John Dewey's Response To Zuriff

Improved Essays
I. John Dewey’s response to Zuriff Learners do not require a special treatment, but instead, they need to be actively exposed to experimentation (Dewey, 1968). This is because, according to Dewey (1986), the experimentation method does not follow the old education system which is based on the built of a ready-made process, and instead is developed by discovering knowledge on experience (Dewey, 1968).
II. John Dewey’s response to Terzi
Dewey would respond by supporting the argument of Terzi in that equality should be the term that governs the progression of skills (Dewey, 1968). This is because Dewey supports equality because it erases prejudices and outcomes of distinctions made unjustly (Dewey, 1968). Through the application of the principles
…show more content…
This is because, according to Dewey (1986), the experimentation method does not follow the old education system which is based on the built of a ready-made process, and instead is developed on discovering knowledge founded on experience (Dewey, 1968). He objected the need for specialized learning in children since it was derived out of external interests (Dewey, 1968). Dewey’s response would also include that his approach aims to include the school system with the essentials of the society to motivate the values of freedom and discovery (Dewey, 1968). He explains this by saying that schooling should not be based on matters of discrimination so that these children form a balanced and critical-minded society with an improved quality of life experience (Dewey, 1968). Dewey response would also include, that the physical, moral, and intellectual development process of children is a clear example of the principle of continuity (Dewey, 1968). The higher maturity of experience will depend on the educator, as he or she will be able to determine and evaluate the individual’s experience to see where it might lead the children (Dewey, 1968). A system of scientific study should, however, be applied in the education system to ensure that the development of each child is monitored towards the development of required …show more content…
She reciprocates Dewey’s view of education democracy by explaining that democracy is created by teaching and not the other way around (Gutmann & Ben-Porath, 2014). She explains this by quoting that “a democratic state is therefore committed to allocating education authority in such a way as to provide its members with an education adequate to participate in democratic politics” (Gutmann & Ben-Porath, 2014). This quote also proves that Gutmann promotes the idea that education develops political communities, contrary to Dewey’s view. Moreover, Gutmann perceives that guardians and parents are not obligated by the societal values but by the nation’s and education’s principles (Gutmann & Ben-Porath, 2014). These two principles hold parents from curtailing the aspects of child development regarding the conveyance of competing notions (Gutmann & Ben-Porath,

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    John Dewey and Maria Montessori both agreed on the principles of effective education. That is: learning is not from receiving information, children themselves form images by working with materials, learning is like going through life—knowledge earned from working with materials is a physical and psychological change, and learning is through interactions with environment. Even though Montessori was focusing on individual’s skills and development, Dewey was concentrated on group approaches. Both human experiments on education were able to prove that students learn better working with materials on hands, rather than teachers lecturing their knowledge on students.…

    • 95 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Many other voices, like Cora Bigelow, George Counts, and Lewis Terman all had their own important sentiments regarding how education should change in this dynamic time in America. Dewey’s ideas have shaped much of the education system that we have today. However, the reforms that occurred during…

    • 1080 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The video Differentiated Instruction in the Classroom at Mesquite Elementary School related to my understanding of Dewey reading by electing to make a change. Mrs. Erikson the founding principal wanted to make a modification since the students were not learning the information presented to them. Based on “The consecutive low state test scores” the staff realized the needed to make a change the way the students were being educated (Edutopia, 2011). Instead, of the staff members continuing to use the same teaching approach they comprehended that it was time to reflect and examine their approach.…

    • 403 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Education is an important part of any child’s life, whether they know it or not. A woman named Maria Montessori has her own philosophy on how education should be. There is another person who has views on education, Colin Powell. Powell believes that structure is the main basis for good education. These two don’t agree on their educational beliefs, and these examples will explain why.…

    • 1098 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I have a book that 's called as Really important stuff my kids have taught me. This is a hand-sized book written by Cynthia L. Copeland, encompassing a multitude of children sayings that are full of sharp-witted common sense. Children perceive the world without any unnecessary complications, hence, their simple but sensible perceptions can always afford grown-ups food for thought by opening up a mind-refreshing perspective. The book reminds me to keep growing yet always keep things simply.…

    • 1557 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    There is another aspect of education that Dewey also considered to be very important, education is a “mode of associated living, or conjunct, communicated experience” (Dewey). Educational institutions are one of the cultural institutions set up to imbue children with the social and cultural norms, values, symbols, and mental maps of reality (Guest, 2014, pp. 36). The other job of education is to teach children how to be Americans and to prepare them for what life will be like outside of school. Thus, Dewey’s two reasons for education are to ensure that citizens can elect the…

    • 1985 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    John Dewey argues against William James' theory by saying that Dewey believes that emotions are experiences in which our emotions are directed toward the environment (84-85). Too, he argues that out bodily responses are needed as a way to deal with the emotion (85) and to relieve that sensation (86). Dewey mentions how he does not grasp why sounds such as laughter should be emitted while responding to an emotion (86). Too, laughing does not always insinuate that something is funny, but a laugh could also be a response to feeling nervous (86). These actions occur to satisfy that particular emotions but things such as heart palpitations, heavy breathing, etc.…

    • 329 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Midterm Exam – The Child and the Curriculum John Dewey’s The Child and the Curriculum, written over a century ago, poses a question that can still prove relevant to teachers in this day and age. His primary question that he attempts to tackle in his paper, is simple: should education be tailored to a child’s specific needs, or to a set curriculum? Throughout the paper, he argues that the tug of war between child and curriculum is ultimately futile; choosing one over the other will still prove detrimental. Ultimately, Dewey says “all depends upon the activity which the mind itself undergoes in responding to what is presented from without” (Dewey, 1906, p.39). In other words, Dewey believes that experience is the key to learning, and the ideal curriculum should focus on…

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Critical democratic pedagogies understand educative or learning processes as a continuous, two-way, dialectic process. These processes are constructed around the personal experiences of the students and allow critical thinking and action. All that, in order to help students grow (Drinkwater, 2014). This kind of pedagogies give students the opportunity to speak out and be heard. That means too that student’s previous experiences and interest are taken into account in the classroom for their on-going development (Dewey, 1938).…

    • 345 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In this regard, to what means do we rectify this injustice? Dewey and Emerson argue that the upheaval and reorganization of this systems is the method needed for reformation, if we are certain of our determination to maintain the functioning of our democratic society. Prose calls for a return to classical studies, while focusing less on the burdens of political correctness. And while these all present valid plans for educational improvement, they fail to account for the core driving force behind human innovation, the source of creativity in its…

    • 1606 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, the restriction of the child prevents him from following his desires, which are good. So Dewey states that knowing what is right is taught by guidance and self reflection. Dewey also states that we cannot treat everyone the same due to the differing relationships between each other. Here it becomes evident that you cannot aim to help and please everyone, but rather you must choose who to help in singular…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Philosophy for Children is a representation of John Dewey’s educational theory put into action written by Matthew Lipman, Gareth Matthews and Kieran Egan. The unified goal of the Philosophy for Children is to fill classrooms with transformed students who have learned to self-correct through dialogue and self-reflection. This transformation is done through conversation, discovery and understanding through the power of dialogue. In order to transform the classroom into a self-corrective environment, a Socratic model must be followed. Socratic model stems from Socrates’ beliefs that reinforce his philosophy of dialogue.…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    It is hard to define what liberalism truly meant. On the surface, to be liberal was to be progressive, forward thinking, actively championing for civil liberties as well as the freedom of the individual. Dewey himself is of the opinion that the idea of liberalism has been distorted; it has become far too individualistic and lost its meaning. Dewey is against the ‘individualism’ espoused by liberalists’ theories. Choosing instead to subscribe to organic philosophy where the intrinsic relationship between society and the individual is emphasized upon, Dewey is adamant that liberalism can be achieved with the aid of social institutions that help shape us, rather than the misguided ahistorical notions of liberalism that classical liberalists have…

    • 1730 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Dewey believed in child-centered approach, he thought children should be allowed to explore their environment, it initiates them to learn through their spontaneous. However, he was alarmed by the excesses of “child-centered” education. He argued that too much reliance on the child could be equally detrimental to the learning process. (Rhalmi, 2011) Therefore the teacher is also important to the children’s development.…

    • 1688 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During this time many theorist voiced their opinion, the most significant of all was John Dewey. He was the one who changed the fundamental approaches of teaching and learning in schools. He based his theory in a more practical realistic skills, revolving around an…

    • 539 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays