance. Caliban is said to be “A strange fish.” and the Creature is called a “…vile insect.” by his creator, as well as a “Devil” on multiple occasions. These descriptions imply that these characters are less than human, which introduces the concept of the “other.”…

    • 1855 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Rene Descartes’ statement, “I at least know for certain that nothing is certain” perfectly illustrates the multiple problems that arise when all rational beings realize that their senses can deceive them and that the very foundation of their knowledge is based on the assumption that everything they encounter is real. Thankfully, being aware of the problem is the first step in solving it. The juxtaposition of Rene Descartes and William Shakespeare reveals a difference of opinion when they set out to examine and solve the problems that arise from the doubtfulness of the knowledge provided by our senses. Although both authors agree on the importance of solitude and the potential problem of an evil genius manipulating our senses, Descartes’ use…

    • 1512 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In “The Tempest” by William Shakespeare, there is an island. It is inhabited by a ‘man’ named Caliban and a spirit named Ariel, who is imprisoned in a tree. Both got there because of a witch called Sycorax. Caliban is her son and Ariel a servant that disobeyed her. Eventually the island becomes home to Prospero and his daughter Miranda.…

    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Humanity’s desire for power and control was the driving force behind the European colonial period beginning in the 16th century. The Tempest, written by William Shakespeare in 1610, portrays the social issues and insecurities that were caused due to the new-found colonialism. In the second scene of Act 2, the relationship between the colonizers and the colonized festers, consequently leading to discord. Shakespeare uses variations of literary devices, figurative language, diction, and combating tones to portray this societal conflict through the inequality that encompasses the partisan power struggles between the Europeans and natives on the island. Repetition and meter were singular literary devices used to create a discrepancy between Caliban…

    • 1417 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    People compare and contrast things on a daily basis. I, myself have done this, comparing and contrasting every little thing I can. Being someone who grow up loving Disney movies, I’ve seen all the Disney/ princess films. I fell in love with these kinds of movies so as I grow older I still watch the movie as they came out with new ones. Moana is one of the recent Disney films that reminded me of another Disney film The Little Miranda.…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Ariel is also almost like Prospero’s spy as he reports back everything that is said from the characters as Ariel has the ability to be unseen by the characters so they do not realise they are being listened to or having tricks played on them. Ariel is also similar to Slim as they both have bosses and are told to carry out tasks, but still they have power over people although they both have a limit of power due to them both having bosses and the audience and the reader of The Tempest and Of Mice and Men are sympathetic towards Ariel and Slim because of this as they are both trapped by the power of their…

    • 1699 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    We immediately see the connection between these characters, and the part of the relationship that the spirit will fulfil throughout the play. It is again Prospero that has taken the governing roll in the relationship between him and another character. Ariel addresses her master as sir on countless occasions during the scene, but not once is she/he prompted to do this by Prospero, nor is she ordered to obey, unlike Miranda who is constantly reminded that she is in the presence of her father, who was once Duke of Milan, Someone who she is expected to serve, and…

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Prospero, a rightful Duke turned sorcerer, possesses magical powers due to extensive learning and reading from his collection of books. Using his magic, Prospero frees Ariel from the tree in which he was imprisoned by Sycorax, the witch who ruled the island before Prospero’s arrival. Having promised him on one condition, Prospero tells Ariel that he must follow the rest of his commands and that he will grant…

    • 1243 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is also possible that Ariel is a personification of his inner feelings – a want to be free from the strict Elizabethan theatre but stuck with completing all his task first. More importantly, power derived from “books” accentuate Shakespeare’s power in writing. Hence, the mention of “charms are all o’erthrown” in the epilogue finalises the end of his writing career and marks the end of his writing magic because his has given up on them, suggested in the word “o’erthrown”. Perhaps then, Shakespeare wants to show that as Prospero he is ultimately human and his power to write will not go on forever unlike his fantasy characters, marking the end to his final play. Therefore, the comparison between the different kings can show Shakespeare’s difference with his own…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Certainly it could be said that Prospero has created a new society on the island with himself as ruler In The Communist Manifesto Marx comments, “as the repulsiveness of the work increases, the wage decreases” . Indeed, although Caliban and Ariel do not receive monetary payment for their labour, Ariel is given the incentive of freedom as Prospero promises Ariel “I will discharge thee.” Once again Shakespeare employs the use of personal pronouns in Prospero’s speech in order to emphasise his position of power on the island. It is not Ariel and Caliban who decide their own actions but Prospero. Ariel’s freedom relies entirely on his obedience; as Andrew Ross writes, “labor practices not only constrain workers but do so while claiming to liberate them to do what they love.”…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The play, The Tempest is one of the many texts which allegorically represents various aspects of colonial oppression. The Tempest resonates with unusual power and variety. Prospero’s supreme control over the island and over the spirits of the island symbolizes his imperialistic nature within the play. Shakespeare presents the issue of imperialism through the character, Prospero as he has dominant power and control over the island and the original inhabitants. Parteni defines imperialism as “the process whereby the dominant political-economic interest of one nation controls other peoples’ land and goods for their own enrichment” (2005) and this can be seen in the tempest as Prospero uses his language and power to imperialize the original inhabitants…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It presents the theme supernatural in all the ways that people believe in the supernatural. Included in this show are spirits, witches, and the undead. In The Tempest, Ariel is a spirit who is mischievous in his own right. He is controlled by Prospero just as the characters Vanessa Ives and Kaetenay control spirits or are affected by them. The characters Hecate and Evelyn Poole are evil witches just as the character in The Tempest,…

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays