Analysis Of Paul Kalanithi's Story 'When Breath Becomes Air'

Superior Essays
In When Breath Becomes Air, Paul Kalanithi was a prominent neurosurgeon that had been diagnosed with cancer. Forced to face mortality, Kalanithi’s life changed completely. Initially, when he found out about his illness, he did not have the intentions to carry on with his career and life. However, with the help of his family and friends, Kalanithi decided that he wanted to pursue his life and strive. In Kalanithi’s story, family relations and the doctor-patient relationship played an important role because those relationships provided Kalanithi support throughout his illness and shaped him into an extraordinary doctor. In When Breath Becomes Air, the first family member Kalanithi introduced to readers was his wife, Lucy. Before his heartbreaking …show more content…
Not only did they help Kalanithi be strong, his family also played an important role in shaping Kalanithi into an incredible surgeon. Kalanithi’s mother was very invested in her son’s education and his father was a cardiologist with a private practice. Although Kalanithi’s father was largely absent throughout the story, he was there for him when he got sick. For instance, Katy mentioned that Kalanithi’s father would often rub his son’s feet (Kalanithi 218). However, Kalanithi’s mother played a big part in Kalanithi’s life when he was younger. His mother was intent on providing Kalanithi the best education and life. Kalanithi described his mother, “In her quest to see that her children were educated, my mom drove more than a hundred miles north, to the nearest big city, Las Vegas, so we could take out PSATs, SATs, and ACTs. She joined the school board, rallied teachers, and demanded that AP classes be added to the curriculum” (Kalanithi 27). With the help of his mother, Kalanithi had the leading foundation to become extraordinary. Not only did his family play a prominent role in shaping Kalanithi into an extraordinary doctor, they went out of their way to provide Kalanithi with all the support he needed. Lucy explains, “Both of us drew strength from Paul’s family, who bolstered us as we weathered his illness and supported us in bringing our own child into the family. Despite stunning grief over their …show more content…
Not only did his illness bring his family closer, but it shaped him into an extraordinary doctor. When Breath Becomes Air was a beautifully written story that touched me deeply. As a doctor and patient, Kalanithi had the ability to make strong doctor-patient connections, but as a writer, he was able to connect to readers on a whole different level. His story and the way he portrayed it was powerful enough to touch readers. With his rhythmic words, you learn about Kalanithi and his family, and you can’t help but feel like you know them personally. The story also opened your eyes up to death and revealed that anyone could be next. Ultimately, When Breath Becomes Air was a marvelous story about the truths of life, death, and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Our Time Is Up Analysis

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages

    What did he do, he let go his pinned up sentiments that he was holding on to; with himself and his patients. Facing the truth of his own demise, he understood life was too short for such insignificant phobias that was holding them back from living life. The turning point was that he held the key the entire time to help them. Now that time for him was running out and his life was dwindling; he made a conscious effort to really help his patients.…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Paul Kalanithi’s memoir When Breath Becomes Air, he teaches the reader that although time is limited and death is inevitable, life can still be meaningful and have a purpose, even if it is as simple as helping an individual find the strength to overcome whatever hardships they may be forced to face.…

    • 1155 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He was prejudiced on his first patient in medical school. To cover up his illness, the patients wore punctilious clothes, but Vaughn instantly noticed the disguise. He felt nothing, but pity when he first saw him. The man had AIDS, as a result, it caused opportunistic infections such as Pneumocystis pneumonia, cytomegalovirus, and Kaposi’s sarcoma. Vaughn was inexperienced and acted purely all business, no feelings involved when he examined the man. The patient noticed it and was mad due to him being insensitive. Vaughn thought, “Hey, pal, don’t blame me. You got yourself in this mess. I’m just trying to help.” The man is being devoured by his disease and Vaughn only saw his outward appearance and diagnosis. Vaughn did not know how to react and felt like a fool because he had no clue how to help him. The man’s room is void of life and not a single get-well card can be seen or any signs of visitors. Vaughn asked him what is his job and Vaughn found to that he worked in computer networking. The patient was depressed, because he wasn’t able “to finish his design for a new audiovisual coupling technique before he died.” It was his last opportunity to leave his mark on the earth that signify that he was alive. His parents were supportive of him being gay and proposed to take care of him during his disease. Not wanting to trouble and create stress for his mom, he did not contact her during his hospitalization. Vaughn was tormented and…

    • 1306 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In "When Breath Becomes Air", Paul Kalanithi uses his experiences as a doctor to convey…

    • 1469 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The doctors always ask her questions such as, “Am I going to fast?” (Edson 3) or “Do you think you can be very tough?” (Edson 6) which confirms they may not believe she can handle what they are telling her. Vivian states, “They read me like a book” (Edson 23) which demonstrates her feeling a loss of respect since she is only viewed as research by the doctors. This results in her feeling a loss in her identity as a professor. A supporting article “The Role Of Identity in Adjustment Among Survivors of Oesophageal Cancer (English)” by Ceara Clarke, Noleen McCorry, and Martin Dempter, discusses a form of cancer different that Vivian’s, but it still supports the argument that identity change is common among cancer patients. These survivors felt “tensions between former roles and new identities” (Clarke et al. 102) and “altered familial and societal roles” (Clarke et al. 105) which can be applied to what Vivian experienced, as well. This can relate to Vivian’s tensions between her former self as a professor and the new her as a student. In her earlier life, she was always the one in charge – the one doing the examinations. Now, she is the object of study, the student, and the research. The relationship…

    • 1576 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After living through everything life has thrown at him, a man is diagnosed with stage four brain cancer. He only has months left to live. Although those months will be filled with constant agony, he must suffer through them. His family must suffer through it. Instead of welcoming the end of life in peace, he will be immobile and uncommunicative. It will be a terrible process leaving everyone involved distressed.…

    • 1516 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Drs. Groopman and Hartzband assert that each of has an unique approach to evaluating the risks and benefits of treatments; Dr. Harpham writes that patients diagnosed with life-threatening diseases can live life to the fullest even while overcoming disease through her three pronged approach of knowledge, action, and hope. Although both books strive to ensure that patients are happy in their road to recovery, Your Medical Mind helps patients make rational decisions that serve them best while Happiness in a Storm takes an emotional approach to inspire those battling disease to become Healthy Survivors, defined as those who “can get good care and live as fully as possible” (Harpham 25).…

    • 1600 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    He cheerfully greeted us despite the fact that we had to interrupt his deep sleep. His surrounding looked different from yesterday, above the pole with the medicines hanging were big colorful balloons with the words “Get well soon.” Additionally, a beautiful bouquet of flowers was in the night stand with friend and family’s cards. The balloons and the flowers gave life to the room creating a positive environmental energy field that influence the patient’s own energy field and also of those that came in contact with it. The first thing, he said was “Hi there, how are you this beautiful morning.” “My kids and some family members came by yesterday night to see me” he continued with a joyful voice that echo throughout the room to the other patient’s ears. It is wonderful to see how a change in the environmental field can modify the human field drastically lifting the person’s spirit to its…

    • 1589 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brain On Fire Summary

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Dr. Najjar started an aggressive treatment plan to hopefully reverse the effects of the disease. Cahalan created a baseline to grow from by doing simple tasks like drawing a clock and writing in a daily journal. In the book there is a recreation of the clock she drew while ill and the reader gets the chance to visualize how strenuous and gruesome her disease was. Cahalan also provides images of her journal entries while staying at the hospital, the reader can see how some entries are crossed out because Cahalan changed her mind and felt different.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When I made my Audience Analysis I found out that 70% of us has had a love one diagnose with cancer, and 71% of us lose their love one to cancer. Today I want to tell you the story of my Grandfather. When I was 9 years old my Grandfather was diagnose with Lymphoma of Hodgkin. I firsthand experience and saw how cancer can physically and mentally destroy a person and their love ones. Over the next four years my Grandfather fought cancer, and initially my Grandfather defeated cancer. Nevertheless his fight against cancer was far from over, one year later his cancer comeback stronger than ever and after a six months battle my Grandfather lose his life.…

    • 1599 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The role of doctors in both the treatment of cancer patients and their families plays a critical role in helping both the patient and their family deal with the stress, burden, and, in some cases, grief during and after treatment. This is evident in Jerome Groopman’s novel, The Measure of Our Days, especially in the story of Matt. Throughout this story, Groopman demonstrates this role, as both he and Dr. Samuels give Billy hope during Matt’s cancer treatments, and aid him in accepting Matt’s inevitable death.…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Life, a beautiful lie that everyone wants to believe lasts forever. Death, a certain ugly truth that no one wants to believe actually exists, because with death, there is pain. Not just pain for the sick, but a pain left unbearable for the survivors. Anita Moorjani, a woman who has experienced both, and shares her story with the world. In her book, “Dying to Be Me,” Anita discusses her life before cancer, during cancer, and death after cancer. Isn’t it hard to believe that one could come back from such a thing as the hands of death? For someone to go from cold and lifeless, back to warm and glowing? In a seemingly “impossible” way, Anita escaped these hands that gripped her. She is now able to live her life cancer free.…

    • 1109 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Atul Gawande Summary

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Atul Gawande explores the difficult situation that doctors face when their patients are near death. Dr. Gawande wants to learn from his mistakes as he feels guilty that he reduced his patient’s limited lifespan. He had had good intentions to attempt to cure his patient’s lung cancer through treatment, but instead worsen the condition. Gawande knew that treatments had a less than five percent chance to cure lung cancer, but he was not honest with his patient trying and maintaining hope. Unfortunately, Gawande’s patient passed away in the hospital with the regret of not spending her final moments with her family. Gawande was trained to save lives, and when his patient died, he felt like a failure. Gawande decided to interview doctors on…

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his autobiography, When Breath Becomes Air, Paul Kalanithi explains his thoughts, feelings, and situations through descriptive analogies in order to demonstrate the evolution of his perspective on the importance of doctor patient relationships. He found himself struggling to separate his patients from the paperwork, but at times, the toll of emotions made it clear how much of an impact he had on so many people’s lives: “Some days this is how I felt when I was in the hospital: trapped in the endless jungle summer, wet with sweat, the rain of tears of the families of the dying pouring down” (Kalanithi 78). Suggesting their tears are the rain pouring down on him as he is the outsider, readers understand the reasons most doctors choose to resort to detachment, and the difficulty Kalanithi faces going against this…

    • 1606 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As what Dr.Kalanithi questioned in When Breath Becomes Air, the true meaning of life is what everyone will discover and pursue for their whole life. When Breath Becomes Air is the memoir of Paul Kalanithi, a brilliant neurosurgeon and a thoughtful soul, who was diagnosed with terminal lung cancer at his age of 36. This book is written at the period Paul Kalanithi fought against with his cancer bravely and positively. The first part of the book mainly narrates why he chose to become a neurosurgeon and how he grew up on his career path. Influenced by his family and his exploration of life and death, he went to the medical school after achieving the degree of literature.…

    • 1261 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays