Analysis Of The Article 'College Women: Stop Getting Drunk'

Improved Essays
In the article “College Women: Stop Getting Drunk,” Emily Yoffe from Slate primarily focuses on the story of female students being exposed to potential sexual assault as a consequence of alcohol drinking. However, former colleague of Emily Yoffe strongly argues in the article “To Prevent Rape of College Campuses, Focus on the Rapist, Not the Victims,” Amanda Hess agrees some of the ideas from Yoffe, but she opposes that female college students is not the one who should be careful about sexual assault due to the overdose of alcohol. Hess points out that college should focus on the male student who is primary threats to the plastered girl to prevent a potential threat of sexual assault by strongly punishing and controlling them in college campuses. …show more content…
Friedman refutes the Yoffe’s idea and she notes that “young men are getting a distorted message that their right to match each other drink for drink is proof of their masculinity. The real…best interests at heart” (Friedman). She believes that the most of the sexual assault were occurred by the boy’s masculinity, not the girl. Their distorted message in their mind is affecting their heart’s decision making skill. There are arguments around this issue whether who is getting a distorted message. Also, Hess backs up the idea of that boys are the one who is responsible for it. However, she is more on the side of college campuses that they are not taking care of the rapist. She states that alcohol in college campuses “is a symbolic proxy for high status on campus do” (Hess). She pointed out that college campuses’ drinking traditional is the real problem and college campuses are the one responsible for it. All three authors have identified an issue and who is more responsible for it. However, blaming one specific person does not resolve the …show more content…
All three authors have provided their ideas to stop the problem in college campuses. However, it leaves an argument because most of the ideas they have provided had their perspective which doesn’t fulfill all sides. Yoffe believes that the college girl has to stop drinking an alcohol because they do not metabolize like the men and “it’s her [daughter] responsibility to take steps to protect herself” (Yoffe). However, there is an argument about this because making women to stop drinking does not resolve the problem, since there are many potential drunk rapist. Former colleague of Yoffe, Hess points out, stopping young female college students to stop drinking does not resolves the problem. She believes that “rape is societal problem, not a self-help issue. Parents can tell their own daughter not to get drunk… it won’t keep other people’s daughters safe” (Hess). She strongly argues that it is not going to change because there are other many college girls whom might not stop drinking an alcohol. Therefore, Hess proposed a different option than Yoffe, “colleges can start changing those structures by refusing to put the onus on victims to prevent their own assaults and instead holding perpetrators accountable for the crimes….. while drunk” (Hess). She believe that unless there are perpetrators in the campus, it wouldn’t resolve the

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Campus Rape Essay

    • 1558 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Many universities constantly do not report any sexual assaults that do happen on campus and they tend to discreetly look the other way. Universities have so much to lose - federal funding and prestige- if they were to say that their campus has a rape problem, so instead the universities falsely report statistics made or even blame the victim for the assault that took place; keeping the sexual assaults quiet. For the most part colleges try to take action into their own hands and doing a petty job at doing so, especially because they are not qualified in handling these situations. So if college campuses do not tend to take action right away or in any effective way, why not just go to the police? One of the main reasons why sexual assault victims typically do not go to the authorities is because they do not want anyone to know.…

    • 1558 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wanted Poster Analysis

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages

    For example, in Time’s article “Why Victims of Rape in College Don’t Report to the Police” Gray interviews a victim who states, “When I reported violence to my school, I was told not to go to the police. But I never would have told [the school] if I knew I was going to be forced into that option”(Gray 1). This demonstrates how not only are crimes being committed against these people, but also how they are encouraged by authorities not to seek justice. In addition to forcing the victim to live in fear of becoming a victim once again, this sentiment also allows a criminal to walk free with no punishment or justice. There are no words to describe how destructive this sentiment is, by promoting silence, this attitude allows the criminal to commit the crime repeatedly until someone is brave enough to report the…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How would you feel if you were being sexually assaulted? One in four women are sexually assaulted in college. The definition of rape from The Free Dictionary is, “The crime using force or the threat of force to compel a person to submit to sexual intercourse, sexual penetration, or any other unlawful sexual intercourse or penetration, as with an unconscious person, or a person below the age or incapable of consent.” (The Free Dictionary.) People need to realize that their actions have reactions. Democratic Assemblyman, Das Williams stated, “I think when there is more accountability, there will be more thought by the perpetrators about whether they are going to endanger their education by engaging in this brutal behavior.” Colleges and universities…

    • 1498 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    College Rape Essay

    • 1163 Words
    • 5 Pages

    It saddens me that women are living in a world where they aren’t heard, or rape cases aren’t considered a “serious crime,” especially when rape occurs to college students. Raising awareness of rape on college campuses should be a priority especially if the administrators are failing to do their jobs with handling reports. Every case should be reported and every case should be heard. Reporting your can save another student from assault by the same offender. Don’t feed into the silent epidemic that continues to…

    • 1163 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    However, others believe that guns not being actively used as a defence against crimes need to be locked up (Kleck 1462). Additionally, a study done on 2500 American adults shows “94 % did not think regular citizens should be allowed to carry guns on college campuses” (Patten, Thomas, Wada 552). This survey doesn’t pertain specifically to students, but it does show that an overwhelming majority does not want non students to have the right to carry while they are on campuses. Studies on students show that “both graduate students and international students are particularly vulnerable to mental health problems due in large part to their increased levels of stress” (Fox and Savage 1475). In a 318 student survey at…

    • 1564 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The transition into college life comes with different experiences and other than academic exposes, students’ get involved in alcohol consumption. Ultimately, Robin Wilson’s article aims to answer “why colleges don’t talk about alcohol’s role in sex assaults.” The writer reveals the sensitivity of the issue, administrators fear of blame, the students’ perspective and sexual assault prevention programs that do not focus fully on alcohol as a proximal cause of sexual assault. Moreover, he highlights administrators’ obligation to prevent sexual assault occurrences and “promptly and fairly, penalize” perpetrators. The write indicates that though statistics show that “half of students involved in alleged sexual assaults’’ used alcohol, college administrators…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This reasoning still stands valid because in fact, it can be debated that the reason many teenagers drink illegally is because of the concept of rebellion. By lowering the drinking age, less and less young adults will have the urge to drink. In a News Weekly article, Jeffrey A. Tucker made a claim that “The drinking-age law would surely be a winner in a competition for the least obeyed law. The notion that this law is accomplishing anything to actually stop or even curb teen drinking is preposterous. Instead, we see all the unintended effects of Prohibition: over-indulgence, anti-social behavior, disrespect for the law, secrecy and sneaking and a massive diversion of human energy.” It is very common amount college students to consume alcohol for social gatherings even if that student is under the age of twenty-one.…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many gun right activists like the National Rifle Association claim that college campuses would be a lot more impervious if students were able to be armed during school hours. This claim defeats the idea that college campuses are already safe. Since anyone who wanted to would be able to carry a gun, a question of how would police or school officers, who are trained to use said firearms, supposed to be taken seriously arises? A study done by the Department of Justice showed that ninety-three percent of violent crimes that occur among college students occur off campus. Guns are not a safer alternative to protect us from the bad things that happen to us in life.…

    • 1116 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Therefore, allowing concealed weapons on a college campus would be a grave mistake with deadly consequences. College’s should not allow students to carry concealed firearms because the presence of deadly weapons only increased the likelihood that there is an incident of violence. On nearly…

    • 1042 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The pregnant girl shouldnt have had sex and this wouldnt have happened and the parents shold have been more strict, but to what fault is the fetus? The baby is not at fault and therfore it should not be the one to have to pay for the consequences. Meanwhile teenagers are not those only women getting abortions but there is also rape victims. Rape is very serious and shameful for the victims who tend to carry it with them for the rest of their lives. Unfortanley in some cases the women becomes pregnant from her attacker and can choose to look at it one of two ways.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays